Okay, time out here.
I get the stress, but as a BGO I think you know the waiver process. You probably have much more insight than anyone here.
~ No where did I see MMAkid19 say they were an expert.
~~ My opinion was he was saying that your DD is at the tippy top. Nothing more.
If she was not your DD, what would be your response as a BGO to a candidate that had the same stats? My guess is this:
DoDMERB DQs, and SA waives, it is a case by case scenario.
~ You are asking kp2001 to make/state a chance without ever seeing her medical records or her career field aspirations.
Just my opinion, but I kind of agree with MMA19kid. Nobody here knows what this years application/candidate roles will be from a number perspective. You have to know as a BGO, that waivers when times are good are easier than when times are bad. You state she is being recruited, and that is an edge, but what is her true career goal? Is her true to desire to serve in the Navy? What happens if USMMA does waive and the Navy doesn't? Where does that leave her 4 years later from her HS graduation when she is about to graduate from USMMA and USNA says NOPE ?!?
Finally, and I am ready to be flamed...I expect more professionally from a BGO than flaming someone publicly, especially a kid that is what 18 at USMMA?
~ The kid just stated his opinion.
~ You are what late 40s, maybe in your 50s?
I know you are a new poster, my advice is if you only want a specific poster to respond to your specific needs, than pm them and take it out of the forums. Placing it publicly means anyone, including me can reply with our own opinions.
I wish her and your family great success and luck.
I understand that intonation cannot be determined via these forums. I hope that your quote of "expert" opinion was just me not understanding your intonation.