- Joined
- Feb 2, 2008
- Messages
- 3,059
http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2014/04/07/why_cant_we_make_fun_of_the_military_anymore
Really interesting question in Foreign Policy:
Seems pretty obvious to me- combination of reaction to the sanctimonious anti-military humor of Vietnam critics in shows like MASH combined with the reality that most folks never serve in the military anymore so it is no longer a commonly shared experience. It is one thing to laugh at yourself- after all you shared in (or maybe caused)the absurdity, and you understand the stresses and demands that caused the goofiness, but it is quite a bit different to have others laughing at you. (Same dynamic in ethnic jokes- the insider gets to talk about himself and the goofiness associated with his tribe- but the outsider doen't get to tell the same jokes- suddenly they are not so funny.) His point is valid though IMHO.
Really interesting question in Foreign Policy:
America used to love laughing at the military. When did it become so taboo?
Seems pretty obvious to me- combination of reaction to the sanctimonious anti-military humor of Vietnam critics in shows like MASH combined with the reality that most folks never serve in the military anymore so it is no longer a commonly shared experience. It is one thing to laugh at yourself- after all you shared in (or maybe caused)the absurdity, and you understand the stresses and demands that caused the goofiness, but it is quite a bit different to have others laughing at you. (Same dynamic in ethnic jokes- the insider gets to talk about himself and the goofiness associated with his tribe- but the outsider doen't get to tell the same jokes- suddenly they are not so funny.) His point is valid though IMHO.
Unfortunately, losing our ability to laugh at the military comes with a price. No human institution is perfect, and none should be given a free pass by the rest of society. Humor and ridicule are potent weapons when trying to keep powerful institutions under control, and giving them up makes it harder to keep those institutions on the straight and narrow. Capable armed forces are a regrettable necessity, but treating them with excessive deference and declining to joke about their foibles makes it more likely they will be indulged rather than improved.