Dad_of_Nominee
5-Year Member
- Joined
- Mar 13, 2010
- Messages
- 22
I would assume each SA (well, I know they have it as USCGA) has their own data (from candidate/appointee/cadet/midshipman surveys) that shows how many appointments were declined/accepted in favor of/over another SA or even civilian colleges.
I'm pretty sure that USAFA asks on their "decline appointment" form if the appointee is declining to attend another SA, and if so, which one.
As much as it pains me to acknowledge it, the data and statistics I've seen show that more candidates decline USMA, USAFA, USMMA, and USCGA appointments to accept USNA appointments. They win the popularity contest.
I'm sure you have heard the old joke: "What do West Point cadets and Naval Academy mids have in common? They were both appointed to West Point."
Our Senators and Congressman (Florida) required each candidate to specify and apply for one SA. Then, after the interview process, they pooled their info so that there were no double nom's ... supposedly.
This info comes from two of the three MOC's.
Fortunately, our nom got his USNA nom and that was the only one that interested him anyway. So, plan B will be one of the other great FL Univ's.
Waiting for a USNA decision is part of the game. The work the 'selection committee' does is over and above their regular work and duties. Tip of the hat to their efforts.
Blue folder or TWE, we have a great kid. Everybody else has great kids. I would not relish the "Solomon-esque" duty of trying to decide who stays and who goes. The ones who don't go have to realize that this test of disappointment is likely one of many to come in life. How they deal with this event becomes a great lesson about what it means to be in our 'grown up' world.
I remind him that when your life is over, the real value you leave behind in this world, is the quality of your children and what you teach them.