OBTW,
One other question to ask all ROTC units, including SMCs.
What is your commissioning rate?
What you are looking for is how many made it through the 4 yrs. You may need to ask a follow up question of how many left because it wasn't for them, and how many academically couldn't handle it.
Usually to get a handle on which it is, you need to ask:
1. % of cadets that leave after freshman yr.
~~~This is usually a not for me issue
2. % of cadets that leave before Jr yr.
~~~ This is usually academic...not selected for SFT.
You may also want to ask when discussing SFT, if their unit has kept the cadets on scholarship even if not selected for SFT.
The CC has the ability to fight for the cadet with AFROTC HQ and try to keep them on scholarship. It happens, but don't assume that it happens often.
If they answer in numbers, always rephrase the question so you can find out %. For example, a det can say 0 for the retaining the scholarship, but only have 50 people in that yr group. Another det can say 4, but have 300, so in essence the odds are the same.
That is the only way you can compare them from the same perspective.
Finally,
To Parents.
REPEATING MYSELF so it is pounded into your cranium
Yes, meet with the CC with your child, BUT at a certain point excuse yourself and leave. Have a pre-planned meeting spot and time.
Let them have that private time. Children tend to act differently with a parent in the room. He may feel uncomfortable asking certain questions because you might "butt" in.
You will not be able to sit in on the ALO interview. You will not be able to sit in on the MOC interview (if they are applying SA). They will be a pro at this time regarding how to interact. Trust them.
It also does give them that freedom to walk the campus by themselves as a college kid. There is a feel to every campus and it is important for them to get a snippet of that feel. I can't tell you of any kid who given the opportunity to do this didn't walk away with at least one of their selections changing up or down on their list. This doesn't mean #1 will drop to number 5, but it may drop to number 3 or vise a verse.
Our DS did this and his number 1 dropped to number 2. His number 3 went to number 1. One of them went off the list completely, it was his safety. Ironically he never finished that application; April 15th rolled around and he got a Congrats letter. Selected with MERIT!
A good indication of if the list changed...meet them at the Student Union where you can grab a bite to eat while waiting for them. In almost every SU there is a book store. Before leaving ask them if they want to get a T-shirt. If they say no, than you know that this school is now on the bottom of the pile. Our DS only bought 3 shirts.
SJBD,
I forgot to say, this was for our DS back in 07/08 re:UNCCH. He was also a NMSF. His stats were match + (SAT was 1390, ACT was 33 or 34). I don't want you to walk in thinking that if it is a reach they will also do this. Plus, the system may have changed. Most IS colleges now are much more competitive now than they were 3-4 yrs ago.
Also, all posters should understand that some ROTC branches have an "in" with admissions, whereas the others on the same campus do not. It comes down to size. For example: If the school is not the host ROTC unit, they really don't have any pull. If they are incredibly big (%) of incoming freshman they will have a pull.
Look at VT. If you say on the application you will be in the CoC and ROTC (any branch), admissions gives you points for that. However, if you enter and drop out of ROTC before a certain date, VT can cut you loose. They accepted you on the condition you would be in ROTC and/or the CoC. Scholarship or no scholarship.
For many this is a problem.
1. They realize early on that their dream of what the military is and reality do not match, but because of that condition placed upon them they need to suffer through it for a yr.
2. They realize they chose the wrong branch, but are stuck for a yr before they can transfer over to the other branch.
Traditional colleges, will allow the student to drop out of ROTC in the 1st yr.