- Joined
- Jun 8, 2009
- Messages
- 289
I know this is a little off topic and rather esoteric, (I think there is a lawyer on the boards though) but how do constitutional rights apply to military members? Are constitutional rights that conflict with UCMJ (i.e. free speech) the only ones which don't apply to the military, or does UCMJ just completely supersede all civilian rules? For example, are military members subject to searches without a warrant, do they have protection from self incrimination, do they have different second amendment rights, etc. I know some items automatically can't coexist with the rules of UCMJ, but what about the others?
I don't think it matters. Before entering the military you understand that there are certain rules and guidelines you accept, and certain rights you relinquish. Granted, it should be made clear to you what you're getting yourself into.
IN my personal opinion, if you swear an oath to keep the UCMJ. And you subsequently don't keep it, then all the blame falls on you.