Seniors earning an appointment by and large have a huge amount on their plate.
Senior year includes AP calc, AP Physics, AP English, etc. Being a key member of multiple sports teams takes valuable study time, and don't forget volunteering, church, and the employment that the academy wants to see.
Oh yeah, NHS functions, student council, and various obligations are in there too.
Being an ex-teacher and coach, I can remember school nights my teams left at 3:00 and returned from trips on the road at 10:30 PM. All day Saturday games and matches and lots of responsibilities.
Now it's easy to say that time management is key to academy appointees, and it definitely is. But to say an appointment should be rescinded without knowing all of the factors including the difficulty of classes and the overall story seems foolish to me. There are bad teachers, and sometimes classes are terribly difficult for almost everyone.
If a kid goofs off with senioritis then he deserves a slap on the wrists and more if the situation warrants it. BUT... if he/she is pushing hard and trying to be all that they can, then I believe they should be given the benefit of the doubt. Afterall, many kids don't take a rigorous schedule and C's and D's wouldn't be in the picture.
Kudos to the kids that keep pushing themselves. I often wonder just how much any senior with an academy as a goal could truly enjoy their senior year with all the pressure on them.