Reapplying to USNA (after a turndown)

USNA1985- Thank you for this summary. My son applied to USNA last year (2020), was a very strong candidate (athletics,leadership, academics and scores are all very strong), had two nominations but was rejected for a minor color vision deficiency. He was also awared an NROTC scholarship- but it was rescinded due to color vision deficiency. He accepted a position at a very good 4 year engineering school and is currently a MechE major and a 4/c midshipman in the NROTC unit at that school (college program). He has reapplied to USNA in hopes of a medical waiver- he received a nomination and reccomendation from his NROTC CO and a nomination from his local congressman. He has done very well academically while taking 20 credits and devoting time to NROTC. He has also distinguished himself physicaly in his unit and has improved his last year's physical test score (he is a long distance runner). He has also participated in his student government as while at college. he is passionate about attending USNA and motivated to serve. He would be a third generation naval officer (his Uncle was USNA82 , Grandfather enlisted in 1949 while college - both were career Naval aviators and retired after 26+ years of service). He is aware of what this commitment implies.
So- the big question: Does he have a better chance of getting a waiver on the second try? Will his tenacity be noticed and considered? is there anything else that he can do?
I am very fortunate and I have received a USNA color vision waiver and I now have an appointment. They are being granted this year! I am still under waiver review for the 4 year Naval ROTC scholarship.
 
My DS is a college re-applicant and received a color vision waiver this time. He is waiting to see if he receives an Appointment.
 
My DS is a college re-applicant and received a color vision waiver this time. He is waiting to see if he receives an Appointment.

Under what circumstances does a color blind waiver get approved and no appointment is offered?
 
Under what circumstances does a color blind waiver get approved and no appointment is offered?
One factor is the future needs of the Navy. Many officer billets/communities need to see color (e.g. SWO, Subs for bouys, and navigation lights). So I believe, if the Navy projects enough need for officer communities that do not require color eyesight, there could be more appoints of candidates with color limitations.

I edited this posting to be more accurate.
 
Last edited:
One factor is the future needs of the Navy. Many officer billets/communities need to see color (e.g. SWO, Subs for bouys, and navigation lights). So I believe. if the Navy projects enough need for Limited Duty Officers (such as Supply Officers and others), there could be more opportunity to appoint candidates with color limitations.

Yes, but they are capped at like 2% by law (or whatever it is).

I guess what I was assuming was USNA isn’t going to go through and approve a color blind waiver (Supe approved) - and not offer the appointment. Should have just denied the waiver.
 
Should I select a major the academy offers to serve as my primary focus while at the university I transfer to?
 
Should I select a major the academy offers to serve as my primary focus while at the university I transfer to?
Have you considered focusing and excelling in the core STEM and other core classes that all MIDN, regardless of major, have to complete? Also, what are your plan B, C, D- especially in regards to other pathways to serving as a naval or as an officer in another branch of service?
 
Have you considered focusing and excelling in the core STEM and other core classes that all MIDN, regardless of major, have to complete? Also, what are your plan B, C, D- especially in regards to other pathways to serving as a naval or as an officer in another branch of service?
That’s what I’m trying to figure out. I’d have to declare a major prior to transferring so I can take those courses chem, calc, physics etc. Looking for schools with NROTC programs as that’s a good backup plan.
 
That’s what I’m trying to figure out. I’d have to declare a major prior to transferring so I can take those courses chem, calc, physics etc. Looking for schools with NROTC programs as that’s a good backup plan.
I believe there's some specific guidance out there for college applicants, I'd recommend doing some queries to find that info. I am going out on a limb and assuming that they are going to look for similar (maybe not identical) characteristics and achievements (scholastic, athletic, leadership etc etc etc) as they do for a HS applicant.
 
I believe there's some specific guidance out there for college applicants, I'd recommend doing some queries to find that info. I am going out on a limb and assuming that they are going to look for similar (maybe not identical) characteristics and achievements (scholastic, athletic, leadership etc etc etc) as they do for a HS applicant.
Makes sense. I know it’ll be a unique contrast of hs NJROTC as anyone could join. Maybe that’ll help having that prior experience? Thank you for the advice!
 
Given where I presently stand, all the prerequisites for the STEM courses admissions wants will not be completed until spring the same semester as graduation. Though my Associates will be in hand, I’m going to have to pay for the actual courses ( calc, chem etc) out of pocket as they are not part of my degree. My concern is they will not be on my transcript and therefore will not be on my application. Can anyone speak on this?
 
why would they not be on your transcript? i'm assuming you're taking these extra classes at the same school? if not, you would have a transcript for the school where you take the classes, and you would send that. this is assuming you take the classes in the fall semester.

taking them in the spring won't help you for this cycle because decisions will be made before you finish the class
 
why would they not be on your transcript? i'm assuming you're taking these extra classes at the same school? if not, you would have a transcript for the school where you take the classes, and you would send that. this is assuming you take the classes in the fall semester.

taking them in the spring won't help you for this cycle because decisions will be made before you finish the class
Because I won’t be able to take the actual courses until after graduation as explained above… ( ran into this issue last cycle) yes following graduation I will pay out of pocket to take the necessary STEM courses to hopefully improve my level of competitiveness. Won’t have the pre recs done until spring. Correct I’d have an answer the month before graduation. However, this is the only way I can get them done.
 
Because I won’t be able to take the actual courses until after graduation as explained above… ( ran into this issue last cycle) yes following graduation I will pay out of pocket to take the necessary STEM courses to hopefully improve my level of competitiveness. Won’t have the pre recs done until spring. Correct I’d have an answer the month before graduation. However, this is the only way I can get them done.
I'm not sure what you're concerned about here. The vast majority of our candidates are taking required courses that are not complete until after the admissions cycle. Example: Many of our most competitive candidates are taking AP Calculus and they will not have final grades or the AP test grades until well after USNA either offers them admission or not.
 
I'm not sure what you're concerned about here. The vast majority of our candidates are taking required courses that are not complete until after the admissions cycle. Example: Many of our most competitive candidates are taking AP Calculus and they will not have final grades or the AP test grades until well after USNA either offers them admission or
I'm not sure what you're concerned about here. The vast majority of our candidates are taking required courses that are not complete until after the admissions cycle. Example: Many of our most competitive candidates are taking AP Calculus and they will not have final grades or the AP test grades until well after USNA either offers them admission or not.
Just figured it would be frowned upon sir, I’ve been told how important they are in admissions eyes especially for college reapplicants and just want to be certain I’m on the right track. It’s good to know that it won’t now!
 
Just figured it would be frowned upon sir, I’ve been told how important they are in admissions eyes especially for college reapplicants and just want to be certain I’m on the right track. It’s good to know that it won’t now!
Did you see the reply above? that was why I thought otherwise sir.
 
Back
Top