Extra Year Dilemma

Thank you all very much for the responses. I know that no one can make this decision besides myself. I have researched a lot about the possible career options for each branch, and it makes it that much harder because I love all the opportunities for both, but as a 17 year old, it's hard for me to make such a life changing decision. My parents will support me regardless - they are simply worried that my prep year will somehow go awry and that my appointment will be taken away. They see how hard I've worked for this goal, and they want a 100% guarantee, not a 99, which I totally understand from a parent POV.

The financial portion for civil prep would not be an issue, because the coaches at the prep schools have offered me athletic scholarships on top of that, so I truly have to wonder if the extra year is worth it. I see a lot of posts on this forum about "what uniform do you see yourself wearing in ten years" and truth is, I see myself as an Army 2LT, yet, I know that I would love the Air Force equally as much if I went there. No matter how it turns out, I am incredibly grateful to have such a difficult decision to make. Again, thank you everyone for your words of encouragement and advice.
You might want to talk to the coaches at USMA. You might lose a year of eligibility if you play "college athletics" at the prep school. Just something to think about. Good luck!
Prep school doesn't count against NCAA eligibility.

Incorrect. For civil prep, since they are receiving alumni foundation scholarships, time spent on the prep school's teams (if NJCAA) counts toward NCAA eligibility. If practicing only, then the time counts as a redshirt year. If competing, then the student will only be able to compete for three years at the academy. Coast Guard Scholars are the exception, because they are under similar programs as Air Force, Army, and Navy prep.
 
Thank you all very much for the responses. I know that no one can make this decision besides myself. I have researched a lot about the possible career options for each branch, and it makes it that much harder because I love all the opportunities for both, but as a 17 year old, it's hard for me to make such a life changing decision. My parents will support me regardless - they are simply worried that my prep year will somehow go awry and that my appointment will be taken away. They see how hard I've worked for this goal, and they want a 100% guarantee, not a 99, which I totally understand from a parent POV.

The financial portion for civil prep would not be an issue, because the coaches at the prep schools have offered me athletic scholarships on top of that, so I truly have to wonder if the extra year is worth it. I see a lot of posts on this forum about "what uniform do you see yourself wearing in ten years" and truth is, I see myself as an Army 2LT, yet, I know that I would love the Air Force equally as much if I went there. No matter how it turns out, I am incredibly grateful to have such a difficult decision to make. Again, thank you everyone for your words of encouragement and advice.
You might want to talk to the coaches at USMA. You might lose a year of eligibility if you play "college athletics" at the prep school. Just something to think about. Good luck!
Prep school doesn't count against NCAA eligibility.

Incorrect. For civil prep, since they are receiving alumni foundation scholarships, time spent on the prep school's teams (if NJCAA) counts toward NCAA eligibility. If practicing only, then the time counts as a redshirt year. If competing, then the student will only be able to compete for three years at the academy. Coast Guard Scholars are the exception, because they are under similar programs as Air Force, Army, and Navy prep.
I stand corrected, CGAS preppies are the exception? I assumed that they were all treated the same. Thanks for the info!
 
Incorrect. For civil prep, since they are receiving alumni foundation scholarships, time spent on the prep school's teams (if NJCAA) counts toward NCAA eligibility. If practicing only, then the time counts as a redshirt year. If competing, then the student will only be able to compete for three years at the academy. Coast Guard Scholars are the exception, because they are under similar programs as Air Force, Army, and Navy prep.
No, it does not. It counts as high school. My niece recently did a civil prep year. She still has her four years at USNA. A nephew did NAPS. He played four years at USNA.
Same with military prep schools. In the eyes of the NCAA they are "high school", not college.
 
To the OP. Civil prep can give you experiences you might never otherwise get. My brother did a civil prep... "a few years ago". He was classmates with and wrestling team mates with the current King of Jordan.
 
Incorrect. For civil prep, since they are receiving alumni foundation scholarships, time spent on the prep school's teams (if NJCAA) counts toward NCAA eligibility. If practicing only, then the time counts as a redshirt year. If competing, then the student will only be able to compete for three years at the academy. Coast Guard Scholars are the exception, because they are under similar programs as Air Force, Army, and Navy prep.
No, it does not. It counts as high school. My niece recently did a civil prep year. She still has her four years at USNA.
Same with military prep schools. In the eyes of the NCAA they are "high school", not college.
Blackhawk, schools with NJCAA affiliation like New Mexico Military and Marion Military fall under NCAA rules. For example, MMI used to have wrestling under the NCWA association. Since those wrestlers were not under NCAA rules, they had a full four years of competition at the academies.
 
Incorrect. For civil prep, since they are receiving alumni foundation scholarships, time spent on the prep school's teams (if NJCAA) counts toward NCAA eligibility. If practicing only, then the time counts as a redshirt year. If competing, then the student will only be able to compete for three years at the academy. Coast Guard Scholars are the exception, because they are under similar programs as Air Force, Army, and Navy prep.
No, it does not. It counts as high school. My niece recently did a civil prep year. She still has her four years at USNA. A nephew did NAPS. He played four years at USNA.
Same with military prep schools. In the eyes of the NCAA they are "high school", not college.
I was told by several of the athletic coaches at the NJCAA that I would lose a year of eligibility if I played next year, but by the time I am a senior at the SA, my mind will not be focused on my sport, rather, I will be focusing on the future and careers.
 
Blackhawk, schools with NJCAA affiliation like New Mexico Military and Marion Military fall under NCAA rules.
Sorry, I missed the NJCAA part.
Two separate entities. You are correct. If it falls under NJCAA, yes, you lose the eligibility.
If it is a military prep school or regular prep school however, is the same as high school.
 
Thank you all very much for the responses. I know that no one can make this decision besides myself. I have researched a lot about the possible career options for each branch, and it makes it that much harder because I love all the opportunities for both, but as a 17 year old, it's hard for me to make such a life changing decision. My parents will support me regardless - they are simply worried that my prep year will somehow go awry and that my appointment will be taken away. They see how hard I've worked for this goal, and they want a 100% guarantee, not a 99, which I totally understand from a parent POV.

The financial portion for civil prep would not be an issue, because the coaches at the prep schools have offered me athletic scholarships on top of that, so I truly have to wonder if the extra year is worth it. I see a lot of posts on this forum about "what uniform do you see yourself wearing in ten years" and truth is, I see myself as an Army 2LT, yet, I know that I would love the Air Force equally as much if I went there. No matter how it turns out, I am incredibly grateful to have such a difficult decision to make. Again, thank you everyone for your words of encouragement and advice.
You might want to talk to the coaches at USMA. You might lose a year of eligibility if you play "college athletics" at the prep school. Just something to think about. Good luck!
Prep school doesn't count against NCAA eligibility.
It does if it's a "junior college" like NMMI or MMI. Even if it is a pure "prep school," anon2021 should still speak to the USMA coaches. The KP football coaches wanted him to do their training program, not the prep schools.
 
Incorrect. For civil prep, since they are receiving alumni foundation scholarships, time spent on the prep school's teams (if NJCAA) counts toward NCAA eligibility. If practicing only, then the time counts as a redshirt year. If competing, then the student will only be able to compete for three years at the academy. Coast Guard Scholars are the exception, because they are under similar programs as Air Force, Army, and Navy prep.
No, it does not. It counts as high school. My niece recently did a civil prep year. She still has her four years at USNA. A nephew did NAPS. He played four years at USNA.
Same with military prep schools. In the eyes of the NCAA they are "high school", not college.
I was told by several of the athletic coaches at the NJCAA that I would lose a year of eligibility if I played next year, but by the time I am a senior at the SA, my mind will not be focused on my sport, rather, I will be focusing on the future and careers.
As long as you are aware and are good with it. No worries. Good luck.
 
Back
Top