Users please read this thread!!!! :)

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm going to second @pixiestudent here. An online internet forum is not obligated in any way to conform to your interpretation of what is helpful, encouraging, and kind - except where the terms of use are concerned. People here are, from what I can tell, very honest. That honesty can be blunt, which is 100 times better than people sugarcoating things or dancing around the issue (trust me on this). If the forum is not giving you what you want/expect, it may be time to find another forum to post on. I suggest reddit or 4chan :sofa: (JUST KIDDING!!) The attitude towards posts on this forum generally depends on the perception of you as a poster. Make sure you check your tone/writing to be sure it comes across humble and wanting to learn. I have only had positive responses on the forum - indicative of the graciousness of these very knowledgeable people who put up with us young and naive people. JMHO
 
As many of you may know, these forums are used to help high schoolers gain admission to the service academies. It is not an area in which people need not to be chided upon, but need questions answered. I personally have asked many questions, but have not gotten general answers, but more of criticism that was not constructive. I think these forums need to cater more to the needs of applicants and less to the liking of the advisors and parents.

I think in some ways, I feel for the underclassmen or airmen who may possibly be under your command should you make it through (being the way your are now without improvements) 4 yrs and become an officer supposedly ready to lead others. Remember, we are not all perfect. You need to get yourself squared away ASAP.
 
Everyone who has posted on my thread has further proved my point. Instead of graciously accepting what I had to say, I am yet again criticized by people who go out of their way to argue.

You think yourself so clever; but just call it self-absorbed .........

In this April 3rd, 2016 Thread , "Theyellowfellow" , 'claimed' that he 'didn't see the "Criminal Records Review Form" Section on his USAFA Portal after his Appointment.
:director:When
our 'clever 'OP replied to Cerberi , the OP accidentally did so with his other moniker "16maybt" ! :oops2:

====

This is the same "16maybt" that minutes ago "LIKED" his Post #13, above ! :rofl:


If 'old yeller' tries now to "unlike" his Post above, no matter, I took a screen shot of it :wave:
 
Last edited:
Murf, it's "possible" that he was on someone else's computer and accidentally logged in with that person's username (parent, friend, whatever)....

Edit: I say this because my teens have done it on Facebook. Well, one kid did it. Once. Then corrected herself. ;)
 
Murf, it's "possible" that he was on someone else's computer and accidentally logged in with that person's username (parent, friend, whatever)....Edit: I say this because my teens have done it on Facebook. Well, one kid did it. Once. Then corrected herself. ;)

Not likely; (1) he thinks everyone is an idiot and that they don't notice his posts, (2) the reason he got caught tonight is directly related to his previously documented self-inflicted calamities.
 
I agree with TheYellowFellow. People like Sidney C, Brovol, and myself all need to learn to be nicer. We also need to just get over reading all the TWE threads from some exemplary candidates, so we can provide kinder/gentler advice to those that have appointments but seem hell bent on seeing what is the absolute minimum that needs to be done before the SA takes notice and starts their own review of the the TWE threads.

Maybe it's generational, but the rule of thumb was the time an athlete should be worried isn't when the coach is barking at them, it is when the coach no longer barks at them and has turned their attention to others.

As a grad, I can tell you that if you are slacking now, it's very hard to turn it back on for BCT and your freshman academics. And rest assured, the Dean does not suffer fools lightly.
I have to say, as I have read this thread, I can't tell you how much I agree with Cerberi, as my DD received TWE in April, she maxed out her physical test, with the exception of basketball throw. Last night recognized during honors night with a GPA of 103.07, team captain of her swim team! 7th in her class... Her congressman, her ALO, the Colonel of the JAFROTC all said she was highly competitive great resume. She has a TWE, wanted AFA more than she ever wanted anything in her life. She swims HS and club, 3000 to 5000 yards 6 days a week... A stellar young lady! As many are who received TWE!
 
Awwww poor baby. You guys hurt his/her feelings. Now say you're sorry and be nice. God forbid we should give an adult advice because it's not what he wants to hear. It's the "everyone's a winner and gets a medal for participation " generation so pleaseeeee give the kid his " safe space" because it is not good for their self esteem to hear anything negative.

Wow OP 2 posts today. One asking about failing a test and the other whinning about how people should play nice with you. Looking back at your posts should tell you why you are getting these responses.

If you don't like what you read here visit usafa's yikyak page. There are a lot of protips for class 2020 you might find more to your liking. Something like "If the cadre yells at you, just tell them you need your safe space and they will give it to you right away and also give you the rest of the day off."

I do hope you are just a troll and this is all fun and games to you; we'll play along. But if you are an actual appointee, you got 6 weeks to seriously get your act together or the academy life will be a miserable one.

"You want the truth? You can't handle the truth!" - Col. Nathan Jessep
 
Everyone who has posted on my thread has further proved my point. Instead of graciously accepting what I had to say, I am yet again criticized by people who go out of their way to argue.

You should rethink your appointment to USAFA and come join the Army. I've got room in my platoon and I think my platoon sergeant would really like you.
 
Yes! With this type of support, anyone on these forums will get all the information they need!

I'm wondering how you managed to get an appointment... Doesn't the application process involve interviews? As in, like, with another human being?
 
Awwww poor baby. You guys hurt his/her feelings. Now say you're sorry and be nice. God forbid we should give an adult advice because it's not what he wants to hear. It's the "everyone's a winner and gets a medal for participation " generation so pleaseeeee give the kid his " safe space" because it is not good for their self esteem to hear anything negative.

Wow OP 2 posts today. One asking about failing a test and the other whinning about how people should play nice with you. Looking back at your posts should tell you why you are getting these responses.

If you don't like what you read here visit usafa's yikyak page. There are a lot of protips for class 2020 you might find more to your liking. Something like "If the cadre yells at you, just tell them you need your safe space and they will give it to you right away and also give you the rest of the day off."

I do hope you are just a troll and this is all fun and games to you; we'll play along. But if you are an actual appointee, you got 6 weeks to seriously get your act together or the academy life will be a miserable one.

"You want the truth? You can't handle the truth!" - Col. Nathan Jessep

I just read all of what this guy is saying to my daughter, she being 16 and part of AFROTC, said oh my, if this guy is for real he'll never make it at the academy!
 
Yeah I in fact did not work hard at all in order to obtain my appointment. I actually won it through a lottery!
 
I normally stay away from posting often between February and July. Mainly, because I prefer to provide information about the application process; the academy/military in general; nominations; and improving yourself as a candidate. Plus, this time of year, I really have a hard time with posts about those who didn't receive an appointment; and how life/the process is unfair. (Not everyone, don't read into it). And because I haven't posted much recently, I doubt this thread has anything to do with me. But; sometimes I like to give my $0.0392949459 (Inflation).

But, I would like to respond to Theyellowfellow's post. This is the "REAL WORLD". And as such, there are some things to recognize when posting on the forum.

1. You GET what you PAY FOR. (How much did you pay for the advice, questions, etc. you wanted to know)? Did you get your MONEY's worth?

2. The vast majority of contributors on this forum; who have direct experience with the military/academy (Meaning: current cadets, parents of cadets, ALO's, active duty, retired military, and accepted applicants preparing to enter); have a DEEP Respect and Passion for the military/academies. For the alumni, active duty, and retired personnel (and family members), we/they've put MANY YEARS of their lives into this. They don't take it lightly.

3. As such; one of the biggest concerns for these posters, is that the military/academy, is all about being part of something "BIGGER THAN YOURSELF". So sorry, if the concerns of the military/academy trump the feelings/concerns of an individual. This isn't picking on you; or chiding; or degrading; etc. Simply put; we/they care about the military/academy more than we care about you. This isn't personal. It's something they are PART OF. The military/academy is part of THEM. It's hard to explain if you're not part of it. It's not a matter of disrespect towards you, but respect for the military/academy/institution. They want the best people applying and attending the academy and becoming military members. It can come across some times as arrogance; but it's not. It's personal to many.

4. Frustration: This is probably the biggest issue on the forums. Not just this forum, but many forums. I would probably be safe betting one of my paychecks, that there isn't a question that can be asked, that hasn't been asked yet on this forum. YET..... many posters want the EASY WAY OUT. They don't search the forums. They don't reference something someone else mentioned first. They ask questions as if they, and their questions, are so unique. Yes, some replies could be a little more thoughtful. But it's quite frustrating when the same questions seem to be asked and answered so many times.

5. Finally; anyone that knows me, knows that I will intentionally go out of my way to NOT BE POLITICALLY CORRECT. I don't believe in it; I believe it is one of the major social downfalls of our country. As such, I tell it as it is. I will not intentionally disrespect you or any other poster. But I'm also not afraid to "Call the Baby Ugly" either. If you ask; "How are my chances", I'm going to tell you to read the other 240,394 posts on the subject first. If you ask something specific, I ASSUME that you want a direct and honest answer. I will NOT try to make you feel good if I think the truth is what you need. Can I be NICER about posting something? Probably. Will I try to be nicer? To be honest, I will NOT EVEN GIVE IT A SECOND THOUGHT. Why? Because I DON'T KNOW 99% of the posters here. 99% of the posters here have never met me. THEREFOR; NOTHING that I say here, should be taken PERSONALLY by you or anyone else. If I don't know you PERSONALLY, then I can't say anything to or about you that you should take PERSONALLY. I CAN'T offend you. Only YOU can BECOME offended. Why is one person offended, upset, etc. about something someone says or does; and yet another person almost equal in every way, ISN'T offended??? Stop thinking that everyone else should become nicer, less offensive, kinder, etc. Instead, think of how YOU can mature, and become LESS offended or have your feelings hurt.

Best of luck.
 
The thing I have liked about these forums over the last year while my son was seeking appointment to three different accademys, is that most folks give you the straight, not sugar coated, answer. Accurate information is valuable. Soft serving it so as not to hurt feelings is actually counterproductive, as it may lead to someone taking the wrong approach.

Bottom line, if you can't take the answer, don't ask the question.
If you can't take the answer, you most likely won't make it past the first week @ the academy
 
Yes! With this type of support, anyone on these forums will get all the information they need!

Oh honey, come here and let me hold your hand. Look here... this is called a search window. Type your question in it and answers magically appear...see? Awwww did I hurt your feelings because I asked you to do it yourself? Here let me type it for you too. See????
 
Here, Yellowfellow, look at it this way.

You've gotta take the positive out of everything, because everything happens for a reason. You've got a very long path ahead of you. Some people take criticism differently, and that's okay, because everyone is different in between their ears. But, not everyone knows how you think or why you think that way. Everyone on here is doing all that they can to help you, because I can guarantee just about everyone on here wants you to succeed, which is why this thread is so active. I know that my appointment to USNA is not guaranteed, but I'm still going to take all the help I can get and offer all the help I can give to everyone else competing for a slot. Why? Because that's integrity. As for why I brought that up, you need to realize that being sassy and a smart mouth is not very intergrous, nor will cadet cadre or anyone else in your life appreciate it.

So basically what I'm getting at here is;
Take whatever bit of positive you can get out of the most negative. It makes you happier, realizing that the people on here only want to make you a better person, mentally and morally. And, seriously dude, watch your tone.
But I'm only 13, so what do I know?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top