My son had an accident resulting in a labral tear in his shoulder freshman year. His orthopedic doctor recommended physical therapy to be followed by surgery if PT was unsuccessful. He followed his PT recommendations and has thankfully not had a recurrence of instability or subluxations since.
Dodmerb requested remedials and we sent in all his medical paperwork. He was subsequently disqualified for 225 - history of any dislocation, subluxation, or instability of the shoulder.
The AFA requested a waiver on his behalf two months ago and we are still waiting to hear. However AFROTC granted him a waiver yesterday!
I have read of others on these boards who have had the surgical repair and gone on to have it waived. Obviously each case is different but I hope this helps.