I am confused Hendrikkim,
You stated you were accepted by USMA LAST October, but are curious about AROTC THIS October. Did you turn it down last yr and now are trying for an IS?
Or did you mean you have been accepted to USMA this PAST October?
Last yr your question came up, and there were various responses. The question was posed differently, and it was if I don't get USMA, and the mass mailing comes after the last board will there be a board just for those that didn't get USMA?
Overall, people said yes, but that the numbers would be very few reviewed and offered the scholarship. Mainly due to the fact that many would have accepted the scholarships already and there would be no room left at certain colleges.
From the gist that I got they do indeed "talk", which is unlike their sister branches.
You can wonder about it all day, but the fact is; whatever they do it is how they do it. They are not going to give you their super secret handshake code to ease your mind. Even knowing how they do it will not calm your nerves, because once you know, than you think of the next big hurdle. Ignorance can be bliss.
It is frustrating beyond belief, but in 9 months from now, none of that will matter.