I agree that they should serve out their commitment. The fact and reality is they know as a rated candidate in ROTC that this (FC1 physical) is a hurdle that they must clear. An FC1 (Flight Class 1) is not just a military exam, but they need to meet the FAA requirements too. At least this is true for the AF. It may be that they met the standards for color deficiency regarding the Navy's standards, but not the FAAs.
There are many that do not pass that FAA FC1. My DS is an AF pilot commissioned via AFROTC. He was a scholarship cadet that passed his DoDMERB 4 years earlier. 1st day at Wright Pat, they gave to all cadets and EKG. 25% failed the EKG and were than sent for an EEG. Luckily he passed that test. Some didn't.
However, either way because he passed the DoDMERB he would have still had to serve out his commitment, but as a non-rated officer since he passed the DoDMERB. That is how I see this aspect.
I am sorry it happened. Personally, I like the AFROTC path for cadets that get a rated slot. They are informed in the spring of their junior year. During the summer of their rising senior year they are sent to Wright Pat for their FC1. If they are dq'd than come fall they will compete with all of the other non-rated cadets for their career path. This means they know prior to commissioning if they are indeed going rated.
Finally to drive home what NavyHoops was stating about the color deficiency tests, hornetguy here is the AF go to expert explaining the different type of tests. Hornetguy got caught in it. He commissioned in 2010 from USAFA. He has a PPL. He was originally given a waiver for UPT, but because he graduated so high out of USAFA he was offered a 3 year fellowship to RAND. That meant he had to delay UPT. Meanwhile during those 3 years the AF changed the parameters/test and he now was not eligible for a waiver.
Just saying for cadet/mids that got cleared with the DoDMERB for the scholarship or even the exit (ROTC pre-commissioning), to be a pilot you need to pass the FAA too.
If you also say they should be able to walk than answer one question for me. AFROTC is like NROTC, you will go AD upon commissioning and you are basically locked into this as soon as you become a POC. How can you say they should be able to walk? If that flight exam was given in college, the results would be the same. They would be DQd and still have to go non-rated.
Look, the fact is, it is heart breaking for the OP, but their DS knew this was a chance. I do feel for them, because as a parent you are the one that needs to support them when they are feeling at the worst. I suspect the OP is not military or does not fly, and due to that they are in unchartered waters.
jiller59, He will rebound. He just needs time to lick his wounds. In years from now he will look back with no what ifs? He will get that this was his fate and something he had absolute no control over.
~ You might not see this as comfort right now, but there are many UPT students that wash out, and they now live with....IF I just studied one more hour....if I just chair flown a little longer instead of playing XBox....maybe I would be a pilot now. This is not what would ever be on his what IF I list. He will get it.
Your job as a parent is to get him to the point that he went NROTC to become a Navy officer, not just a Navy pilot.
In the AF there is a joke...you know what they call a pilot at UPT? O1! Just like the intel officer or Maintenance. Nobody says Pilot Jiller. They say Ensign Jiller. Great pilots know that without the non-rated officers that airframe would never get off the ground. Crappy ones, well they will be crappy be it in the military or in the corporate world.