I’m not applying to NROTC because if I don’t get accepted I’m going to a school close to home and going to try and improve my resume. Are you?
I do recommend thinking long and hard about NROTC as a parallel path.
If the main goal is to serve as a Navy or Marine Corps Officer, NROTC is a fine path. If you’re competitive for an SA, you’re competitive for all varieties of NROTC scholarships. If you’re doing NROTC, even as a non-scholarship midshipman, that gives you a shot at an ROTC nom, exposes you to professional training and officers who can help you learn more about your career path, and provides excellent proof of your desire to serve if you find yourself re-applying to USNA - more stuff to include in Round 2 application.
No reason you can’t work on “improving your resumé” while participating in NROTC, which I would argue is a superb way to enrich your SA application. And, if for some reason, USNA never says yes (some people do apply until they age out), you are well on you way to a career as a Navy or Marine Corps Officer - if that is what your heart is truly set on.
You can also avoid pesky interview questions about why you are not also applying to NROTC. Service Academies ask you to balance academics with professional military training. Succeeding in ROTC, which also asks you to balance academics with military training, though in a less immersive way, ensures you already have a grasp of Navy and Marine customs, language, values, and basic pre-comm leadership training. That, assuming you have “stats” that are otherwise competitive, puts you in an attractive light. The SA sees you’re doing well with academics and military training, possibly sees you have earned the confidence of the NROTC PNS through an ROTC nom.
Just something to consider. If you want to be a Navy or Marine Corps officer, which is the entire goal of all this, why avoid a quality path? You might even find NROTC is the perfect fit for you, score a great scholarship, the school might throw in room and board, and you love your unit and shipmates. The SA looks at the whole person, not just tangible grades/scores/ranks. They also look at military aptitude and potential to succeed as an officer. I contend success in NROTC is a fairly clear proof of that, while in and of itself functioning as a superb source of top-quality officers.
Invest some time in analysis of this parallel path. Good luck!