In this AM's Wall Street Journal

cb7893

10-Year Member
Joined
Dec 6, 2011
Messages
3,513

Don't get the wrong idea from reading the title. Col. Hoffman didn't "spur" the Marine Corps. (I assume they meant "spurn." I swear, the quality of editing has plummeted in the age of spell check and online news media). He simply had the courage to turn down a prestigious command position out of concern for his own ability to properly lead. The article is excellent, plotting Col. Hoffman's Marine Corps career along the timeline of US involvement in Afghanistan and Iraq.

WSJ has a paywall. If you cannot get through, PM me your email and I can send it to you, in which case WSJ will let you read a couple of articles/month. I promise not to sell your email address to spam.com

It is a lengthy piece with numerous pictures so it is too large to copy/paste in its entirety, but I will copy the first portion:

Marine commando Randy Hoffman’s plane took off from Kabul, climbed over the jagged mountains and turned toward home.
Somewhere down there was his tent, a piece of canvas stretched across a pit he had carved into a high-altitude ridge. Randy had spent most of the previous 2½ years in the mountains along the Pakistan border, turning Afghan villagers into soldiers.

Rugs covered the tent’s dirt floor. He had a wood stove for heat and collected catalogs of farm equipment and RVs to remind him of home in Indiana. A metal thermos stored the goat’s milk and cucumber drink delivered each morning by the mountain men who fought alongside him. He and the Afghans would sit on a dirt bench, talking about poetry, faith and honor, and how to make it through the next day alive.

Randy’s camp watched over the narrow passes and smuggling paths used by al Qaeda and Taliban militants to sneak into Afghanistan from Pakistan. He kept mortars aimed at likely approaches. At times, he was the only American for miles.

On Randy’s last trip down the mountains, a caravan of Afghan fighters in Toyota pickups escorted him on the seven-hour drive to a U.S. base. From there, he caught a helicopter to Kabul and trimmed the beard he had grown so he wouldn’t stand out as a target during gunfights.

It was July 2005. As Randy headed home, he couldn’t escape one thought. U.S. troops had been in Afghanistan for three years and nine months—as long as they had fought in World War II. Yet the Afghan war wasn’t close to won.


On the flight home, Randy pictured the many villagers lost in combat, men he had come to admire for their courage and strict sense of right and wrong. He thought about those left legless by militant bombings and now facing a life ahead in mud-brick compounds perched on mountainsides.
 
Last edited:
wow, lots of sensitive and personal details. Good on General Neller for taking care of him.
 
@Devil Doc ,

At least he wasn't referred to as a "Soldier".

I'd like to hear what you think, from the perspective of a US Marine. I'm just the father of a soldier.
Yes. That irritates me to no end.

I’m not a Marine but a retired Senior Chief Navy Corpsman who was stationed with the Marines three times. I’ve spent more time with the Corps than most Marines ever did. Also, my son is a Marine officer up for major next board. He has caught up with me time wise and after making major will probably figure he out ranks Senior Chiefs.

The story of Colonel Hoffman is very compelling and makes one wonder how many senior officers suffer in silence. I know General Neller from years ago at Camp Lejeune when our kids were in youth sports. I ran into him again when he was director of operations at HQMC. He comes across as gruff and he actually is. Reading about his involvement with Hoffman and Cpl Leuken and the compassion he showed was good for my soul.

My son is the senior combat engineer at Tactical Training Exercise Control Group at 29 Palms. Prior to that he was CO of Mobility Assault Company in the 1st Marine Division. He owned ABVs, AAVs that launched line charges, and the Marines who he sent down range to blow stuff up. The only thing worse than thinking of having my son injured is him going through the pain of having his people killed or injured. It’s a pain that never goes away.

I get my care at Walter Reed and as the years have passed, fewer young people are there with outwardly visible injuries. The ones we don’t see though, the post traumatic stress and traumatic brain injuries are still plentiful. That’ll be the case for a long time.
 
My DS (SARC/SOIDC) Marine Raider sent me this article yesterday. He knows COL Hoffman and speaks highly of him. We need more role models like COL Hoffman in the Corps. It takes a lot of guts to admit a problem like he did, seek help, and let other Marines know it's okay. Too many of our combat veterans suffer in silence.
 

Don't get the wrong idea from reading the title. Col. Hoffman didn't "spur" the Marine Corps. (I assume they meant "spurn." I swear, the quality of editing has plummeted in the age of spell check and online news media).

Sorry to disagree, but, in this case, the WSJ's writing and editing was just fine. The use of the verb "spur", as in encourage, motivate, incite, etc., was correct.
 
Sorry to disagree, but, in this case, the WSJ's writing and editing was just fine. The use of the verb "spur", as in encourage, motivate, incite, etc., was correct.
You are probably right about spur vs. spurn, but I thought Gen. Neller did the spurring. I agree it is an excellent article, which is why I posted it.
 
Back
Top