DD got 4-year on this second board. Her un-weighted GPA is a 3.74 (weighted 4.3) and her ACT composite is a 29. Since so much goes into the selection process, like leadership, athletics, extracurricular, PFT, interview and survey, it is hard to compare just based on GPA and test scores.
I had 55 pushups, 52 situps, and 7:20 mile. For leadership I had various things like student council, boys state, volleyball captain, varsity soccer.
hopefully i get the 3rd board.
Make sure you are taking credit for EVERY activity you have done between 9-12. I think that is where my DD picked up a lot of points. She has 6 varsity letters (3 sports), 2 years captain, JROTC commander/officer/NCO (4 years), competitive cheer and dance for 8+ years, Beta (no NHC at her school), choir, drama, foreign language club, tutoring and part-time job for 2 years lifeguarding. Point is, go back and make sure you are giving yourself every possible point. She didn't get scholarship on first board and her ROO told her to go back and make sure she wasn't shorting herself. She made some updates for things she didn't feel were important originally (silly girl) and it may have been the difference this time around. There is no magic formula (if there is they certainly will never share it) so all you can do is put the very best you forward and enjoy the next few months of being a senior!