... In reality, they WOULD NOT RECOMMEND USNA to any prospective student...
Having two current midshipman, I'm going to challenge this post.
There is certainly no shortage of cynical midshipmen who are dissatisfied with how things operate at the academy. But, to suggest that
most of these midshipmen feel this way and, given the opportunity, would not attend the Naval Academy is completely ... well ... to be blunt - complete BS!
These are tough times in the military. Budget constraints are resulting in certain cutbacks. It is affecting the Naval Academy, as well. Certain training opportunities are being cancelled. There is less leniency for infractions for the midshipmen. The days of second, third and fourth chances are evaporating in favor of a "Strike one, you're out!" policy.
Welcome to the
real world, midshipmen!
Those who are candidates should take this post with a grain-of-salt. It should not discourage you. Most midshipmen with this extremely cynical attitude are struggling in some area; either academically, physically, conduct-wise, honor-wise, or military aptitude. Some realize that they are not going to be competitive for their first choice in Service Selection and cannot adjust to the prospect of their 2nd choice. (i.e. wanted to be a hotshot fighter pilot but will now probably be a division officer on a destroyer.)
PREDICTION: The original poster will probably respond with how well his/her midshipman is doing. He's a real stud and excelling in all areas and
still thinks it is a horrible school to attend.
And yet, that midshipman signed his commitment papers for his 2/C (junior) year. Why? Did he just learn what a horrible institution it was this past year?
The Naval Academy is a great institution but, in many ways, it's like anything else - it is what you make of it. Is it a perfect school? No! There are great opportunities to excel and hone your leadership skills. Or, you can choose to bask in your cynicism and only see the bad.
Whenever there seems to be a completely illogical, random act on the part of the administration (like the example of the punitive action taken against the midshipman who lost "too much weight"), there is usually more to that story that is not being told.
My advice: Continue with your applications. If you've received an appointment - rejoice! You have a golden opportunity placed before you. What you choose to do with that opportunity is up to
you. Don't wait for somebody to inspire or motivate you. Be an instrument of inspiration and self-motivation that is an example to others. That's what a
true leaders is.