Your son/daughter goes where???

In the sad but sometimes happens category:

A woman whom I have known casually for years was discussing my sons, not knowing I was just beyond her sightline across the room (and I couldn't leave so it wasn't my fault!). I overheard her saying that while "yes, those <insert name> kids are smart enough, their parents were so cheap they refused to send them to college, so they went into the Air Force."

Had it not been for two full inches of plexiglass separating us, I'd have bopped her in the kisser myself.


:hammer:

Oh my goodness.... I am laughing so hard I nearly fell of the chair. Thank you for that one. My vote is for you to win the thread posts so far!
 
In the sad but sometimes happens category:

A woman whom I have known casually for years was discussing my sons, not knowing I was just beyond her sightline across the room (and I couldn't leave so it wasn't my fault!). I overheard her saying that while "yes, those <insert name> kids are smart enough, their parents were so cheap they refused to send them to college, so they went into the Air Force."

Had it not been for two full inches of plexiglass separating us, I'd have bopped her in the kisser myself.


:hammer:
If someone said this to me I'd have gone through the plexiglass.
 
A classmate asked me:
"You're going for a pilot slot right? Why do you need to workout? Why do pilots need to be in shape?"
A question that is ridiculous to us, but for some reason made sense to him

Take a gander at GEN Breedlove and some of the others in the AF pilot community. The question asked isn't as silly as you like to think.

That's why there's velcro on the side of flight suits, yeah?
 
Ok. I posted this time last year but recently heard another doozie a while ago from a relative on DS#2's USAFA appointment c/2018.

My wife...."he will be studying civil engineering at the Air Force Academy."
Confused-looking relative.."you can't get a college degree in the Air Force."
My wife...."yes you can and it's top -tier engineering and science school."
Really confused-looking relative....no response

DS3 is heading to USMA in June...can't wait to post and share again....
 
Got this from MIL last weekend:

MIL: He's happy at West Point?

Me: Yep, still loves it.

MIL: He had other choices, didn't he?

Me <in my head>: Too bad MIL is not a choice.
 
It's really sad when high school administrators don't get it. My son's ALO wants to present his certificate to him at the senior awards assembly and recognize him for receiving his appointment and the school admin's response is, "Why? It's not really a scholarship." I'm dumbfounded.
 
This is an ancient nugget, but one that still makes me smile.

One of my mother's friends, a traditional grand older Southern lady, said upon hearing I had graduated from college, and after a competitive selection, was headed to Navy Officer Candidate School and a commission: (1) You're supposed to marry one of those boys, not be one. (2) Won't handling those ropes in the open air ruin her complexion and her hands? (3) What a waste of her college education. She could have found a nice job as a bank secretary and met a suitable husband. (absolutely hilarious to see the unintended irony of that statement)
 
It's really sad when high school administrators don't get it. My son's ALO wants to present his certificate to him at the senior awards assembly and recognize him for receiving his appointment and the school admin's response is, "Why? It's not really a scholarship." I'm dumbfounded.
That's the same at my DD's school. The ALO wants to make a presentation and has been turned down as it's nothing out of the ordinary. She is the first student in the school's history to be appointed to any Service Academy. I don't think they understand what a feather in their hat this is, and how it can inspire more kids to seek appointments. Oh, well. Such is life. Congrats to your son.
 
That's the same at my DD's school. The ALO wants to make a presentation and has been turned down as it's nothing out of the ordinary. She is the first student in the school's history to be appointed to any Service Academy. I don't think they understand what a feather in their hat this is, and how it can inspire more kids to seek appointments. Oh, well. Such is life. Congrats to your son.

That is a shame. After everything your DD has worked for and now achieved, she deserves a little recognition. I think it can inspire more high performing kids to think about the SA's as an alternative. We are fortunate that DS's administration gets it. They are thrilled with his appointment. I hope you have an opportunity to fight for your DD, she deserves it. Good Luck!
 
"Dear Head of School System (state, district, whatever),

I am a senior at Acme High, in Acmevillle, and I wanted to express my appreciation for the quality of education I received there over the last X years. In particular, I wanted to single out Ms. Jones and Mr. Smith, as teachers who were particularly (good things), and the AP program....(whatever)

The Acme education was a critical building block in my successful two-year campaign to obtain an appointment to USXA, Class of 2020, which required me to compete against the top scholar-athletes in our state for a nomination. Congressman Z chose me to receive his nomination, and the competitive process continued. Over ?? thousand applications are received annually at USXA, with a class of approximately 1200 successfully obtaining an appointment. I have attached a class profile from the Class of 2019, which shows the caliber of students on a national level attending USXA. I have also included a copy of (maybe something from USXA.edu that talks about competition, caliber of applicants, something impressive) to illuminate the special opportunity I am being offered.

I am humbled and honored to receive an appointment to a prestigious service academy, where my education will be provided to me at an estimated cost of $____, and I will have the honor of serving our country immediately after graduation as a commissioned officer in the (Service.)

I was required to have top-tier grades in demanding classes, deliver impressive test scores, demonstrate athletic ability, leadership and community involvement, pass a physical strength test, and excel in ___ interviews, to compete for my nomination and then for an appointment. My Acme education was a large contributor, and I am grateful.

As the first student at Acme to receive one of these highly-sought after appointments/as one of the handful of students in our state to..., I was saddened to learn that Acme does not plan to acknowledge this accomplishment at our awards ceremony on (date.) I understand that school policy does not allow it, but sending a student to a Service Academy reflects positively on Acme's quality of education, and can serve as an inspiration to other students to apply for this extraordinary opportunity. I think the singular value of this appointment, and the fact it leads to service to the nation, after a grueling competitive process, would merit consideration for an exception. Would you be willing to reconsider this policy?

Thank you.

Sincerely,
Student Appointee"




Just a thought. It might make you/parents feel better, and I think there is always power in the written word. For an evil twist, copy the Senator or Congressmen from whom nomination(s) were received (if applicable).
 
Last edited:
Great letter Capt MJ. My only suggestion is to add something about earning a BS degree in that third paragraph to counteract the tendencies of the "Your kid went where?" thread (or whatever name it was).

EDIT: Oh! We're on that thread!!! Duhhhhhh.
 
"Dear Head of School System (state, district, whatever),

I am a senior at Acme High, in Acmevillle, and I wanted to express my appreciation for the quality of education I received there over the last X years. In particular, I wanted to single out Ms. Jones and Mr. Smith, as teachers who were particularly (good things), and the AP program....(whatever)

The Acme education was a critical building block in my successful two-year campaign to obtain an appointment to USXA, Class of 2020, which required me to compete against the top scholar-athletes in our state for a nomination. Congressman Z chose me to receive his nomination, and the competitive process continued. Over ?? thousand applications are received annually at USXA, with a class of approximately 1200 successfully obtaining an appointment. I have attached a class profile from the Class of 2019, which shows the caliber of students on a national level attending USXA. I have also included a copy of (maybe something from USXA.edu that talks about competition, caliber of applicants, something impressive) to illuminate the special opportunity I am being offered.

I am humbled and honored to receive an appointment to a prestigious service academy, where my education will be provided to me at an estimated cost of $____, and I will have the honor of serving our country immediately after graduation as a commissioned officer in the (Service.)

I was required to have top-tier grades in demanding classes, deliver impressive test scores, demonstrate athletic ability, leadership and community involvement, pass a physical strength test, and excel in ___ interviews, to compete for my nomination and then for an appointment. My Acme education was a large contributor, and I am grateful.

As the first student at Acme to receive one of these highly-sought after appointments/as one of the handful of students in our state to..., I was saddened to learn that Acme does not plan to acknowledge this accomplishment at our awards ceremony on (date.) I understand that school policy does not allow it, but sending a student to a Service Academy reflects positively on Acme's quality of education, and can serve as an inspiration to other students to apply for this extraordinary opportunity. I think the singular value of this appointment, and the fact it leads to service to the nation, after a grueling competitive process, would merit consideration for an exception. Would you be willing to reconsider this policy?

Thank you.

Sincerely,
Student Appointee"




Just a thought. It might make you/parents feel better, and I think there is always power in the written word. For an evil twist, copy the Senator or Congressmen from whom nomination(s) were received (if applicable).
CAPTMJ, what a great idea. I am very disappointed that I did not think of that myself. I have been talking with the career counselor and she has been great, but never thought to write a letter. I will get on that today and let you all know what happens.
 
CaptMJ, you are not going to believe what just happened. I penned your letter, almost word for word, (great letter BTW). I was doing a spell check and getting ready to send it to the headmaster and the phone rang. It was the career counselor calling to say that she convinced the leadership that the presentation would be good for the student body and provide inspiration to the underclassmen and they will be doing it at the end of year awards in front of the entire student body (all 267 of them). A small victory as common sense prevails. This really is a great thing for this small school. Not to brag, but yes, to brag, out of 44 seniors in my DD class, 8 of them are National Merit Finalists. I think that is a reflection of the quality of education provided at their little charter school. Perhaps we will have more appointees to SAs in the future. Thanks again for the encouragement.
 
CaptMJ, you are not going to believe what just happened. I penned your letter, almost word for word, (great letter BTW). I was doing a spell check and getting ready to send it to the headmaster and the phone rang. It was the career counselor calling to say that she convinced the leadership that the presentation would be good for the student body and provide inspiration to the underclassmen and they will be doing it at the end of year awards in front of the entire student body (all 267 of them). A small victory as common sense prevails. This really is a great thing for this small school. Not to brag, but yes, to brag, out of 44 seniors in my DD class, 8 of them are National Merit Finalists. I think that is a reflection of the quality of education provided at their little charter school. Perhaps we will have more appointees to SAs in the future. Thanks again for the encouragement.

Well, well, karma does exist. Glad to hear.
Now I recommend a TY letter to school, principal, commenting on teachers, guidance counselor, etc. , who were of particular help, and the quality of your "Acme" education overall which played a role in your appointment. That would pay off for future appointees.
 
Me: My top two college choices are the Air Force Academy and the Naval Academy.
Professor: If you change your mind partway through, you may have a hard time finishing your education. A lot of state schools won't accept transfer credits from the "big-name" schools.
Me: o_O
Professor: You also might not be able to get into grad school if other colleges won't accept your Bachelor's Degree.
Me: .....I'll look into that.

No joke, this actually happened. :eek3:
 
Me: My top two college choices are the Air Force Academy and the Naval Academy.
Professor: If you change your mind partway through, you may have a hard time finishing your education. A lot of state schools won't accept transfer credits from the "big-name" schools.
Me: o_O
Professor: You also might not be able to get into grad school if other colleges won't accept your Bachelor's Degree.
Me: .....I'll look into that.

No joke, this actually happened. :eek3:

And the counterpoint...two USNA firsties were at the house last night. One has a lock on the Cambridge scholarship for immediate grad school, and has a chance at the Oxford one. This firstie's older USNA siblings attended Harvard Kennedy School of Govt for Master's, and the other attended Cambridge and also did a Fulbright in Taiwan, finishing two Master's. The other firstie is in play for a Fulbright and another prestigious grad program. The SA's routinely have grads get into a wide array of grad schools, med school - guess those schools didn't get the memo.

And those pesky SA Rhodes Scholars - didn't the selection committee notice where they went to college?

And...these grads went to Oxford, Cambridge, Durham and others.
https://www.usna.edu/Notables/marshall-scholars.php

The quoted post was a good one, in a sad way.
 
CaptMJ, you are not going to believe what just happened. I penned your letter, almost word for word, (great letter BTW). I was doing a spell check and getting ready to send it to the headmaster and the phone rang. It was the career counselor calling to say that she convinced the leadership that the presentation would be good for the student body and provide inspiration to the underclassmen and they will be doing it at the end of year awards in front of the entire student body (all 267 of them). A small victory as common sense prevails. This really is a great thing for this small school. Not to brag, but yes, to brag, out of 44 seniors in my DD class, 8 of them are National Merit Finalists. I think that is a reflection of the quality of education provided at their little charter school. Perhaps we will have more appointees to SAs in the future. Thanks again for the encouragement.

FalconsRock, I would not stop there. If you have a local newspaper, send a picture of your DD along with a statement about where she is about to go-there is nothing like good publicity to make schools take notice of their own accomplishments. Glad it worked out.
 
Why aren't you going to university, you're smart enough to go?

The worst question: So you're enlisting in the military?

So you want to kill people?

Why would you join the Air Force, won't you have to give up like 20 years of your life?
 
Back
Top