Each program performs its own waiver review.
There is no obligation for a 4 year Army ROTC scholarship until the first day of the second year. The obligation is waived if a cadet is appointed to an SA.
Yes. No pay back if appointed to an SA.
It depends on the cadet. Some yes, others no.
Last year, my DS played intramural soccer, worked as a snowboard instructor on weekends, did honor guard, cannon duty at football games, carried 15 semester units, and still made dean's list.
So, if I understand correctly, a student can start AROTC for a year. If decide it is not for them, they can leave without any obligation, even if they do not go to a SA? The information that he was told that once DS starts as a freshman, DS would owe 8 years to the Army - regardless.
Was you DS's ROTC program on campus or at another campus? Sounds like he had a great year.
What is AROTC like for a freshman as far a commitment? Does it vary from school to school. There has been little information provided thus far. They are working on the waiver for AROTC now. My DS is in contact with his SGT and a friend who went through the program at another school, but don't have a solid understanding of how it all works with school and sports.