Hello all, I was just thinking about plebe summer and USNA and I had a thought. What would happen if someone had surgery that would take someone out for months during plebe summer or the academic year? Would they be sent home if they were still able to serve once they recovered? For example, I have a waiver for my ankle but what if I injured it so badly that it would take me out for 6 months during plebe summer?
Injury during plebe summer/school year.
- Thread starter Alan99
- Start date
Case by case situation. If it happens early on Plebe Summer the liklihood of being sent home is higher. As mentioned, they usually get an LOA for the next class. We had a guy blow his knee out on the second or third day there, he got sent home and came back the following year. USNA looks at how bad the injury is and how much training they will miss. It is really case by case.
Academic year things are handled also case by case. Depends on severity, recovery time, how much class is missed, etc. Mids are very active people and do get hurt, very few get pulled out of their class to recover. To get rolled back a class it’s usually something like cancer or something severe. It is rare for an injury to push someone a class. Even surgery and being out a few weeks isn’t enough to roll someone. USNA understands that someone having something like ACL surgery will do better at home or a sponsor’s for a week or so. Once they get past the initial surgery and start to recover, they can return to class and spend a lot of time in physical therapy.
Academic year things are handled also case by case. Depends on severity, recovery time, how much class is missed, etc. Mids are very active people and do get hurt, very few get pulled out of their class to recover. To get rolled back a class it’s usually something like cancer or something severe. It is rare for an injury to push someone a class. Even surgery and being out a few weeks isn’t enough to roll someone. USNA understands that someone having something like ACL surgery will do better at home or a sponsor’s for a week or so. Once they get past the initial surgery and start to recover, they can return to class and spend a lot of time in physical therapy.
Last edited:
HopefulDad3210
5-Year Member
- Joined
- Nov 24, 2015
- Messages
- 322
More likely to get you sent home during summer than ac year. DS is a youngster. Broke foot over summer at Airborne school. Returned to school for youngster year with a chit getting him out of PT etc. No problem.
usnavynurse
Member
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2017
- Messages
- 85
There are plenty of kids on crutches, slings and in boots during Plebe summer and into academic year. Although I don't know the extent of their injuries it seemed USNA was committed to heeling these individuals, especially since they already took their Oath of Office. What I would try to avoid is any injury before I-Day, that could defer you till the following year. Good Luck!
Thank you for the reply, so do you think someone would get sent home if they were to get surgery after plebe summer?
I know a few cadets from the Houston area that are having major surgery since the academic year has started and they are being allowed to proceed with the year.
It still is going to come down to severity. If it will not affect the chance of commissioning, they should be fine.
There are also quite a few post on the class pages about cadets having surgery.
It still is going to come down to severity. If it will not affect the chance of commissioning, they should be fine.
There are also quite a few post on the class pages about cadets having surgery.
shock-n-awe
5-Year Member
- Joined
- May 12, 2015
- Messages
- 755
If it’s serious they for sure will notify. The only exception may be if the Cadet/Mid signed a medical non disclosure type form (forget actual term). Some parents get surprised to find out their kid signed one!
To answer the old question above regarding getting sent home if getting surgery during Plebe summer would happen, short answer, likely. Sickness or injuries happen during Plebe summer, but the severity of those is the determining factor. If recovery will take too long, or full recovery will not happen they will likely out process completely or may have an option to join the next class if cleared.
Another thing to keep in mind is if the health issue (or any issue) prevents the Cadet/Mid from completing all of the requirements of Plebe summer, they will not graduate PS training and will be out processed.
- Joined
- Sep 27, 2008
- Messages
- 20,475
Plebes sign all kinds of forms, including the one at the link below, for all kinds of personal information, and once through Plebe summer, can control their choices online.
USNA has deep experience in the notification process, and would notify the designated NOK in the case of serious injury or illness, perhaps requesting permission from the mid first, if the mid had actively chosen “don’t notify.” “Everyday” injuries and illness, where the mid is “on chit,” with light duties or SIQ (sick in quarters) bed rest but expected to fully recover and resume training, would be considered routine.
https://www.usna.edu/PlebeSummer/_f... 2020 Item 17 Consent to Disclosure Form.docx
Many parents are surprised their mids elect “no disclosure.” As a USNA BattO, I had many a call from a furious parent who didn’t understand why I couldn’t tell them their DA/DD would not be home for Thanksgiving, because I would be looking right at the screen showing “no disclosure of misconduct.” As usual, after one of those, I’d point the company officer and the Batt chaplain toward the mid for some counseling. We could not order the mid to share the info, but the chaplain was always the champ in getting the parents on the phone and coaching the mid how to break bad news.
Circling back to the original inquiry, given the plebes are mere days into their new status as adults, if something truly serious happens, USNA knows what to do to get information into the right hands while respecting personal information regulations.
USNA has deep experience in the notification process, and would notify the designated NOK in the case of serious injury or illness, perhaps requesting permission from the mid first, if the mid had actively chosen “don’t notify.” “Everyday” injuries and illness, where the mid is “on chit,” with light duties or SIQ (sick in quarters) bed rest but expected to fully recover and resume training, would be considered routine.
https://www.usna.edu/PlebeSummer/_f... 2020 Item 17 Consent to Disclosure Form.docx
Many parents are surprised their mids elect “no disclosure.” As a USNA BattO, I had many a call from a furious parent who didn’t understand why I couldn’t tell them their DA/DD would not be home for Thanksgiving, because I would be looking right at the screen showing “no disclosure of misconduct.” As usual, after one of those, I’d point the company officer and the Batt chaplain toward the mid for some counseling. We could not order the mid to share the info, but the chaplain was always the champ in getting the parents on the phone and coaching the mid how to break bad news.
Circling back to the original inquiry, given the plebes are mere days into their new status as adults, if something truly serious happens, USNA knows what to do to get information into the right hands while respecting personal information regulations.
TheNimble1
5-Year Member
- Joined
- Jun 1, 2018
- Messages
- 27
I can, unfortunately, provide some insight here...
Some of you may know about this from the parent FB groups, so my apologies for any duplication.
Last Saturday (the day before our first scheduled plebe phone call), my phone lit up w/DD's caller ID. Uh oh, I thought. This can't be good. Well, it wasn't. Turns out that she had a near-fatal cardiac episode in the Hall. I'll skip all of the details here, but she ended up spending a week in the Anne Arundel Medical Center and was released last Thursday and forced to return home.
Thank God that her life was saved, but sadly, she has been deemed her “non-commissionable”. So, after years of hard work (including a USNA Foundation prep year), making the cut and earning her spot in the Brigade, swearing the Oath of Office, and beginning (and crushing, according to the detailers) Plebe Summer, it is now gone - poof! To add insult to injury, we found out yesterday (7/15) that her competitive rowing career is over as well (she'd been recruited by all of the "big" rowing schools and, perhaps naively, thought that may still be an option in her new non-Academy life). She would have gladly dropped rowing in an instant in order to serve, but she didn't expect to have to drop it in addition to having to leave the Academy.
After leaving the hospital, she had to sign her separation papers. Any of us would be blessed to have a fraction of the strength that she had to muster in order to put pen to paper. I can’t imagine how hard that moment was for her. Today, she is having surgery to put in an implantable cardioverter defibrillator (ICD) - at 19. She absolutely did not want to leave. She wanted to go Marine ground and fight the fight. From what was almost her deathbed, she was pleading with the O-6 Brigade Medical Officer for any opportunity stay and fight. We know that in the grand scheme, many are much worse off and that she'll have a relatively normal life. Tough for a 19 year old to see past what has been taken away, but we know she'll get there.
So, to the OP's question - there are worst-case scenarios that would "prevent deployment to austere environments", thus rendering one non-commissionable. If it happens later in the Academy career, presumably after 2-for-7, there are rare opportunities to graduate but not commission. Earlier than that (especially in Plebe summer) it can lead to separation. For less severe scenarios, where one would still be deployable, but just not able to complete Plebe Summer, as others have said, that Mid would simply be rolled to next year's class (assume all else remains good to go - academics, character, etc.)
As a side note, we’ve gained some insight into how hard the detailers work and how much they care for our Plebes. They were rotating shifts all week to sit by DD's bedside 24/7, and told us that they considered it an honor to do so. These kids (yes - detailers are still just kids) are amazing and are by far the hardest working people on the Yard during Plebe Summer. What a fantastic leadership experience for them. I assure you, they want only the best for the Plebes. We are so thankful for the medical team that found the issue and kept her with us, and for the amazing people at the Academy. The respect and honor that they have paid to DD has been truly incredible.
This community has been great as well. If I can every help anyone with perspective on the Foundation program or, unfortunately, the medical separation process, please do not hesitate to reach out.
Some of you may know about this from the parent FB groups, so my apologies for any duplication.
Last Saturday (the day before our first scheduled plebe phone call), my phone lit up w/DD's caller ID. Uh oh, I thought. This can't be good. Well, it wasn't. Turns out that she had a near-fatal cardiac episode in the Hall. I'll skip all of the details here, but she ended up spending a week in the Anne Arundel Medical Center and was released last Thursday and forced to return home.
Thank God that her life was saved, but sadly, she has been deemed her “non-commissionable”. So, after years of hard work (including a USNA Foundation prep year), making the cut and earning her spot in the Brigade, swearing the Oath of Office, and beginning (and crushing, according to the detailers) Plebe Summer, it is now gone - poof! To add insult to injury, we found out yesterday (7/15) that her competitive rowing career is over as well (she'd been recruited by all of the "big" rowing schools and, perhaps naively, thought that may still be an option in her new non-Academy life). She would have gladly dropped rowing in an instant in order to serve, but she didn't expect to have to drop it in addition to having to leave the Academy.
After leaving the hospital, she had to sign her separation papers. Any of us would be blessed to have a fraction of the strength that she had to muster in order to put pen to paper. I can’t imagine how hard that moment was for her. Today, she is having surgery to put in an implantable cardioverter defibrillator (ICD) - at 19. She absolutely did not want to leave. She wanted to go Marine ground and fight the fight. From what was almost her deathbed, she was pleading with the O-6 Brigade Medical Officer for any opportunity stay and fight. We know that in the grand scheme, many are much worse off and that she'll have a relatively normal life. Tough for a 19 year old to see past what has been taken away, but we know she'll get there.
So, to the OP's question - there are worst-case scenarios that would "prevent deployment to austere environments", thus rendering one non-commissionable. If it happens later in the Academy career, presumably after 2-for-7, there are rare opportunities to graduate but not commission. Earlier than that (especially in Plebe summer) it can lead to separation. For less severe scenarios, where one would still be deployable, but just not able to complete Plebe Summer, as others have said, that Mid would simply be rolled to next year's class (assume all else remains good to go - academics, character, etc.)
As a side note, we’ve gained some insight into how hard the detailers work and how much they care for our Plebes. They were rotating shifts all week to sit by DD's bedside 24/7, and told us that they considered it an honor to do so. These kids (yes - detailers are still just kids) are amazing and are by far the hardest working people on the Yard during Plebe Summer. What a fantastic leadership experience for them. I assure you, they want only the best for the Plebes. We are so thankful for the medical team that found the issue and kept her with us, and for the amazing people at the Academy. The respect and honor that they have paid to DD has been truly incredible.
This community has been great as well. If I can every help anyone with perspective on the Foundation program or, unfortunately, the medical separation process, please do not hesitate to reach out.
Thanks for the update and perspective. I have heard about your DDs story... she is a strong one. I can’t imagine her dreams being shattered so much, but i am so glad she has come out the other side with a plan that will get her healthy! I know she will go on to do great things and will find a new passion! Best of luck to her.
Last edited:
AggieTexan
5-Year Member
- Joined
- Mar 1, 2019
- Messages
- 33
TheNimble1, I have also been following your daughter’s story and her posts on Instagram. She is truly an inspiration! I pray she finds another way to serve others because that is obviously her passion and what she’s been called to do.
- Joined
- Sep 27, 2008
- Messages
- 20,475
@TheNimble1
I am so proud of your daughter’s spirit and courage. She did not fail. I am also not surprised and am pleased to know her detailers and her chain of command were there for her. That is the nature of the military bond. She will always hold that family feeling, even as she finds her new path.
After recovery, rest and renewal, I hope your daughter considers applying her fine mind and warrior-athlete spirit to service in one of the Fed “ABC” agencies. Serving as a field operative would not be likely given her medical issue, but powerful minds and drive to serve are also needed in operations planning, logistics, cyber, intel analysis, forensics and many other fields. If she can’t be a door-kicker, she can have the backs of those who do. Many have college programs and internships. Here are just a few:
https://www.fbijobs.gov/students/undergrad
https://www.cia.gov/careers/student-opportunities
https://www.intelligencecareers.gov/nsa/nsastudents.html
I am so proud of your daughter’s spirit and courage. She did not fail. I am also not surprised and am pleased to know her detailers and her chain of command were there for her. That is the nature of the military bond. She will always hold that family feeling, even as she finds her new path.
After recovery, rest and renewal, I hope your daughter considers applying her fine mind and warrior-athlete spirit to service in one of the Fed “ABC” agencies. Serving as a field operative would not be likely given her medical issue, but powerful minds and drive to serve are also needed in operations planning, logistics, cyber, intel analysis, forensics and many other fields. If she can’t be a door-kicker, she can have the backs of those who do. Many have college programs and internships. Here are just a few:
https://www.fbijobs.gov/students/undergrad
https://www.cia.gov/careers/student-opportunities
https://www.intelligencecareers.gov/nsa/nsastudents.html
- Joined
- Apr 9, 2017
- Messages
- 9,287
@TheNumble1, I have also been following your DD’s story! She is quite the warrior. She will do GREAT things, not a doubt in my mind. My momma heart has thought about your family almost non-stop, praying for y’alls strength, wisdom, acceptance and peace.
#GoNavyBeatArmy
Member
- Joined
- Jul 31, 2019
- Messages
- 152
As a nurse practitioner, married to a heart surgeon that is responsible for implanting ICD’s, and a Mom of a competitive, elite rower, my heart is broken for your daughter’s unfortunate life threatening medical issue. Health is ALL the wealth one needs in life. While your daughter may feel she lost out on her dream, she has been spared her life, and WILL indeed take her grit and determination and forge a new and wonderful path in life. I will be praying for courage and strength as she processes her “new normal” yet, there is a special plan in her future, no doubt. God bless all of you.
TheNimble1
5-Year Member
- Joined
- Jun 1, 2018
- Messages
- 27
Sorry to hijack the thread, but I thought an update would be welcomed... With a new plan to work with elite athletes (and potentially military operators) as a sports scientist, DD has completed her undergrad work in kinesiology. She recently learned that she earned a teaching assistantship that will provide total funding for her grad school in the same field. From there, she'll pursue her Ph.D. (hopefully at Auburn University's Warrior Research Center) as she continues to forge the new path. Perhaps one day it comes full circle and she'll have the opportunity to return to USNA as a performance coach. We'll see...
Along the way, she's been coaching high school soccer (at her brother's school) and is head coach of a competitive U17 travel soccer team. Note - she was a high-level soccer player before she started rowing.
Here's the fun part... for her day job, she works as a firearms instructor where she leads programs that focus on helping new shooters and female shooters feel comfortable and confident in self-defense scenarios. To fill the competitive void, she's competing in, and climbing the ranks of, action shooting competitions (USPSA.) She's secured several sponsorships and will be competing at her first "nationals" this summer. Generally, things are kept anonymous here, but given the support we've received, I'm comfortable sharing her IG, if anyone is interested in keeping up with the new path: instagram.com/2AlphaGrace
What's also cool is news about her "little" brother. We're excited that DS will be attending NAPS this year with the intent to join the USNA class of '28 next summer. He was a football recruit with an offer from Army in-hand when the call came from Navy. It was a no-brainer for him and he wasted no time in shutting down the burgeoning recruiting process and committing to Navy.
My apologies for a poor job of responding to the support you showed 4 years ago, and thank you for indulging me here.
Along the way, she's been coaching high school soccer (at her brother's school) and is head coach of a competitive U17 travel soccer team. Note - she was a high-level soccer player before she started rowing.
Here's the fun part... for her day job, she works as a firearms instructor where she leads programs that focus on helping new shooters and female shooters feel comfortable and confident in self-defense scenarios. To fill the competitive void, she's competing in, and climbing the ranks of, action shooting competitions (USPSA.) She's secured several sponsorships and will be competing at her first "nationals" this summer. Generally, things are kept anonymous here, but given the support we've received, I'm comfortable sharing her IG, if anyone is interested in keeping up with the new path: instagram.com/2AlphaGrace
What's also cool is news about her "little" brother. We're excited that DS will be attending NAPS this year with the intent to join the USNA class of '28 next summer. He was a football recruit with an offer from Army in-hand when the call came from Navy. It was a no-brainer for him and he wasted no time in shutting down the burgeoning recruiting process and committing to Navy.
My apologies for a poor job of responding to the support you showed 4 years ago, and thank you for indulging me here.