NROTC MO Essay #1 Review

tman9285

Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2017
Messages
68
Hey guys, I have a first draft of an essay and I would like to see what you all think of it. Please feel free to be brutally honest:

Discuss your reasons for wanting to become a Marine Officer. Specifically comment on leadership positions you've held, the challenges you have faced and the lessons you have learned. (Limit 2500 characters)


For as long as I can remember, I have always looked up to the military as my calling in life. There was something I saw about the way a military member carried him or herself whenever they were around at a family function or school activity, which is best described as commanding. As a child, I always wanted to defend my country and be part of something bigger than myself. Even now, that is my focus in life, as I have no desire to make the most money out of my peers or have the most fun. To me, the most selfless people are the most admirable, and I want to be one of those people. My fulfillment will come from when I can say that I helped people in my life and tested my limits in doing so. I find it most fulfilling to use my talents to work with and lead others. I feel like I would do all of these things best through leading Marines as a Marine officer.

After school and sports, service is perhaps an activity that takes more time than any other activity, and perhaps one of the most time-consuming of my activities is St. Michael’s Church Retreat Team. This Retreat Team organizes Confirmation retreats for high school students and it’s led by the youth minister in partnership with a group of teens who were already confirmed in the Church. We make the schedule, decide who gives the witness talks, and rehearse skits. I have another responsibility, which is music. I plan out which songs to play, organize the band to play those songs, and take the role of guitar player in that band. I take great joy in being able to use my talents not only lead my peers in something but also in bettering the spiritual experience of the Confirmation students. However, Retreat Team was no easy job, especially when our youth minister last year was a rather difficult leader to deal with. Our group often times put up with her strong will, requiring us to use our best tact in order to convince her that her ideas were perhaps misguided. However, I find that having difficult leaders allows you to learn what not to do as a leader, which is a valuable lesson in itself. I soon discovered …With all of this in mind, Retreat Team has taught me much about leadership, from delegating work to meticulous planning to the exercise of tact and even how to guide others.

With these experiences under my belt, I hope to become the effective officer that the Marine Corps wants and needs. Furthermore, I hope that I will have the privilege of using my talents and skills to serve others in the Marine Corps.
 
Very little, if anything, on why you want to be a Marine officer as opposed to Army, Navy, AF etc.
I hate making comments on these things but that's what jumps out at me. Good luck with your application.
 
Agree with Kinnem, the same essay could be used for any other branch by replacing "Marine" with "Sailor" or the like. Focus on what makes the Corps unique, and how that aligns with your own goals of service and patriotism. refrain from the cookie cutter type essay
 
For as long as I can remember, I have always looked up to the military as my calling in life.

This opening sentence....or a similar incarnation of it, is severely overused on these essays.

Please try to grab the reader with something insightful but also original. The first impression is so important, make it count.

Good luck!
 
Last edited:
To tman: You’ve gotten good advice above. Make the essay your own — unique, genuine, authentic. Say what you want to say, not what you think the readers want to hear. It’s hard to stand out if your essay, especially the opening, is generic, cookie-cutter, vanilla.

Which brings up this point: Turn to friends, teachers and family to critique your essay. They know you best. You’ll get mainly basic feedback here, because we don’t know you and what makes you tick. Best wishes to you.
 
I almost always advise to avoid hyperbole, because that starts mental eyerolls in readers’ minds - and I see @AROTC-dad commented on the same phrase. It’s similar to those who write “all my life I have wanted X....”

Presumably, you have your earliest memories of, say, being a toddler and perhaps remembering your first pony ride or ice cream cone. So, as far back as that, you looked upon the military as your calling? Scary kid! This is meant as gentle feedback - it’s more interesting to read a unique story, and it gives a better picture of you when it’s something like: “I was around 8 when I saw someone in uniform at my church, and I asked my Dad about her. She looked so perfect in her uniform, and stood so straight. After that, I always noticed people I uniform, and read about the military, and my interest in the military was formed. I met a retired Marine Sergeant Major at my school 3 years ago, and after hearing of his experiences, and his stories of leadership and service, that’s exactly when I knew the goal I wanted to pursue - a path to service as a Marine officer.“
 
Last edited:
Hat’s off to Capt MJ. I look forward to the day when my DD can inspire a little boy or girl by the way she wears her uniform and carries herself — with pride, confidence, humbleness and humility.
 
That’s good to hear, tman9285. Not often that candidates circle back to the thread they started, to update folks on how things turned out. That’s thoughtful and mature. Now go have your essay reviewed by a couple grownups who’ll be honest and frank. Best wishes to you.
 
I just had my interview as a matter of fact after my first PFT (I will retake), where I did 20 pull ups 80 crunches (main reason for retaking) and running 3 miles in 20:29. There were TWO questions I had an issue answering mainly because I couldn't think of an example of any instances, so I'm sort of worried. Otherwise, I'm pretty sure I got my points across clearly and showed at least some potential for being a good future leader, but you never know.
 
I just had my interview as a matter of fact after my first PFT (I will retake), where I did 20 pull ups 80 crunches (main reason for retaking) and running 3 miles in 20:29. There were TWO questions I had an issue answering mainly because I couldn't think of an example of any instances, so I'm sort of worried. Otherwise, I'm pretty sure I got my points across clearly and showed at least some potential for being a good future leader, but you never know.

tman, I second the post thanking you for returning to post after getting some feedback.

As long as one of the interview questions you wobbled on wasn’t the variation on “what are your character flaws or weaknesses, and how do you counteract them?”.... There’s always someone who is stumped by that, which doesn’t speak well for their self-knowledge.

You’re not expected to answer everything perfectly. It’s more annoying to get someone who is overly slick and rehearsed, with rote answers. Though I don’t do these interviews, I have done enough interviewing in uniform and in the corporate world to know which comes across as more genuine.
 
tman, I second the post thanking you for returning to post after getting some feedback.

As long as one of the interview questions you wobbled on wasn’t the variation on “what are your character flaws or weaknesses, and how do you counteract them?”.... There’s always someone who is stumped by that, which doesn’t speak well for their self-knowledge.

You’re not expected to answer everything perfectly. It’s more annoying to get someone who is overly slick and rehearsed, with rote answers. Though I don’t do these interviews, I have done enough interviewing in uniform and in the corporate world to know which comes across as more genuine.[/QUOTE]

Thanks for the help there, the questions I kinda choked on were "describe a time where you had to sacrifice your own success for the good of a group" as well as "describe a time where your decision had a negative impact on others" (basically a failure in leadership), and I really couldn't think of anything off of the top of my head. Those were the two toughest questions of the whole interview in my opinion.
 
I just had my interview as a matter of fact after my first PFT (I will retake), where I did 20 pull ups 80 crunches (main reason for retaking) and running 3 miles in 20:29. There were TWO questions I had an issue answering mainly because I couldn't think of an example of any instances, so I'm sort of worried. Otherwise, I'm pretty sure I got my points across clearly and showed at least some potential for being a good future leader, but you never know.
Good PFT!
 
I almost always advise to avoid hyperbole, because that starts mental eyerolls in readers’ minds - and I see @AROTC-dad commented on the same phrase. It’s similar to those who write “all my life I have wanted X....”

Presumably, you have your earliest memories of, say, being a toddler and perhaps remembering your first pony ride or ice cream cone. So, as far back as that, you looked upon the military as your calling? Scary kid! This is meant as gentle feedback - it’s more interesting to read a unique story, and it gives a better picture of you when it’s something like: “I was around 8 when I saw someone in uniform at my church, and I asked my Dad about her. She looked so perfect in her uniform, and stood so straight. After that, I always noticed people I uniform, and read about the military, and my interest in the military was formed. I met a retired Marine Sergeant Major at my school 3 years ago, and after hearing of his experiences, and his stories of leadership and service, that’s exactly when I knew the goal I wanted to pursue - a path to service as a Marine officer.“

Exactly what I thought, my daughter was given the same feedback (first from me, but she didn't take it, it was a ROO who was the smart and insightful one - as it should be), I totally agree a firsthand story instead of "the idea" of something has so much more impact!
 
My son was also unable to think of an example of a time he had to sacrifice his success for the good of a group when he got that question in his interview. He was worried about that but thought the rest of the interview went very well. He did get the scholarship so I don’t think it’s a dealbreaker if you falter a bit on one question.
 
My son was also unable to think of an example of a time he had to sacrifice his success for the good of a group when he got that question in his interview. He was worried about that but thought the rest of the interview went very well. He did get the scholarship so I don’t think it’s a dealbreaker if you falter a bit on one question.

Clearly, it is better to be honest and speak the truth than to make up a "story" about sacrifice.
 
Back
Top