I had a similar dillema this time last year. I received both Type-1 and Falcon Foundation scholarships. For me, it was a pretty easy descion based on my goals. My highest goal was to earn a commission. For that reason I accepted my AFROTC scholarship. I figured that not only would I get a year of experience to reapply to USAFA, but if it didn’t end up happening, I still had a great path to commission. I can tell you that if you do well in ROTC, and improve the weaker aspects of your packet, you’ll be in good shape this time next year.
Here are some pros and cons based on my experience with ROTC (and limited knowledge of Prep schools).
ROTC:
Pros//
-Great path to commission
-Free college
-“Normal” college experience
-Immersive Air Force experience
Cons//
-Will require a lot of self-discipline to improve your packet
-Mixed support from cadre/fellow cadets on wanting to transfer out to USAFA (at least in my experience)
Prep:
-Emphasis on improving your packet specifically for USAFA
-Classmates and instructors that are more dedicated to helping you reach a service academy goal
Cons//
-Will require a transfer if you end up deciding it’s not for you/don’t end up getting in
At the end of the day, it’s up to where you see yourself improving the most and putting yourself in the best position to achieve your goals. It’s a very good problem to have. I went the ROTC rout and had a great time and learned a lot. I ended up getting an appointment, and I can say I had at least a year of “normal” college experience before USAFA...