1. I do not think that "hopeful" was being judgmental, only realistic. We live less than an hour away from the Yard, and last year our Plebe came home for every long weekend. The drive back to Annapolis after winter break was done in deafening silence. This year, our Youngster spent Thanksgiving in Florida with another Mid, and frankly was ready to go back to the Yard after a week of being home during winter break. Point is, they grow, and sometimes it is very hard for parents to let go. Sometimes it depends on how much time a child has spent away from home at camps, retreats, etc., in terms of how well they adapt to being away from home. There is no right answer for every situation, other than to follow your child's lead. If someone is homesick, perhaps bi-monthly visits would just exacerbate that, OR if someone is independent, yet close to family, those visits would be a great opportunity to share and catch up (because they really do not have a lot of time during the week to call or email).
2. They are Midshipmen, not cadets. If she's gonna go there, you gotta learn the lingo!!