My son was in the same position last year. He had two four-year ROTC scholarships for Penn State and Pitt and liked both programs. Both also had students successfully get appointments after a year or two. When he was offered the AOG civil prep he took it and is finishing at Georgia Miltary College this year. There are 9 sponsored WP prep cadets with him and all received their appointments in February as well as three other students there. Also, do not worry about getting the congressional nomination the next year. Finally, the credits they take at GMC would transfer is the student decides not to attend an academy. My son will have his associate's degree (in one year) when he graduates from GMC in May, they take A LOT of classes, it's not easy! My son also feels much better prepared than had he gone to WP right away, especially as he was virtual for much of his senior year. Both are amazing options, as others say it depends on if he wants WP or to be an Army officer. Good luck!