Honestly, I think USMMA is amazing. However, I would also say I have been here long enough and what I have not read in any of these posts is simple.
~ To get a flight slot you must be competitive. To be competitive your academics have to be strong. I have read many times that the Sea year at USMMA is hard to say the very least.
~~~ Rated board for AF includes their cgpa and their TBAS score. It is putting more of a burden on them. For AFROTC that board meets their junior yr. For USAFA it meets the 1st few weeks of their senior year.
It is hard for a kid at 18 to decide what they want to do basically for the next decade. If he loves the water, and flying is a 2nd thought than go USMMA
At USMMA we go through a ROTC detachment at a neighboring school in the Bronx called Manhattan College. You can contract junior year or senior year, but I think they prefer contracting junior year, and then you start getting the stipend that contracted cadets get. USMMA mids don't do any unit activities with that ROTC unit, their staff just administers the process I think. Sea year isn't really hard, and the sea term carries less credits than academic terms, so its not that big of an impact on cGPA. USMMA has pretty low GPAs in general though, if you have above a 3.0 you're doing alright.
A couple years ago at graduation, the anchorman (last in the class), probably carrying a 2.1 or less went up to get the cash that they always give the anchorman and surprisingly he was wearing the Air Force dress blue uniform (not sure about AF uniforms). And he commissioned as a 2nd LT.