AcademyAspirant
Member
- Joined
- Jan 27, 2024
- Messages
- 62
Is the medical insurance info really required to apply for the SLE? There is a worry for medical fraud when (yes, not if) USMA is hacked.
So, hypothetically, if someone had no medical insurance, they wouldn't be allowed to attend? Also, the information required is rather specific and USMA's database won't be scrubbed if I don't get in, because that would be an enormous use of time.They (USMA) definitely need to know, and I assume your student will not be invited to SLE without insurance. Hopefully, the information is only noted as yes/no, and the details are saved later only when a student is invited and attends. None of my students over seven years have had issues with SLE and insurance information loss.
Been 6 days since I reached out with no response yet. How long do you think it would reasonably take her to respond?Yes, I believe both are likely. Admissions 'knows' the answers so I recommend that you reach out to them directly to address your questions and concerns. Let us know what you find out.
I'm hoping for an exception.Do you want to go SLE? Share the information that was requested.
If you are hoping for an exception, the military may not be right for you. It is about the herd and the needs of the Service versus the interests of the individual.I'm hoping for an exception.
TBH (and I could be misreading), but based upon the comment "except my parents see that my providing our medical insurance information is a risk for me as well as them, which is why they are being stingy."; it sounds like it is more of an issue with the parents.If you are hoping for an exception, the military may not be right for you. It is about the herd and the needs of the Service versus the interests of the individual.
Personally, I have no problem with it. However, my parents share none of those aspirations and releasing medical information online is as much their decision as mine, if not more. A good middle ground is, from my biased perspective, getting an exception/waiver of that, to the extent of just saying "will provide if needed." I do not have anywhere near the level of experience as the other members, which is why I'm asking if that would be acceptable.If you are hoping for an exception, the military may not be right for you. It is about the herd and the needs of the Service versus the interests of the individual.
Sure, it’s ok to ask. One can always ask. But be prepared for the answer to be ‘no’. Or not selected. There are plenty of applicants to select from. And SLE is a recruiting tool more than an opinion on you as a competitive candidate.Personally, I have no problem with it. However, my parents share none of those aspirations and releasing medical information online is as much their decision as mine, if not more. A good middle ground is, from my biased perspective, getting an exception/waiver of that, to the extent of just saying "will provide if needed." I do not have anywhere near the level of experience as the other members, which is why I'm asking if that would be acceptable.
I think it's important to not conflate medical insurance information with medical information. The academy isn't asking for your EHR. The intent is to confirm that each participant has medical insurance coverage. As for security concerns, the portal is meant to be very secure. Also, if I'm not mistaken, applicants have to provide their SSN (please correct me if I'm wrong), which is much more sensitive than information re: insurance coverage. As stated by other posters, it's a personal decision and one can ask for an exception. If you are indeed, interested in SLE, it would be a shame for this to be the reason you aren't able to participate. My DS did SLE1 last summer and loved it. He had no real interest in the academy prior to SLE and now we're getting him ready for R-Day (exactly 38 years to the day after my own R-Day).Personally, I have no problem with it. However, my parents share none of those aspirations and releasing medical information online is as much their decision as mine, if not more. A good middle ground is, from my biased perspective, getting an exception/waiver of that, to the extent of just saying "will provide if needed." I do not have anywhere near the level of experience as the other members, which is why I'm asking if that would be acceptable.
Congratulations, and thank youI think it's important to not conflate medical insurance information with medical information. The academy isn't asking for your EHR. The intent is to confirm that each participant has medical insurance coverage. As for security concerns, the portal is meant to be very secure. Also, if I'm not mistaken, applicants have to provide their SSN (please correct me if I'm wrong), which is much more sensitive than information re: insurance coverage. As stated by other posters, it's a personal decision and one can ask for an exception. If you are indeed, interested in SLE, it would be a shame for this to be the reason you aren't able to participate. My DS did SLE1 last summer and loved it. He had no real interest in the academy prior to SLE and now we're getting him ready for R-Day (exactly 38 years to the day after my own R-Day).
Good luck to you