A few questions about disqualification and waivers

m50612

New Member
Joined
Apr 19, 2021
Messages
8
Hello, I received a letter stating a disqualification with the reason of "History of airway hyper responsiveness including asthma, reactive airway disease, exercise induced bronchospasm or asthmatic bronchitis, after the 13th birthday".

Important background before my questions:
Three years ago, I had a cough that had lasted for a year, so ending 2 years ago. At the time, when I went to see a doctor I was never diagnosed with anything and was prescribed an inhaler after a pulmonary that showed no indication of any problems. The inhaler prescription was renewed for a total of three months which coincidentally coincided with the ending of the cough and there was never a recommendation for an emergency inhaler. I was also tested for allergies and have none. The cough ended and was seemingly a phenomena as the inhalants were never required afterwards and I'm in the best physical condition I've been in. I've gone on to do varsity track and am able to run 8 miles without any indicator of an impending respiratory incident.

Questions:
I've applied for the USNA and if they deny me, I'm under the impression that they will not send a request for a medical waiver. Does this mean that a waiver can be requested for in the future?
(Follow up of first question) I've been accepted and intend to attend Norwich University (SMC), going through the Corps of Cadets and NROTC. Assuming that no waiver request was sent by Annapolis in 2021, is Norwich or the national NROTC able to request a waiver for a later date like 2022 when it is necessary again? (This is under the assumption that no waiver request was ever put in before)
Whoever decides the waiver request decisions, do they view waivers holistically? Considering there is currently clear evidence of athletic performance without issue and in the future if the waiver is requested through Norwich where there would be additional evidence of performance without issue, I don't see a reason for denial. I understand the purpose of disqualification, but it doesn't make any logical sense to not look at the circumstances, especially if the person deciding just looks at the reason and not the facts. (Sorry about the venting in this question, it's extremely frustrating and demoralizing to want to serve a country in uniform whose services do not want you there for a reason that could be written off through clear observation)

Conclusion:
I'm not well versed in exactly how the waiver system works, I'm just extremely nervous that the only thing I've ever wanted to do, not even being an officer but being a service member, is in jeopardy and am just trying to weigh in my chances of even joining the reserves during or after college.
 
Hey, I am just wondering as part of your background: you had a cough for a year but when exactly did you see your doctor? Did she prescribe you the inhaler during or after as a precautionary? What medications did you use to correct your cough? PS - I was DQ and now denied a waiver after being appointed to USAFA because of very similar situations as that above. I had episodes of coughing but my doctor prescribed me albuterol inhalers as a precaution and that is why I am being denied. It seems they can deny you for the medications you were prescribed (not even used) and you said your case was phenomena, so you may need to contact some pulmonologists and medical experts showing that you have severely improved but even in my case, the woman in charge of my file said it is unlikely. Do all that you can to overturn any decisions and provide a lot of information that you're perfect now. Also, I assume you haven't been accepted or denied to USNA, so you should contact authorities on your decision/status of your medical. Not sure that much about ROTC but I'm assuming similar guidelines apply.
 
when exactly did you see your doctor? Did she prescribe you the inhaler during or after as a precautionary? What medications did you use to correct your cough?
Albuterol and Symbicort were prescribed during the cough, a few months before it disappeared. They were given to see if they worked which is unknown if they did or didn't as if they didn't I'd still be coughing but if they did I'd also still be coughing since it's been years since last refill of prescription, I don't even own inhalers anymore. The pulmonary showed no issues whatsoever which was baffling since there was a cough but evidently not so much anymore since I can perform strenuous physical activity with no reactions and there hasn't been a cough since.
 
Hello, I received a letter stating a disqualification with the reason of "History of airway hyper responsiveness including asthma, reactive airway disease, exercise induced bronchospasm or asthmatic bronchitis, after the 13th birthday".

Important background before my questions:
Three years ago, I had a cough that had lasted for a year, so ending 2 years ago. At the time, when I went to see a doctor I was never diagnosed with anything and was prescribed an inhaler after a pulmonary that showed no indication of any problems. The inhaler prescription was renewed for a total of three months which coincidentally coincided with the ending of the cough and there was never a recommendation for an emergency inhaler. I was also tested for allergies and have none. The cough ended and was seemingly a phenomena as the inhalants were never required afterwards and I'm in the best physical condition I've been in. I've gone on to do varsity track and am able to run 8 miles without any indicator of an impending respiratory incident.

Questions:
I've applied for the USNA and if they deny me, I'm under the impression that they will not send a request for a medical waiver. Does this mean that a waiver can be requested for in the future?
(Follow up of first question) I've been accepted and intend to attend Norwich University (SMC), going through the Corps of Cadets and NROTC. Assuming that no waiver request was sent by Annapolis in 2021, is Norwich or the national NROTC able to request a waiver for a later date like 2022 when it is necessary again? (This is under the assumption that no waiver request was ever put in before)
Whoever decides the waiver request decisions, do they view waivers holistically? Considering there is currently clear evidence of athletic performance without issue and in the future if the waiver is requested through Norwich where there would be additional evidence of performance without issue, I don't see a reason for denial. I understand the purpose of disqualification, but it doesn't make any logical sense to not look at the circumstances, especially if the person deciding just looks at the reason and not the facts. (Sorry about the venting in this question, it's extremely frustrating and demoralizing to want to serve a country in uniform whose services do not want you there for a reason that could be written off through clear observation)

Conclusion:
I'm not well versed in exactly how the waiver system works, I'm just extremely nervous that the only thing I've ever wanted to do, not even being an officer but being a service member, is in jeopardy and am just trying to weigh in my chances of even joining the reserves during or after college.
You've posted in the right place for the official from DoDMERB to see your post and he can assist you from there. There is lots of good advice on this forum from veterans of the process, and they were incredibly helpful to us and advised us of how the process typically works while providing lots of encouragement. Having said that, they will also advice you that comparing specifics of one candidate situation to another is more problematic than helpful.

I think the recommendation is: Google DODMERB TRICARE and read Questions about the Process if you haven't already. Responding to your original post above, in summary, first wait to see if you will be Disqualifed. Then for an SA application, they must request a waiver on your behalf (you do not request it) and will only do so if you are considered competitive for an appointment. ROTC can also request a waiver, and my understanding is that each SA and ROTC have their own set of guidelines for waivers. Though they all work through the same agency, DoDMERB, they process independently. Our experience, and many others will tell you the same, the waiver process is very effective. Have confidence that if a waiver is requested, the review will be thorough.

Just a parent of a candidate that went through the process, but I hope this is helpful until the DoDMERB official comes along - it's a very busy time of year, so be patient. Good luck!
 
m50612 = Correct. Google "DoDMERB;" Hit "Questions on the process;" If you meet the criteria in paragraphs 11-12 determined by USNA Admissions, then 15-19 and 21 will apply. For NROTC, it would be 11 & 13 and then 15-19 and 21. :wiggle:
 
Hello- My DS received a "disqualification due to joint instability/dislocation", currently he is pending waiver review. He is a 3yr AD AROTC scholarship winner. A little background on the injury- During football in freshman year, he tore his labrum while making a tackle. He had surgery that summer, we opted for an open surgery rather than laparoscopic due to the decreased risk of recurrance with open. He has since played football every year in high school and wrestled every year with no issues to the shoulder. I sent in all the operative and post op notes, even took him back to the surgeon last month for a follow up to document strength an range of motion ( he is back to 100%). Is this something that will likely get a waiver? I know that the 4 year students are probably the priority right now, but the wait for the waiver is torturous.
 
DS, say again, DS should = Google "DoDMERB;" Hit "Questions on the process;" For ROTC, it would be 11 & 13 and then 15-19 and 21. :wiggle:
 
Albuterol and Symbicort were prescribed during the cough, a few months before it disappeared. They were given to see if they worked which is unknown if they did or didn't as if they didn't I'd still be coughing but if they did I'd also still be coughing since it's been years since last refill of prescription, I don't even own inhalers anymore. The pulmonary showed no issues whatsoever which was baffling since there was a cough but evidently not so much anymore since I can perform strenuous physical activity with no reactions and there hasn't been a cough since.
Well even for my case, I easily passed the CFA, play soccer year-round, but have had small episodes of bronchitis, so it all matters on your condition and how recent it was. You said 2 years ago so maybe USNA will grant a waiver (if they consider it first) but for my case at USAFA, it has to be 3 years and the timeline is non-negotiable (denied). Same with the albuterol prescription - it can't have been within 3 years. Different services have different guidelines so look into those.
 
Back
Top