Pima
10-Year Member
- Joined
- Nov 28, 2007
- Messages
- 13,900
I would also like to mention to everyone that I live in an EXTREMELY competitive district. Getting a nomination for USMMA would be much, much easier than USMA or USNA.
I think that is a fallacy. The fact is USMMA is much much smaller than USMA or USNA. (I think they only have about 400 per year group compared to 1000 for USNA and USMA). You can't take the leap that nobody else has had the exact same thought.
~ Yes, I know for USMMA you can apply to every cong. in the state, whereas for USNA/USMA you can only apply to your cong.
Using my premise of 535 MoCs, than for USMMA there is no national pool. USNA and USMA offer @1350 every year. Add the 100 Presidential, and you have about 700 that will be charged via different routes for the pool.
~ Typically competitive districts also have candidates with very competitive stats from a national aspect.
~~ VA MoCs talk. 1 nomination to 1 SA is the best that most can hope for when applying. Yet, come appointment time many come off the national list.
Thus, the old statement exists....all you need is that 1 nomination. I don't know the stats for % appointed for USMMA, but if it is like the sister services, @16%, than your chances are not any better with the USMMA over USNA and USMA even from a competitive district.
Finally, my DS got 3 noms in NC. The Senators did a nomination ceremony. The program for Sen. Dole listed one candidate that had both USMA and USMMA. Sen. Burr did not have any on more than one slate. Obviously, the MOCs did not talk.
Now here is why I see your flaw. Our DSs close friend applied and was appointed to USMMA. However, he did not receive a nomination from either Senator. This is a state where it is seen as not a competitive state, but it must have been competitive enough that he did not make the Senators cut.
Again, anyone that has researched USMMA knows they can apply to every MOC. I would think that many will apply to all of the MoCs or as many as they can to increase their chances. I would think that the kid in Fairfax VA would apply to the Cong. that covers Blacksburg VA, while they opt not to spend time and apply to the congressman that cover Richmond and Norfolk, especially Norfolk since many kids want the sea option.