My commander plans on telling each FTP their results individually during LLAB. I will assume that she wants to tell those that didn't get EAs first so that they don't need to stay for LLAB.
I honestly think that your detachment's way of presenting EA results is only good if everyone makes it in. While a public announcement of the EAs praises those that got EAs, I think that it publicly humiliates those that didn't get one. If that happened to me it would leave a sour taste in my mouth and I will probably leave the detachment with resentment.
Perhaps individually might be better, but in the end everyone still knows who did and didn't make it. Of course at all Dets if you don't get an EA you arent required to go to LLAB or the AS200 class for the rest of the week, but it's not like you never have to go back there again. You still get an actual grade on your transcript for the AS200 class so you have to start showing up for that again so you don't fail it. Unless of course you decide you can handle an F on your transcript.
I sure would hate to have it announced where those who got EAs go in one room, and those who didn't go in another, and everyone's told that way. If you were in a group that didn't get EAs you'd know that before the cadre member even told you, all you'd have to do is take a look around and see who is in your group. There are ppl for whom it could go either way, but there's always one or two cadets in every class who are for sure not going to make it.
Who knows though, they might do it differently this time. We experienced a turnover with half our cadre this year. Commander is the same, but he's not the one that announces it, the Education Officer does and they're new to the Det. It'll be interesting to say the least.
I sure hope the boards make their final decisions by the end of this week so we can know next week. Otherwise we'll have to contend with over a quarter of the wing (and closer to half of FTP) being out due to crosstown spring breaks the week after next. If that happened I would hope they'd decide then to personally call everyone as opposed to waiting a whole week to tell us all
. My Det is like my second home, I'm always there even on non LLAB days doing work so I chit chat with a lot of the cadre on a regular basis. Idk if I could handle it if they said "Yeah, we have the EA results, we're just waiting til everyone's spring break is over to tell you guys..."
.
Edit:
Alpha,
Follow up question, does your det also not announce rated slots in front of everyone either? We have a big presentation with music and everything. It's a pretty joyous occasion, everyone's really happy for them. I never actually thought about it before, but I suppose there may be ppl who were set on rated from day one that didn't get it and are trying to mask their disappointment while their classmates are busy celebrating the fact that their dreams of flying are still alive. And what about getting AFSC selections? Cadets can find out what job the got before the cadre announces it, but some don't want to look and see so they wait til their called up in LLAB to find out. Usually everyone either gets their 1st or 2nd choice so their happy but every now and then someone gets pulled for an AFSC that they really didn't want. Just an example that you never want to put anything on your AFSC dream sheet that you're not willing to do.
Does anyone know if it's possible to be pulled for an AFSC that you didn't put on your sheet? I know it's needs of the AF, but they usually try to put ppl where they indicate they want to be.