I have an almost identical story to the one above. I was a recruited athlete last year to Navy (Soccer), but in the end I chose not to follow through and therefore did not receive an appointment. I instead attended a 4-year private college, excelled in plebe-like courses (Chemistry, Calculus, English, History and Military Science), received a 4-year full Army ROTC Active Duty Scholarship and reapplied to Navy as well as the other 4 academies. So far I have received appointments to 4 of the 5 academies and I am waiting to here from one other. My choice has already been made, but the real moral of this story is hard work and "persistence", (well said EAGLE-PRIDE), pays off.
Even if I had been denied from the Academies I would still be in a great position to continue my education and pursuit of becoming a great Military officer. So, to sum it all up, don't be discouraged by not receiving a nomination. Thousands of great applicants like yourself are in the same boat. But it is those with a true desire and passion that continue to strive to be the best and to not lose hope on their dreams. Best of luck to you all.
USMC8
USNA 2017 Appointee