'23 Herndon Climb

brewmeist

5-Year Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2018
Messages
1,485
So it appears that '23 will be climbing Herndon afterall this fall. There was a survey taken, and the class voted it down, but it's being done anyway. I get it that the Navy is not run by poll results, but it does makes me wonder why they had the poll taken at all. Masks required indoors to control Covid, but a thousand half-naked bodies on top each other...

It's a shame Herndon didn't happen, but it's also a shame that PROTRAMID didn't happen.
 
This is something that Plebes are supposed to do, not 2C Midshipmen. I could see the entire class thinking it's more than a little demeaning.
We'll see if it really happens. I would bet that it doesn't.
 
So it appears that '23 will be climbing Herndon afterall this fall. There was a survey taken, and the class voted it down, but it's being done anyway. I get it that the Navy is not run by poll results, but it does makes me wonder why they had the poll taken at all. Masks required indoors to control Covid, but a thousand half-naked bodies on top each other...

It's a shame Herndon didn't happen, but it's also a shame that PROTRAMID didn't happen.

Having the class of '23 climb Herndon sounds crazy. I imagine the 2025s will be watching closely for when it is their turn.
 
Why do I image, if the class as a whole truly isn’t interested, that they will break ‘24’s record longest climb? As if in protest 🤔

I could see an emphasis on completing the missed events, that they can…’22’s ring dance. ‘23’s climb. ‘24’s dining outs. Idk. Might be neat and part of a bigger ‘reset’ from last years mess. Although, the way things seem to be heading, this “kick Covid to the curb” attitude may be premature. And Fall may be welcoming back in ways I don’t even want to imagine (discussion with our Mid last night, was if he will be dining in his room again. Can they eat in KH with the mask mandate situation??).

Hope the temps hold out. It can be chilly in the Fall, for a greasy, watered climb for hours.
 
Last edited:
In protest as a class they should just go back to their rooms when they sound the start to it. They would be a class of legends for it. I am all for chain of command and those things; but this is 100% a class decision in my opinion. Hopefully the Brigade Sgt Maj and Class President can be the voice for the class in this situation and speak with leadership.
 
In protest as a class they should just go back to their rooms when they sound the start to it. They would be a class of legends for it. I am all for chain of command and those things; but this is 100% a class decision in my opinion. Hopefully the Brigade Sgt Maj and Class President can be the voice for the class in this situation and speak with leadership.
Well, mutiny did prompt the founding of USNA...
 
In protest as a class they should just go back to their rooms when they sound the start to it. They would be a class of legends for it. I am all for chain of command and those things; but this is 100% a class decision in my opinion. Hopefully the Brigade Sgt Maj and Class President can be the voice for the class in this situation and speak with leadership.
Agree with Hoops on this. As a class, perhaps they should thank the leadership
for the opportunity to check this ceremonial block, but brainstorm a class-wide, creative event that would demonstrate their leadership and maturity, perhaps a charity drive or event (just spitballing here) that would deliver back to the community and be a memory that makes them stand out as a resilient and innovative class. A massive athletic shoe drive (think of all those shoes in Bancroft). Some kind of marathon run around the Yard that runs 23 (!!) hours and involves every mid in the class, develops leadership and logistics expertise, delivers great photos, makes great memories, raising money for some approved and carefully-chosen mil-vet cause such as the SEAL Foundation, Travis Manion, USO, Brigade Fund, etc. with mids getting family and friends to sponsor their miles. Invite their Link in the Chain class to participate (and donate.) Now, that would be recognition of who they are today, and mark a right of passage in a truly legendary way, a proactive way, rather than a reactive way.

But that’s just me. All my leadership juices are boiling over thinking how I would do it, going back to the leadership with a win-win and great PR material for the media. Herndon could feature in it in a symbolic way.

The critical factor is if the midshipmen think of it, strategize it, develop the tactics and execute with full commitment. Harness the brainpower and the will and skill of the class.
 
Last edited:
This is something that Plebes are supposed to do, not 2C Midshipmen
Funny.. my Class had a big movement afoot to climb Herndon again at our 30th Reunion .. Completely unsactioned, but the plan was to climb right after the Class Memorial Service . I think the talk fizzled out when we the entire weekend was drowned by a tropical storm. (However, the rain did nothing to impair our ability to drink copious amounts of BEAT ARMY Lager, and our tailgater was great ...!)
 
In San Diego this weekend with my 3/C and his roommates during PROTRAMID. They were discussing this. The vibe in the brigade is that this is somewhat of an insult to ‘23. Somewhat of a cast off or do over.
I agree with others suggestion for ‘23 to forge their own path and make their own version of Herndon epic. And done on their terms (within regs)
I don’t say this to demean the milestone that Herndon is for plebes. Not at all. But at this point 2023 has moved on. And done so with many hurdles and U turns and segues.
 
Last edited:
Not that '23 might necessarily want it- but I was thinking that it might be a good gesture and show of respect for the '25 class to "dedicate" their climb in part to their upperclassmen in '23 (now, if it is the longest climb in history then '23 might be like "never mind").
 
It just hit me...

I just saw pics of my son signing his 2-for-7. Proud moment. The picture would be a framer if not for the huge white mask covering his face.

However, in two short days he will be climbing on top of the same Mids he was just masked along with. And this time, they will all be maskless.

The difference between the two scenarios? Grease! Grease is apparently a Covid deterrent. I will now be rubbing down my entire body in bacon grease daily until we kick this thing.
 
Back
Top