USAFA Summer Seminar Essay 1

Joined
Dec 31, 2023
Messages
17
Writing my summer seminar essays. I have some kinks in them, would any of you mind taking a look at my first? All of your help means a lot to me.

The prompt: Please discuss any personal life experience where you have overcome adversity or challenges that have shaped you into the person you are today.? (3000 characters max)

My essay: It was March of my sophomore year of high school and my Boy Scout troop’s camping trip was going as planned. It was a jamboree with hundreds of troops in attendance. We were enjoying our evening by the campfire after a long day of activities when we heard an announcement. Over the booming PA system, the organizers revealed the ominous weather forecast for the night, calling for a nor’easter bringing lightning and rain over the area. At this point, a lot of troops left, but we battened down our campsite because we didn’t want to let a little rain ruin our weekend. However, our optimistic moods shifted when we woke up the next morning.

As I crawled out of my sleeping bag, I noticed that my entire tent was soaking in an inch of water. However, it seemed I was the luckiest. As I zipped open my tent I was met with a wasteland of broken, soggy, and gloomy scouts. Although we were forced awake early by our sinking tents, We had merely an hour to strip our encampment down. Although I knew we had to rally together to clean up, having been the troop’s Senior Patrol leader, I knew it would be a challenge enticing my fellow cold, wet, and miserable scouts to even move.

I immediately split our troop into teams. I tasked one team, led by my assistant, to break down our campsite and pack up our wet gear, while another team, led by myself, was assigned to assist our youngest, most inexperienced scouts in salvaging their equipment. I vividly remember the shock and awe of being a novice camper. I had been in their shoes many times before, and I had seen the importance of having an older scout take the lead and set an example. As I worked with them, I shared my knowledge, demonstrating how to salvage damp gear and minimize the impacts of weather. The camaraderie I developed with them through many past camping trips was key to our success. Our frustration began to transform into determination to overcome the challenge.

Through our teamwork, we slowly transformed our desolate campsite into a place of order. Tents were folded and packed, our gear was stowed, and a fire crackled to life. Through the sizzling of bacon, the resistant groans had turned into jokey murmurs. Resiliently we waited to be picked up, our success was a testament to our strengthened bonds. For many of our fresh scouts, it was their first lesson on teamwork and adaptability. For me, however, it was a lesson that true leadership doesn’t happen on sunny days, but in the face of unexpected challenges.
 
Your draft is engaging and vividly describes a significant event where you demonstrated leadership and resilience. However, it seems to focus more on the narrative( too much creative writing) the event rather than directly linking the experiences to the personal growth or specific attributes you've developed. Here's how you might consider revising:
Directly Address the Prompt: Start with a clear statement that connects the story to the prompt. For instance, "Facing a nor'easter during a Boy Scout jamboree taught me invaluable lessons in leadership, resilience, and adaptability."
Personal Growth and Characteristics: Throughout the essay, explicitly mention how the experience shaped you. After describing a particular challenge or action, reflect on what it taught you about yourself or how it changed you. For example, after mentioning rallying the troop, you could add, "This moment was pivotal in transforming my understanding of leadership from merely organizing to inspiring and motivating."
Less Detail on the Event, More on Reflection: Your essay is currently heavy on the story and light on personal reflection. Consider shortening the narrative of the event to make room for more introspection. For instance, instead of detailing the entire process of dealing with the rain and organizing the camp, summarize this quickly and then delve into what this experience revealed to you about your capabilities and how it has shaped your approach to future challenges.
Conclusion that Ties Back to the Prompt: End with a strong conclusion that directly ties the experience back to the prompt. Reflect on how the qualities you've developed through this adversity (like leadership, resilience, adaptability) are relevant to your aspirations, and how they will contribute to your future and the Air Force Academy.
Remember, USAFA wants to understand who you are and how you've grown from your experiences. They are less interested in the event itself and more in how it has contributed to your personal development. Make sure every paragraph bridges the gap between the story and the prompt.
 
Last edited:
Your draft is engaging and vividly describes a significant event where you demonstrated leadership and resilience. However, it seems to focus more on the narrative( too much creative writing) the event rather than directly linking the experiences to the personal growth or specific attributes you've developed. Here's how you might consider revising:
Directly Address the Prompt: Start with a clear statement that connects the story to the prompt. For instance, "Facing a nor'easter during a Boy Scout jamboree taught me invaluable lessons in leadership, resilience, and adaptability."
Personal Growth and Characteristics: Throughout the essay, explicitly mention how the experience shaped you. After describing a particular challenge or action, reflect on what it taught you about yourself or how it changed you. For example, after mentioning rallying the troop, you could add, "This moment was pivotal in transforming my understanding of leadership from merely organizing to inspiring and motivating."
Less Detail on the Event, More on Reflection: Your essay is currently heavy on the story and light on personal reflection. Consider shortening the narrative of the event to make room for more introspection. For instance, instead of detailing the entire process of dealing with the rain and organizing the camp, summarize this quickly and then delve into what this experience revealed to you about your capabilities and how it has shaped your approach to future challenges.
Conclusion that Ties Back to the Prompt: End with a strong conclusion that directly ties the experience back to the prompt. Reflect on how the qualities you've developed through this adversity (like leadership, resilience, adaptability) are relevant to your aspirations, and how they will contribute to your future and the Air Force Academy.
Remember, USAFA wants to understand who you are and how you've grown from your experiences. They are less interested in the event itself and more in how it has contributed to your personal development. Make sure every paragraph bridges the gap between the story and the prompt.
 
Remember, you are competing with the Nation's best. The question asks about overcoming adversity and challenges - we can only imagine what other applicants have gone through. Imagine the narratives our prior enlisted can write about. Or those with parents who were in combat zones while they waited for them at home. Or those who lost loved ones due to cancer, had to move five times during high school, had a single parent, were homeless for a while, faced addiction in their families, or countless other challenges that molded them into the person they are (either because of it, or in spite of it). You wrote about a camping trip when it rained. That's not a knock on you - it may be the greatest challenge you have ever faced. But if there is more, I would write it.
 
Remember, you are competing with the Nation's best. The question asks about overcoming adversity and challenges - we can only imagine what other applicants have gone through. Imagine the narratives our prior enlisted can write about. Or those with parents who were in combat zones while they waited for them at home. Or those who lost loved ones due to cancer, had to move five times during high school, had a single parent, were homeless for a while, faced addiction in their families, or countless other challenges that molded them into the person they are (either because of it, or in spite of it). You wrote about a camping trip when it rained. That's not a knock on you - it may be the greatest challenge you have ever faced. But if there is more, I would write it.
Very good! I wasn't brave enough to point that out about his content.
 
Remember, you are competing with the Nation's best. The question asks about overcoming adversity and challenges - we can only imagine what other applicants have gone through. Imagine the narratives our prior enlisted can write about. Or those with parents who were in combat zones while they waited for them at home. Or those who lost loved ones due to cancer, had to move five times during high school, had a single parent, were homeless for a while, faced addiction in their families, or countless other challenges that molded them into the person they are (either because of it, or in spite of it). You wrote about a camping trip when it rained. That's not a knock on you - it may be the greatest challenge you have ever faced. But if there is more, I would write it.
Remember, you are competing with the Nation's best. The question asks about overcoming adversity and challenges - we can only imagine what other applicants have gone through. Imagine the narratives our prior enlisted can write about. Or those with parents who were in combat zones while they waited for them at home. Or those who lost loved ones due to cancer, had to move five times during high school, had a single parent, were homeless for a while, faced addiction in their families, or countless other challenges that molded them into the person they are (either because of it, or in spite of it). You wrote about a camping trip when it rained. That's not a knock on you - it may be the greatest challenge you have ever faced. But if there is more, I would write it.
I seriously appreciate the comment and I was concerned about that going in, I don’t come from a military family, so a lot of those examples of adversity I could not really apply to myself. With all that being said, do you know how much this essay will effect my app? Could it make or break it?
 
Your draft is engaging and vividly describes a significant event where you demonstrated leadership and resilience. However, it seems to focus more on the narrative( too much creative writing) the event rather than directly linking the experiences to the personal growth or specific attributes you've developed. Here's how you might consider revising:
Directly Address the Prompt: Start with a clear statement that connects the story to the prompt. For instance, "Facing a nor'easter during a Boy Scout jamboree taught me invaluable lessons in leadership, resilience, and adaptability."
Personal Growth and Characteristics: Throughout the essay, explicitly mention how the experience shaped you. After describing a particular challenge or action, reflect on what it taught you about yourself or how it changed you. For example, after mentioning rallying the troop, you could add, "This moment was pivotal in transforming my understanding of leadership from merely organizing to inspiring and motivating."
Less Detail on the Event, More on Reflection: Your essay is currently heavy on the story and light on personal reflection. Consider shortening the narrative of the event to make room for more introspection. For instance, instead of detailing the entire process of dealing with the rain and organizing the camp, summarize this quickly and then delve into what this experience revealed to you about your capabilities and how it has shaped your approach to future challenges.
Conclusion that Ties Back to the Prompt: End with a strong conclusion that directly ties the experience back to the prompt. Reflect on how the qualities you've developed through this adversity (like leadership, resilience, adaptability) are relevant to your aspirations, and how they will contribute to your future and the Air Force Academy.
Remember, USAFA wants to understand who you are and how you've grown from your experiences. They are less interested in the event itself and more in how it has contributed to your personal development. Make sure every paragraph bridges the gap between the story and the prompt.
Thank you so much for your advice, it really means a lot to me.
 
i highly doubt a prior E is applying for a summer seminar, and I wouldn't lose sleep over the essay. I wrote the essay for NASS at an olive garden and turned everything in the same night the day the application opened, and got a slot mid february.
 
Last edited:
i highly doubt a prior E is applying for a summer seminar, and I wouldn't lose sleep over the essay. I wrote the essay for NASS at an olive garden and turned everything in the same night the day the application opened, and got a slot mid february.
Oh my, you are right. Sorry OP - I missed the "summer seminar" part. My advice was for your actual SA application essays. Good catch Sngtlm.
 
I seriously appreciate the comment and I was concerned about that going in, I don’t come from a military family, so a lot of those examples of adversity I could not really apply to myself. With all that being said, do you know how much this essay will effect my app? Could it make or break it?
I think your content is fine. It's pretty normal for a 16-17 year old to not have something traumatic happen or experienced major adversity in their life. Write about what YOU have experienced and how you handled it. I liked your essay.
 
Back
Top