Contrarian Viewpoint:
Having a "fall back" (Plan B) in place after I-Day may make it easier to quit during a difficult Plebe Summer.
Knowing (apologies to Richard Gere) "I got nowhere else to go" may help a struggling Plebe get through a rough stretch, keeping him there rather than allowing him take the easy way out and DOR.
I somewhat agree with this viewpoint.
My sons (currently Youngsters), every once in a while will get pissed off and talk about how they are going to apply to other colleges - just to "test the waters." I always say, "Go ahead!" But I don't lift a finger to help them.
I have to admit, I did a lot of advising while they were going through the Academy application process. I felt, as their father and USNA grad, that I had some insight in the process that I should share with them. I also helped them with other college applications. (Yes, I admit, I wrote a few essays - so
shoot me!) But now that they are at the Academy, they are on their own. If they should choose to quit and go to another college - they can do it all themselves. I'm not lifting a finger.
They won't quit - but they sure like to vent. I think they use me as a sounding board at times. I don't fight them. I don't give them anybody to argue with. I just say, "Hey, if you want to quit - then QUIT! You don't need my permission." Then they shut up.
The one thing I keep repeating: Nobody has ever graduated from the United States Naval Academy and said, "Gee, I sure wish I had
never done that." There are never regrets.
But there are
plenty of people who have quit and regretted it tremendously.
The process may not be fun, but that's why, universally, all grads say, "It's a great place to be
FROM." It's true.