Will my file not get reviewed?

[Flyer1700]

So as many have, I've had green checkmarks across the board everywhere... except for my CFA, which is still yellow. I submitted it months ago. West Point has this stated on the application overview:

"Once all application requirements are on file (marked with a

), including Nominations and 7th Semester Transcripts, your application file will enter the queue for committee review. During high peak times, it can take up to 60 days for files to reach the committee. You will be notified immediately of any committee decisions on your file."

This implies they won't even review my application until they get around to watching my CFA videos, and even if they do get around to it, it could take 60 days from then.

If I get that green check mark on March 1st, it could take 60 days for them to review my profile and give me a decision, which would be past April. It seems like they're giving me no shot, considering about 40% of the class of 2025 has received appointments. This rubs me the wrong way considering I completed my application months in advance and I'm not getting a shot to be reviewed when there's a good amount of slots left.

EDIT: This was not meant to sound like a big complain, more so I was hoping someone would be able to tell me whether my speculations are correct or not(I didn't make that clear at all with my tone)

Is the 60 days thing common? I'm just a little worried my application won't be reviewed in time and I'm curious if I'm wrong

 

[Korab]

So as many have, I've had green checkmarks across the board everywhere... except for my CFA, which is still yellow. I submitted it months ago. West Point has this stated on the application overview:

"Once all application requirements are on file (marked with a

), including Nominations and 7th Semester Transcripts, your application file will enter the queue for committee review. During high peak times, it can take up to 60 days for files to reach the committee. You will be notified immediately of any committee decisions on your file."

This implies they won't even review my application until they get around to watching my CFA videos, and even if they do get around to it, it could take 60 days from then.

If I get that green check mark on March 1st, it could take 60 days for them to review my profile and give me a decision, which would be past April. It seems like they're giving me no shot, considering about 40% of the class of 2025 has received appointments. This rubs me the wrong way considering I completed my application months in advance and I'm not getting a shot to be reviewed when there's a good amount of slots left.

Complaining here won't get anything done. Maybe try calling admissions with your complaints and see what kind of response you get.

 

[A1Janitor]

You are getting rubbed the wrong way by a scenario that is speculation on your part.

Like Korab said, I would call admissions. I wouldn’t be accusatory. I would be inquisitive.

 

[TheRightStuff]

....considering about 40% of the class of 2025 has received appointments.

Where did you see that number?

 

[Flyer1700]

Where did you see that number?

I'm pretty much guesstimating based off the appointment list, which is a pretty small sample size but it's probably relatively accurate

 

[Flyer1700]

You are getting rubbed the wrong way by a scenario that is speculation on your part.

Like Korab said, I would call admissions. I wouldn’t be accusatory. I would be inquisitive.

Thank you, I'm probably just going down that mental rabbit-hole of waiting. I don't mean to accuse admissions. They definitely know what they're doing considering they've done this so many times with great success

 

[TheRightStuff]

I'm pretty much guesstimating based off the appointment list, which is a pretty small sample size but it's probably relatively accurate

If the thought that 10% of admitted SA applicants are on SAF is at all accurate (a big "if"), then close to 85% of USMA appointments have been made (102 on the list now is 1020 of +/- 1200, although there may be more or less than 1200 appointments offered for 2025 in the end).

This is pure speculation though.

 

[Flyer1700]

If the thought that 10% of admitted SA applicants are on SAF is at all accurate (a big "if"), then close to 85% of USMA appointments have been made (102 on the list now is 1020 of +/- 1200, although there may be more or less than 1200 appointments offered for 2025 in the end).

This is pure speculation though.

Boy do I hope that's not the case! Although I'd be happy for the guys and gals who got in

 

[MCA]

Your CFA will be reviewed. If the academy wants you, they will offer you a letter of appointment. CFA reviews are delayed for almost all candidates.

The forum appointment list is a voluntary response from a very small sample size which introduces major bias and shouldn't be a source to draw major conclusions from. That would be bad statistics (BS).

I understand you are anxious but the reality is that it's barely the middle of February. Most appointments come out March - May. Be patient. I am in the same boat as you, but I am just being patient. It is key to learn how to manage your stress and compartmentalize your anxiety.

Good luck to you!

 

[jl123]

Be professional, be polite, be patient, but also be proactive.

It is probable that all is ok with your file submission, and the delay is just part of the waiting process. But there is also the possibility of an administrative oversight. If you're at about the 3 month time since the CFA was submitted, it should not be considered poor etiquette to check and confirm that admissions has everything they need to evaluate your file.

If you have not received any communication explaining why there might be such a long delay and if you have not already done so, send an email to your RC explaining that you have all green checks except for the CFA. State that you submitted the CFA and include the date submitted. Ask if there is anything else needed and express your desire to attend USMA.

 

[Flyer1700]

Your CFA will be reviewed. If the academy wants you, they will offer you a letter of appointment. CFA reviews are delayed for almost all candidates.

The forum appointment list is a voluntary response from a very small sample size which introduces major bias and shouldn't be a source to draw major conclusions from. That would be bad statistics (BS).

I understand you are anxious but the reality is that it's barely the middle of February. Most appointments come out March - May. Be patient. I am in the same boat as you, but I am just being patient. It is key to learn how to manage your stress and compartmentalize your anxiety.

Good luck to you!

Thank you my friend, helps with the peace of mind

 

[foxtail0520]

If the thought that 10% of admitted SA applicants are on SAF is at all accurate (a big "if"), then close to 85% of USMA appointments have been made (102 on the list now is 1020 of +/- 1200, although there may be more or less than 1200 appointments offered for 2025 in the end).

This is pure speculation though.

I've looked at 2024 appointment list and 2023 list as well and the trend is that more and more people are using this forum. Last year, there were almost 180 appointments listed on the thread so I wouldn't really speculate around 85% already got their appointments. It would be more around 60%.

 

[professorm804]

So as many have, I've had green checkmarks across the board everywhere... except for my CFA, which is still yellow. I submitted it months ago. West Point has this stated on the application overview:

"Once all application requirements are on file (marked with a

), including Nominations and 7th Semester Transcripts, your application file will enter the queue for committee review. During high peak times, it can take up to 60 days for files to reach the committee. You will be notified immediately of any committee decisions on your file."

This implies they won't even review my application until they get around to watching my CFA videos, and even if they do get around to it, it could take 60 days from then.

If I get that green check mark on March 1st, it could take 60 days for them to review my profile and give me a decision, which would be past April. It seems like they're giving me no shot, considering about 40% of the class of 2025 has received appointments. This rubs me the wrong way considering I completed my application months in advance and I'm not getting a shot to be reviewed when there's a good amount of slots left.

EDIT: This was not meant to sound like a big complain, more so I was hoping someone would be able to tell me whether my speculations are correct or not(I didn't make that clear at all with my tone)

Is the 60 days thing common? I'm just a little worried my application won't be reviewed in time and I'm curious if I'm wrong

The way I believe they do it is based upon your WCS. I finished my CFA on the 1/22 and I had it reviewed on 1/25. I think they give priority to candidates that are more competitive for admissions. However, this is just speculation so take it as you will.