Anecdotal, Empirical, and Scientific Evidence

THParent

Founder - Service Academy Bacon Forums (SABF)
5-Year Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2017
Messages
6,744
Anecdotal evidence is evidence collected in a casual or informal manner and relying heavily or entirely on personal testimony. Example: "I am going to buy this car because Jane has one and she says it's the most reliable car she has ever owned."

Empirical evidence relies on experience or observation alone, often without due regard for system, theory, or science. Example: Wood frame houses are built with 2x4s at 16" on center. They can be built with 2x4s at 24" on center (saving money on structure), but people still build them at 16" on center "because that's the way it was done before, and they didn't fall down".

Scientific evidence is conducted in the manner of science or according to results of investigation by science : practicing or using thorough or systematic methods. Example: In the 17th century, Galileo Galilee theorized that light traveled at a finite speed, but was unable to measure it. What a surprise, he used two guys holding lanterns a set (albeit long) distance apart. It wasn't until 1983 that the recognized speed of light was accurately measured with a proper, repeatable, scientific method in a vacuum, and adopted by scientists all over the world. That's 299,792,458 meters per second, by the way. ;)

Why the lecture on evidence, you may ask?

It's because we here at SAF sometimes get into the trick bag of reporting Anecdotal Evidence that something is bound to happen to JoeCandidate or JaneCandidate, because our very own beloved DS or DD had the same thing happen, and it turned out okay! So don't worry, everything will be fine!

Yes. I have done it. More than once. Sorry about that!

The truth is, every application and every candidate is different. Every time they go to a DoDMERB physical, it is different. Every time that the Academy reviews their application, it's different. Every time that they land in hot water while at the Academy, it's different. Every time they have color-blindness, it's different. Every time there's a new person in charge (of Admissions, the Academy, DoDMERB, etc.) they are different. You can usually expect that their policies, procedures, and regulations will be different, too.

One thing is always constant in the military, and that is change. Change is necessary to overcome and adapt to changing times and policies. Change isn't always good, but you can always count on it happening.

There. I feel better.
 
I know. The story about the screws in my daughter's tibia was too much. My bad.
 
I have not read this bone-screw post of which you speak.
 
upload_2019-8-24_9-0-33.png

This evidence is scientific. Asparagus grilled on a Himalayan salt table is outstanding. I did it last night to rave reviews. It went with chicken breasts, broccolli and potatoes cooked on the smoker.
I smashed the potatoes with the skins on, for smoky smashed potatoes. I probably wouldn't have bought this salt block thing on my own, but I got it for Christmas and just finally started using it this summer.

Then there was this fridge drawer selection:

upload_2019-8-24_9-5-4.png

Had friends over, ate on the deck (it finally wasn't too hot outside). It was great.
 

Attachments

  • upload_2019-8-24_9-3-47.png
    upload_2019-8-24_9-3-47.png
    973.7 KB · Views: 11
Last edited:
Is that a "Cubs" beer hidden in the back? Vanilla porter has to be the tastiest of that selection...IMHO
 
Anecdotal evidence is evidence collected in a casual or informal manner and relying heavily or entirely on personal testimony. Example: "I am going to buy this car because Jane has one and she says it's the most reliable car she has ever owned."

Empirical evidence relies on experience or observation alone, often without due regard for system, theory, or science. Example: Wood frame houses are built with 2x4s at 16" on center. They can be built with 2x4s at 24" on center (saving money on structure), but people still build them at 16" on center "because that's the way it was done before, and they didn't fall down".

Scientific evidence is conducted in the manner of science or according to results of investigation by science : practicing or using thorough or systematic methods. Example: In the 17th century, Galileo Galilee theorized that light traveled at a finite speed, but was unable to measure it. What a surprise, he used two guys holding lanterns a set (albeit long) distance apart. It wasn't until 1983 that the recognized speed of light was accurately measured with a proper, repeatable, scientific method in a vacuum, and adopted by scientists all over the world. That's 299,792,458 meters per second, by the way. ;)

Why the lecture on evidence, you may ask?

It's because we here at SAF sometimes get into the trick bag of reporting Anecdotal Evidence that something is bound to happen to JoeCandidate or JaneCandidate, because our very own beloved DS or DD had the same thing happen, and it turned out okay! So don't worry, everything will be fine!

Yes. I have done it. More than once. Sorry about that!

The truth is, every application and every candidate is different. Every time they go to a DoDMERB physical, it is different. Every time that the Academy reviews their application, it's different. Every time that they land in hot water while at the Academy, it's different. Every time they have color-blindness, it's different. Every time there's a new person in charge (of Admissions, the Academy, DoDMERB, etc.) they are different. You can usually expect that their policies, procedures, and regulations will be different, too.

One thing is always constant in the military, and that is change. Change is necessary to overcome and adapt to changing times and policies. Change isn't always good, but you can always count on it happening.

There. I feel better.
 
Soooo.........

ANECDOTAL EVIDENCE: Private Jarhead says his rifle is clean, so it must be so.
EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE: Private Jarhead's rifle is usually clean, so it probably is clean right now.
SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE: Private Jarhead's rifle was examined his NCO, Company 1t Sgt & Company CO & they all reported it to be clean.
 
If Private Jarhead's rifle is clean, and there is no one available to verify that it's clean, is it still clean?
 
It's because we here at SAF sometimes get into the trick bag of reporting Anecdotal Evidence that something is bound to happen to JoeCandidate or JaneCandidate, because our very own beloved DS or DD had the same thing happen, and it turned out okay! So don't worry, everything will be fine!

This post should be a sticky at the top...or at least some warning to all Users. As I often say here, one data point doesn't make a trend. There are many variables in the Admissions process...and everyone's experience is different.
 
Back
Top