Myopia Medical Waiver

usna2025

Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2019
Messages
27
Hi,

I was selected for a 4 year Navy ROTC scholarship pending my medical clearance but I was DQ'd for high myopia. DODMERB requested a series of AMIs including a complete eye exam in which the doctors found both eyes correctable to 20/20 and no abnormalities, however BUMED denied my waiver request due to "increased risk of retinal detachment." My current prescription is -9.75 R -7.50 L. I was hoping some of you might have some advice as to what else I could do to try and get my waiver approved. Thank you!
 
Hi,

I was selected for a 4 year Navy ROTC scholarship pending my medical clearance but I was DQ'd for high myopia. DODMERB requested a series of AMIs including a complete eye exam in which the doctors found both eyes correctable to 20/20 and no abnormalities, however BUMED denied my waiver request due to "increased risk of retinal detachment." My current prescription is -9.75 R -7.50 L. I was hoping some of you might have some advice as to what else I could do to try and get my waiver approved. Thank you!

You’ve already been in contact with Mr. Mullen a couple of times about this. There is no better source here for information on disqualifications and waivers. Follow what he has told you.

Stealth_81
 
Thx Stealth _81 :wiggle:

I... AND... and NROTC ... have answered repeatedly...to no avail. So, clearly there's someone on the Forums that will provide the desired advice
 
@usna2025

I have no doubt it is a punch in the gut to realize this may be the end of the road. The waiver authority has said no, after taking the time to obtain AMI and re-reviewing the case. Mull over why DQs are given, and waivers not granted. It’s not personal, though I am sure it feels that way. The military accession medical bar is set very high, because military people often live and work in remote, harsh, industrial environments far from specialty medical care. The physical readiness of the unit is paramount. The military aims to bring in people with the least amount of unfixable problems and potential risk. They waive many things, and some they don’t.

Clearly you have worked very hard to earn your scholarship, with huge potential and past accomplishments. This may be the roughest bump in your life road you have encountered to date. It doesn’t feel fair at all - to you - to be at the start of your life and be told there is something physically that is just not going to allow you to do what you want.

If this door does indeed close in your face, you may experience some of the stages of grief at a lost opportunity. That would be normal.

A DQ is a DQ, but waiver policies differ by Service - different missions, different gear, different equipment. I don’t know whether you have researched any other Service.

You have more practical challenges ahead. If this is the end of your NROTC path before it begins, are you able to afford college you had planned to attend.

Finally, for you to think about down the road, I’ll copy and paste a post that I have often used for those whose dream of military service has ended, whether SA or ROTC.

Let us know how it goes. Remember when you were younger and all you wanted to do was be grown-up, run your own life, make your own decisions, drive, get out of the house? This is what life looks like sometimes. Smacked in the face, deep breath, adjust, press on.
——————————————————
(my old post)
Health is paramount. Always.

Not knowing the details of the DQ condition - and not asking for them - the Services do have different waiver policies. The Services’ policies differ because missions, gear and operating environments differ. Mr. Mullen is in the best position to give insights into other Service possibilities. Or it could be one of those DQs that is seldom or never waived.

Every year, we have applicants who realize their pursuit of military service must end for medical DQ reasons. There are still ways to serve the country.


Federal agencies and departments, particularly the “ABC” ones, are eager to hire college grads who wish to serve the country in the area of national security. If you can’t be a “door-kicker” or operational field agent, you can have their backs as analysts and specialists in cyber and intelligence, in forensics, communications, logistics, operations planning and other critical fields. Federal civil service is a way to serve.

Below I’ve pasted some info I have used here over the years, in the hope of shining a light toward other open doors.



proxy.php.jpg

Students

Explore hiring programs for students.

proxy.php

www.dhs.gov

Students | FBIJOBS



1__#$!@!#__proxy.php

www.fbijobs.gov

NSA | Students | Intelligence Careers

STEM Scholarships | DoD STEM

DoD STEM scholarships are available to exceptional STEM education students excelling in one of 15 supported STEM disciplines of interest to the DoD.

2__#$!@!#__proxy.php

dodstem.us

You can find similar student internships, scholarships, and other programs for CIA and other major agencies. There are HS, college undergraduate and post-grad programs.



Federal service offers excellent benefits and education opportunities, plus the ability to move around in search of promotions or between agencies and departments. One of our USNA sponsor daughters had a younger sister who was a math whiz, varsity athlete, all-around scholar who would have been very competitive for SA or ROTC scholarship, but her Crohn’s DQ’ed her. She majored in Applied Mathematics at a very good school, took advantage of one of the programs above and did paid work for them in the summer, and she was hired 4 days after she graduated college. She is now doing highly classified work for that agency, and starting a fully paid for Master’s at a prestigious university.

If the USAFA door is firmly closed, look around for doors and windows in other shapes and sizes which also lead to service.
 
Last edited:
A phenomenal post by @Capt MJ (as always). I'd add that service to one's country doesn't stop at jobs with the federal government. Sometimes the people serving the most are doing so at a community level e.g. firefighters, teachers, nurses, etc.

It may be completely different path from the one you thought you would take, but looking at your profile, service seems to be the theme. Look into opportunities like Teach For America, Red Cross, search and rescue teams, or Doctors Without borders. I think you'll find that even if they're lacking a military flavor, all will present unique opportunities (and challenges) that will surely fulfill this desire to serve that you've expressed.
 
@usna2025 one quick recommendation is to pick up and read "Who Moved My Cheese?" by Spencer Johnson - it's a short book but you may find some of the points relevant to your energy investment and redirection in addressing your situation. I have no affiliation with this author or book other than being a reader who benefitted from reading this book - I see some guidance in it that helped me and may also help you.
 

Attachments

  • WMMC.png
    WMMC.png
    354 KB · Views: 2
@usna2025

I have no doubt it is a punch in the gut to realize this may be the end of the road. The waiver authority has said no, after taking the time to obtain AMI and re-reviewing the case. Mull over why DQs are given, and waivers not granted. It’s not personal, though I am sure it feels that way. The military accession medical bar is set very high, because military people often live and work in remote, harsh, industrial environments far from specialty medical care. The physical readiness of the unit is paramount. The military aims to bring in people with the least amount of unfixable problems and potential risk. They waive many things, and some they don’t.

Clearly you have worked very hard to earn your scholarship, with huge potential and past accomplishments. This may be the roughest bump in your life road you have encountered to date. It doesn’t feel fair at all - to you - to be at the start of your life and be told there is something physically that is just not going to allow you to do what you want.

If this door does indeed close in your face, you may experience some of the stages of grief at a lost opportunity. That would be normal.

A DQ is a DQ, but waiver policies differ by Service - different missions, different gear, different equipment. I don’t know whether you have researched any other Service.

You have more practical challenges ahead. If this is the end of your NROTC path before it begins, are you able to afford college you had planned to attend.

Finally, for you to think about down the road, I’ll copy and paste a post that I have often used for those whose dream of military service has ended, whether SA or ROTC.

Let us know how it goes. Remember when you were younger and all you wanted to do was be grown-up, run your own life, make your own decisions, drive, get out of the house? This is what life looks like sometimes. Smacked in the face, deep breath, adjust, press on.
——————————————————
(my old post)
Health is paramount. Always.

Not knowing the details of the DQ condition - and not asking for them - the Services do have different waiver policies. The Services’ policies differ because missions, gear and operating environments differ. Mr. Mullen is in the best position to give insights into other Service possibilities. Or it could be one of those DQs that is seldom or never waived.

Every year, we have applicants who realize their pursuit of military service must end for medical DQ reasons. There are still ways to serve the country.


Federal agencies and departments, particularly the “ABC” ones, are eager to hire college grads who wish to serve the country in the area of national security. If you can’t be a “door-kicker” or operational field agent, you can have their backs as analysts and specialists in cyber and intelligence, in forensics, communications, logistics, operations planning and other critical fields. Federal civil service is a way to serve.

Below I’ve pasted some info I have used here over the years, in the hope of shining a light toward other open doors.



View attachment 9843

Students

Explore hiring programs for students.

proxy.php

www.dhs.gov

Students | FBIJOBS



1__#$!@!#__proxy.php

www.fbijobs.gov

NSA | Students | Intelligence Careers

STEM Scholarships | DoD STEM

DoD STEM scholarships are available to exceptional STEM education students excelling in one of 15 supported STEM disciplines of interest to the DoD.

2__#$!@!#__proxy.php

dodstem.us

You can find similar student internships, scholarships, and other programs for CIA and other major agencies. There are HS, college undergraduate and post-grad programs.



Federal service offers excellent benefits and education opportunities, plus the ability to move around in search of promotions or between agencies and departments. One of our USNA sponsor daughters had a younger sister who was a math whiz, varsity athlete, all-around scholar who would have been very competitive for SA or ROTC scholarship, but her Crohn’s DQ’ed her. She majored in Applied Mathematics at a very good school, took advantage of one of the programs above and did paid work for them in the summer, and she was hired 4 days after she graduated college. She is now doing highly classified work for that agency, and starting a fully paid for Master’s at a prestigious university.

If the USAFA door is firmly closed, look around for doors and windows in other shapes and sizes which also lead to service.
Capt MJ, please allow me to add one more to your outstanding list as I've had the pleasure of nominating two students for the Cybercorps and both got in.

This Federal Government program provides scholarships to assist students through a variety of undergrad and grad education in return for agreeing to work for the government. My students got career guidance and internship assistance as well.

 
Last edited:
Capt MJ, please allow me to add one more to your outstanding list as I've had the pleasure of nominating two students for the Cybercorps and both got in.

This Federal Government program provides scholarships to assist students through a variety of undergrad and grad education in retrn for agreeing to work for the government. My students got career guidance and internship assistance as well.

Thank you! I will add to my boilerplate and update the version I have saved in Notes on my iPhone. That’s where all my lengthy oldy-but-goody posts hang out.

So many great programs with the Fed!
 
Back
Top