Negativity at the USAFA?

*If your cadet is a Division I athlete, their responsibilites within their squads and their interaction with their squads may be much different than the other cadets'. Sometimes, these cadets are not sure just where they fit in - all they know is that they don't have enough time for anything. And, that is not just for the 4-degree year.
 
..It seemed you were trying to say that you thought most of the cadets left before Recognition and not too many after.
That is the point I was trying to make. I did not realize that almost half of the losses occurred after Recognition and I appreciate you explaining it to me. :thumb:
 
This is added on for those lurking and reading who plan to be at USAFA:
Be prepared it is quite an adjustment to go from big smart fish in your high school pond to end up in the SA pond where EVERYONE got there by being in the top 10 percent of their class.
Don't be discouraged. You aren't going to love every minute of ANY college experience.
Relax and do the best that you can. Don't compare yourself to your peers.
To quote someone else: The race is long and in the end it is only with yourself.
Keep sight of your own goals.
Like many others on this board having been there and done that I can guarantee you that many of the generals leading were not in the top ten percent of their graduating class. It was the other things they brought to the table that advanced their careers.
 
Last edited:
Like many others on this board having been there and done that I can guarantee you that many of the generals leading were not in the top ten percent of their graduating class. It was the other things they brought to the table that advanced their careers.

Actually, that's not really true about the generals. The Econ or BS department did a study of generals who were USAFA grads. In >95% of cases, generals were: anywhere in PEA, top 10% MPA and top 25% GPA. While not always top 10% overall, most were quite close. USAFA was a good indicator for which groups were most likely to become generals.
 
Actually, that's not really true about the generals. The Econ or BS department did a study of generals who were USAFA grads. In >95% of cases, generals were: anywhere in PEA, top 10% MPA and top 25% GPA. While not always top 10% overall, most were quite close. USAFA was a good indicator for which groups were most likely to become generals.

I don't want to name names, but I do speak from experience. :smile:
Unfortunately sometimes even the best and brightest get passed over to the shock of many.
edited to add:
I don't want to argue, so I will rephrase: Not everyone in the top 10 percent will be promoted to General.
I still stand by my statement that many generals were not in the top 10 percent.
 
Last edited:
I don't want to name names, but I do speak from experience. :smile:
Unfortunately sometimes even the best and brightest get passed over to the shock of many.
edited to add:
I don't want to argue, so I will rephrase: Not everyone in the top 10 percent will be promoted to General.
I still stand by my statement that many generals were not in the top 10 percent.

I will stand by, at least, that almost all were at least top 10% MPA. Yes yes, graduating well at the USAFA is hardly a guarantee!

While the generals who were an exception to the rule tend to be remembered more, the findings show that generals showed their "talent" early at USAFA and the rags to riches story is the exception, not very common. This is based on the actual numbers.
 
This is added on for those lurking and reading who plan to be at USAFA:

Don't be discouraged. You aren't going to love every minute of ANY college experience.

*Lurks* :bleh2:

I actually hadn't thought of this before. It makes sense though!
 
Generals who were an exception to the rule tend to be remembered more, the findings show that generals showed their "talent" early at USAFA and the rags to riches story is the exception, not very common. This is based on the actual numbers.

Rags to riches? I would not choose to use that comparison when talking about any graduate of a SA. There is a lot of hard work involved in the process. Certainly you remember the old joke, What do you call the last member of your graduating class? Yep, 2nd Lieutenant. It is a level playing field upon graduation. While I agree, it doesn't look hopeful for the guy numbered last, I would be remiss not to say, "Don't ever under estimate the intelligence of your peers regardless of their GPA."

****The wife said that I am swaying off topic. I posted on this thread to offer encouragement so I should get back to the subject matter. She said she knows you from other boards and that you are a good kid. I wish you the best with your service career.
 
Last edited:
Rags to riches? I would not choose to use that comparison when talking about any graduate of a SA. There is a lot of hard work involved in the process. Certainly you remember the old joke, What do you call the last member of your graduating class? Yep, 2nd Lieutenant. It is a level playing field upon graduation. While I agree, it doesn't look hopeful for the guy numbered last, I would be remiss not to say, "Don't ever under estimate the intelligence of your peers regardless of their GPA."

****The wife said that I am swaying off topic. I posted on this thread to offer encouragement so I should get back to the subject matter. She said she knows you from other boards and that you are a good kid. I wish you the best with your service career.

The thing is; first impression in the military matter just as much as in the "Real World". A 2Lt graduating in the top-10% of their academy class WILL be recognized for that at their first duty station/assignment; and/or additional training. e.g. UPT. Of course, what you do with that after you get there,

Also, while you might not use the "Rags to Riches" statement when talking about about any graduate of the academy; I think it's safe to say that I personally wouldn't call a graduate of the air force academy a "Good Kid". But that's just me. I know you didn't mean anything negative with that; just like I'm sure that hornet didn't mean anything negative about comparing the O-1 to O-7 assent as "Riches" compared to to the O-1 who only made it to O-5. They're just analogies; nothing derogatory.
 
The thing is; first impression in the military matter just as much as in the "Real World". A 2Lt graduating in the top-10% of their academy class WILL be recognized for that at their first duty station/assignment; and/or additional training. e.g. UPT. Of course, what you do with that after you get there,

Also, while you might not use the "Rags to Riches" statement when talking about about any graduate of the academy; I think it's safe to say that I personally wouldn't call a graduate of the air force academy a "Good Kid". But that's just me. I know you didn't mean anything negative with that; just like I'm sure that hornet didn't mean anything negative about comparing the O-1 to O-7 assent as "Riches" compared to to the O-1 who only made it to O-5. They're just analogies; nothing derogatory.

What you say is true. I just go back from a walk and was reflecting upon this back and forth and realized there is so much more to say on that topic, but this just isn't/wasn't the place to delve into the "deep selecting" "last man standing" etc. And again, you are right I didn't mean to come off as condescending to hornet guy. My wife already berated me. The point is, there is a lot that happens between graduation and the twilight of your career. I think I will leave the boards to my wife from here on out.

In the mean time, my original message was meant to encourage incoming appointees. And I stand by that. There is nothing like walking across the stage at the end of 4 with your degree in hand knowing what you accomplished regardless of where you ranked in the class, and that was my original post and point.
Aim high, aim for the sky.
 
You are definitely correct. This subject; in similar context; happens here a lot with the appointees who received an LOA, an early appointment, the normal March/April selection, had 1 nomination vs 4 nominations, etc... When the dust settles, and you get on the bus at the AOG and take the oath the next morning; every single person there is "CADET".

Same with Academy, vs ROTC, vs OTS. When you graduate your college/university, and are finally commissioned, you are all "Lieutenant".

Now; are there some "Unofficial" perks or opinions of officers who went to the academy vs ROTC/OTS? Yes, most definitely. I won't get into actuals, but "Unofficially", there definitely is. Also; unofficially, there will be perceptions and opinions, as well as "Expectations" upon the Academy grad who graduated in the top-10% of their class. This doesn't mean that if you were at the 50% mark that you can't become an O-7, test pilot, astronaut, JCS, etc... We all know that 1,2,5,10,20 years of excellent performance can be erased with one stupid act such as DWI, Drugs, black marketing, etc... The top-10% academy graduate has an additional kudo to start off their career, but it's what you do with it that will matter. And that means immediately. You can't just sit back for 4-6 years of service and think you can live off of the laurels of having graduated in the top-10% of your academy class. You'll have the perception and first impression on your side if you graduate in the top-10%. But after that perception and impression, it's totally up to you.
 
Not to sway this even further off topic:

She said she knows you from other boards and that you are a good kid

I'd be more than happy to say that I can wholeheartedly confirm that statement, but I wouldn't want this young Lt to get too big a head. It ruins the balance when you surf, right Hornet? :thumb:
 
Rags to riches? I would not choose to use that comparison when talking about any graduate of a SA. There is a lot of hard work involved in the process. Certainly you remember the old joke, What do you call the last member of your graduating class? Yep, 2nd Lieutenant. It is a level playing field upon graduation. While I agree, it doesn't look hopeful for the guy numbered last, I would be remiss not to say, "Don't ever under estimate the intelligence of your peers regardless of their GPA."

****The wife said that I am swaying off topic. I posted on this thread to offer encouragement so I should get back to the subject matter. She said she knows you from other boards and that you are a good kid. I wish you the best with your service career.

lol no worries, I am neither offended nor upset. It's refreshing to have a discussion civilly on these boards. ;) Even if CC says I'm not a good kid, I am. I like my toys. :biggrin:

I guess I didn't expect my analogy of rags to riches to be so ambiguous. I'll be a tad more specific. The likelihood that a lower 25% graduate, especially the particularly cynical ones out there, is low that they will hit O-7, by the numbers! There are exceptions out there (and they weren't hesitant to let anyone know during visits!). I certainly hope you're not one of those exceptions and feel offended by my statements. I'm not trying to logically argue this point, I really wouldn't try to speculate on the outcome because everyone brings so much to the table in our service (Lance Sijan, first USAFA MOH recipient was considered a huge jerk as a cadet and graduated very low, but he had some cojones!). Based strictly on the numbers collected by USAFA, it is very unlikely that anyone ranked low will reach general and those that do/did were usually exceptions to the rule.

Side-note, the last graduate as a LT. True. Also get hit with the RIFs much quicker. But also, that reputation does follow them. If they were not hard workers and were just a crap cadet and ended there, their career and peer reputation usually follows and life is a bit harder. I was shocked, when talking to grads, how much a person's academy reputation followed them. LtGen Rice, when I visited Yokota, told us a story about how he got a job as a Captain based on his reputation at USAFA as a cadet, a job which was probably the door which led the path to his stars.

Anywho, don't leave the forums. I'm not one to bite your head off! I will also eat my words in a heartbeat if I am proven wrong (part of being a scientist, and also a result of working in a place like RAND). I seek the truth and won't fight to the bitter end on what is a loosing argument just to try and save face. I don't know your background at all. If you have stories and info, share! (if comfortable). I have learned so much from my interactions with others in the world that my decisions changed drastically. (I had some long talks with Bullet and Pima at their home and on the phone, helped form my decision to ditch med school for the grad school/pilot track). I'm a habitual student, feed this LT some knowledge!
 
Not to sway this even further off topic:



I'd be more than happy to say that I can wholeheartedly confirm that statement, but I wouldn't want this young Lt to get too big a head. It ruins the balance when you surf, right Hornet? :thumb:

Lol, sadly I haven't surfed since I got here. I'm slacking!!!

And I won't be able to get out of my apartment for a few hours after your comment, something about my cranium and the door.... Maybe another shot of weed with you will solve it! :eek: Speaking of, ever had a shot of 100 degree F weed? My bud at med school at UVA left it in his trunk and decided we needed to do a shot of it. I think it ate through half of my esophagus on the way down. Took burn to the next level.

P.S. still have that snazzy bulle(i)t bourbon taunting me on my liquor shelf. :yllol:
 
Lol, sadly I haven't surfed since I got here. I'm slacking!!!

And I won't be able to get out of my apartment for a few hours after your comment, something about my cranium and the door.... Maybe another shot of weed with you will solve it! :eek: Speaking of, ever had a shot of 100 degree F weed? My bud at med school at UVA left it in his trunk and decided we needed to do a shot of it. I think it ate through half of my esophagus on the way down. Took burn to the next level.

P.S. still have that snazzy bulle(i)t bourbon taunting me on my liquor shelf. :yllol:

Brother.... Do you know how many brain cells you probably killed??? :biggrin: The main reason for freezing weed is to kill the critters. LOL!!! Actually, I prefer it refrigerated but not necessarily from the freezer. Although, we did try freezing some with liquid nitrogen once. Poured it out of the bottle into a tupperware bowl and tried freezing it. Made a nice Popsicle, but it didn't tast very good as we let it thaw. yuk!!!

By the way; I expect you to come to a falcon football game next fall and join us at Thudgate for some weed. The Army game is at home. That would be a good one.
 
Hornetguy & Christcorp: Thanks for your contributions to the thread topic.
 
Back
Top