"Committed Athlete" Question?

NHDad_2023

New Member
Joined
May 4, 2015
Messages
4
Can somebody explain to me how someone can say they have "committed" to USMA for a particular sport if they are only a Junior in High School and it is only November 1?

I have been following this forum for a long time, particularly the admissions process/timeline etc. I am not seeing how it really means anything to "commit" to a service academy for a sport at this point in the process. Or, is it just saying I am "committing" to your program assuming I can jump through all of the other hoops and actually get in?

Thanks.
 
Can somebody explain to me how someone can say they have "committed" to USMA for a particular sport if they are only a Junior in High School and it is only November 1?

I have been following this forum for a long time, particularly the admissions process/timeline etc. I am not seeing how it really means anything to "commit" to a service academy for a sport at this point in the process. Or, is it just saying I am "committing" to your program assuming I can jump through all of the other hoops and actually get in?

Thanks.
I believe you are referring to the non-binding verbal commitment used by colleges and athletes.

The "commitment" to USMA and by USMA works the same as any other college. It signifies the intent by both parties that the student will probably attend the school and that the school will probably accept the student. A student/athlete can de-commit if a better offer comes along. The coach can de-commit if a better athlete comes along or the coach's evaluation of the athlete changes.

Admissions departments will normally give an initial read on the file to determine if the athlete is in an acceptable range before the coach can make a commitment, but each college establishes its own procedures. Therefore, it is very unlikely that the athlete will be rejected as long as the coach maintains his support. A qualified candidate/athlete for a service academy that has the endorsement of a varsity coach will almost certainly receive an appointment. The difference with a service academy is that there are many things that can disqualify an applicant besides academics, so the likelihood of an appointment is slightly lower than at a regular college.

For example, College Hockey Inc lists all Division I hockey commitments. USAF and USMA both list current commitments for the 2017-2018 and 2018-2019 years, although none of those candidates has an appointment yet. But, as long as they are qualified and keep their games up, they will receive appointments.
 
Can somebody explain to me how someone can say they have "committed" to USMA for a particular sport if they are only a Junior in High School and it is only November 1?

I have been following this forum for a long time, particularly the admissions process/timeline etc. I am not seeing how it really means anything to "commit" to a service academy for a sport at this point in the process. Or, is it just saying I am "committing" to your program assuming I can jump through all of the other hoops and actually get in?

Thanks.
To add to jl123. Signing a "letter of intent" at one of the academies is really just for show. The letter is a good photo-op for signing day.
 
The athlete making the verbal commitment should first discuss openly with the coach what sort of support the coach will be able to provide in the admissions process. Some athletes (highly recruited, in major sports) will be basically guaranteed admission once they are pre-screened. Others will be told that they need to get in on their own (but they too may be pre-screened to let them know they have are quality applicants). I don't know much about details, but i DO know that the admissions support varies by athlete and sport.
 
I don't know much about details, but i DO know that the admissions support varies by athlete and sport.
Good point. The high school college counselor can be helpful in this step. A good counselor will contact the admissions office to verify that the student is a recruited athlete, an initial read has been done, and the student is likely to be admitted.
 
It is also possible that person is simply bragging about talking with a WP coach since everyone doesn't use the terminology in the same way. Is he/she an athlete who has excelled at the state/national level in their sport? Those are likely the first ones who catch the coaches eye when doing recruiting. Being recruited is no guarantee of getting an appointment.

Since no one pays tuition/room/board at an SA, the actual incentive to play sports at an SA is a LOT different from a civilian college. Even if you attend WP and play a varsity sport, you can decide to drop that sport at any time and you don't lose your scholarship as would be the case at a civilian college. The primary reason you attend an SA is to pursue a career in the military. Lots of older threads on here about what it means to be recruited and the associated time commitment to play varsity sports with all of the other demands on your time at an SA.
 
My DD (2021 Candidate) has been in contact with USMA's Rugby Coach a few times over the past several weeks, and was told to go through the NCAA clearinghouse. Rugby is a sport that has 95%+ walk-ons...not a very popular HS sport...,but if the cards play out and she is offered an appointment, she is proudly going to take advantage of the photo op that comes with "committing" to a SA sport program.
 
It is also possible that person is simply bragging about talking with a WP coach since everyone doesn't use the terminology in the same way.

Since no one pays tuition/room/board at an SA, the actual incentive to play sports at an SA is a LOT different from a civilian college.

Sometimes student/athletes and their parents are unfamiliar with the recruiting process and mistake communication with commitment.

The incentive to become recruited at a service academy is similar to that of a Division III school. It offers an edge in admissions and may allow the student to get an acceptance/appointment that they might not get otherwise.
 
Last edited:
My DD (2021 Candidate) has been in contact with USMA's Rugby Coach a few times over the past several weeks, and was told to go through the NCAA clearinghouse. Rugby is a sport that has 95%+ walk-ons...not a very popular HS sport...,but if the cards play out and she is offered an appointment, she is proudly going to take advantage of the photo op that comes with "committing" to a SA sport program.
Having a coach ask your DD to complete the paperwork in the NCAA Clearinghouse is a very good sign. That means he is interested in her and wants to make sure she is eligible to compete.
 
Back
Top