Don't over think this. Obviously AP, Honors science and math classes, high GPA and top class rank help your competitiveness; BUT there are many other factors that are considered when Admissions decides who they are going offer an appointment (leadership, outside activities, community service, athletics, SAT/ACT scores, competitiveness of candidate's high school, counselor and teacher evaluations, etc., etc.). In the past there have been extremely bright, academic rock stars who have not been selected for appointments since they were too one dimensional.
Remember, it's called a Whole Person Score for a reason.