Advice for a Freshman 3 yr. Army ROTC scholarship winner who wants out although doing well

Wow, ksdale99 -I'm so very sorry to hear that you, too, also lost a teenager. Life is never the same, of course, but we must keep going. I admire your son - that's quite an ordeal he went through. I'm SO glad that he found such a meaningful purpose. Thank you so much for your understanding and your post. It's incredibly helpful.
 
Last edited:
@ Kaylar - your daughter's situation is very similar as well. You're right - this is HUGE! I'm pretty sure I couldn't do it - I have so much respect for these fantastic young people. It really gives me hope! AND - it helps so much to know that for some, this is part of the process. Thank you!

Congratulations to all of you for raising such wonderful men and women.
 
It sounds like he's just learning more about himself. The first year of college is tough for everyone with so much change occurring. I bet his outlook changes in the second semester, and if not, then he'll know it wasn't meant to be. And there's nothing wrong with that.
 
My heart goes out to your family. I can't even imagine what you all have had to process and deal with. Your sensitivity in handling your sweet boy is amazing.

My daughter has wanted to be an Army officer since she was tiny. She was her JROTC BN XO and Color Guard Commander with an ACT of 30 and a 4.0 (her weakness was she was only on the Swim Team for 2 years) and she was awarded a 3 year AD. She attends the honor college at her GIANT university and was carrying a ridiculous load (20 credits) her first semester because she wanted to go with Chemical Engineering. She became so overwhelmed so fast, she too, was considering dumping the whole deal. She was homesick, stressed out, exhausted and 2000 miles away from us.

We sat down and went over what parts meant the most to her. What was more important to her; Chemical Engineering or Army? Did she want to move to a school closer to home? What damage would it do to drop one of the classes that stressed her out the most?

In the end, she decided Chemical Engineering wasn't for her (made us really sad but it wasn't about us) and she transferred to different program when scheduling time arrived. She dropped the most stressful class which was one she wound up not needing because she switched majors. She came home for Thanksgiving and a few weeks later for the Holiday and recharged and approached her 2nd semester with a better outlook and made the Dean's List both of those semesters. She's now a contracted MSII, happy as a clam and fully enjoying her college experience; ROTC-wise, academically and socially.

It's amazing what a little break can do to help one's frame of mind. He just needs to determine if he's chasing his brother's dream or his own.

Hang in there! You and your family are incredibly strong!
 
Thank you, Bull and asuwur - very much! Bull - your comment was right on - he is learning a lot about himself and whatever he decides will be ok with us. It's a great opportunity, but if it's not what he wants, it's not the right opportunity for him.

asuwur - thank you for your kind comments and your story. I agree completely - we'll see how things are once he gets a break and a fresh perspective. There's nothing like looking at things from a different vantage point. Congratulations to your daughter!
 
I think what your DS is going through is pretty normal. Seems like the first year at any college can be a challenging adjustment that makes young people question everything. Adding the military aspect of ROTC, SA or SMC only gives them more to think about. For us, DD started at USNA last year. She had serious second thoughts on I-Day but she stayed. After Plebe summer she felt pretty good about making it through, then the academic year started which was a whole new challenge. By the winter break, she was seriously questioning her choices again. Throughout all of this DW and I tried to listen a lot and let her know we'd be OK with whatever decision she made, but thought she should finish her first year before deciding. Fast forward to today with Plebe year behind her and a good experience with her summer training and she says she is where she should be and happy she stayed. My DS is currently in his first year at a SMC on ROTC scholarship and has the benefit of having his sister go before him. I think he knew a little better what to expect. He still says he questions everything but knows now is not the time to make any major decisions.

Good luck.
 
DD is currently in her fourth year of NROTC and I don't think there has been a semester yet in which she has not at some point asked "Tell me again why I am doing this." As you say, it is VERY time consuming, especially as a senior (at this point she averages over 25 emails per day relating to ROTC) and as her consortium consists of six different schools and she is on the battalion staff, she has to do a lot of travelling back and forth between campuses. As you also say, she is "not as obsessed with ROTC as 90% of the others appear to be" (though over the years I think this changes a bit for many, half of those in her university who began NROTC freshman year didn't return for the sophomore year), and she also does not like all of the bureaucracy. All of that being said, I can make the following observations.

Every semester when she asks herself why she is in ROTC, she always comes back to the same conclusion that it is what she needs to be doing. As a freshman she was very sleep deprived because, as you say, much of what happens in college occurs after 9 PM. And I'm not speaking about partying, I'm speaking of mandatory dorm meetings, scheduled study breaks, and during her freshman year ensemble practice for a singing group she was in which often didn't begin practices until ten in the evenings so everyone could be there. By now, she has to a large degree taken control of her own schedule. She found another singing group on campus and is now leading it so she can set the rehearsal times herself. She goes to bed at 9 PM and gets up at 5 AM each morning to work out (her unit only has PT one morning a week so she goes to the gym on her own the other days), and she manages her class load better (no credit for ROTC classes which are on another campus - that is on top of her regular load). She still hates all of the bureaucracy, though she is not alone in that as it is the number one complaint among junior officers in all branches and one reason the military is having major retention problems. While she gets along fine with the others in ROTC, her social group is outside of ROTC. She tells me she has three groups of friends: ROTC, Class, and Social Group (largely church and music connections), and there is little overlap between the three. Her senior year has been her best, though still has its frustrations. On the other hand, she has had great opportunities to meet a wide variety of people, attending lunches with numerous admirals, with the majority of the living medal of honor recipients, and on one occasion she was seated next to the SECDEF for lunch. She commented once after attending a Naval Conference at Notre Dame that most of the admirals who spoke said they were originally not obsessed with the navy and had planned on getting out after five years, but one thing led to another and the next thing they knew they had been in twenty-five years. Through it all she has held to Socrates statement that an unexamined life is not worth living, so she regularly examines her own life and her decisions. Perhaps that comes from being a philosophy major (though she is going into nuclear power in the navy). And as a parent, I wouldn't want it any other way.
 
Back
Top