USAFA v ROTC in general (& pilot slots)

mrhalfaday

Member
Joined
Dec 7, 2022
Messages
11
Hey everyone! I am a USAFA '95 grad and parent of a Jr. who is interested in USAFA as well as ROTC. As a grad I understand a good bit about USAFA, but know very little (almost nothing) about ROTC. One question (among many) is how pilot opportunities differ among these two choices. (slot #'s, competitiveness, preparedness, process, etc.). Would welcome any input! TYIA!
 
Hey everyone! I am a USAFA '95 grad and parent of a Jr. who is interested in USAFA as well as ROTC. As a grad I understand a good bit about USAFA, but know very little (almost nothing) about ROTC. One question (among many) is how pilot opportunities differ among these two choices. (slot #'s, competitiveness, preparedness, process, etc.). Would welcome any input! TYIA!
I'm a father of three AFROTC kids who passed on the academies but as I understand pilot slots, there is more opportunity by attending USAFA. Others here can discuss that in more detail.
As for other areas, your son should tour the Academy and colleges. ROTC will offer a more normal college life (e.g., going out for pizza at Midnight, more time out of uniform, have a job on campus, full summers off - though ROTC offers great summer programs such as Project Go, etc.). It also offers the student a chance to socialize and hang out with a diverse group of students including those who aren't ROTC. My kids all had/have ROTC friends and non-ROTC friends. Having said that, we see more and more normalcy in cadet life with our sponsored cadet and our friends' sponsored cadets. Once they have access to a ride, they are away almost every weekend (skiing, hanging out at sponsor's homes, renting Airbnbs for parties) - our cadet eats out more often than our kids do at a regular college. :)
There are also some life skills learned via ROTC - our kids worked, created a budget, paid rent and utilities, searched for off campus housing, had to buy groceries and cook, etc.
Both routes are good for the right personality. My oldest thought he wanted USAFA but after going on a college tour for Spring Break. My youngest probably would have chosen USNA but he wasn't notified until he'd committed to a university and cadre and gotten excited about it. Taking your son to visit schools is a great tool, and a really fun way to hang out with your son for a week.
Good luck!
 
Anecdotal....

My big bro went USAFA and got a pilot slot. One of his kids went AF ROTC and got a pilot slot. One went NROTC and got a pilot slot. Big bro noted once in the squadron there was no difference between ring knockers and ROTC. In the Army I have a similar experience.

If your kids are quality they will get the pilot slots no matter the program.

Note: As an ROTC guy I have much better college stories than my USAFA big bro.
 
Anecdotal....

My big bro went USAFA and got a pilot slot. One of his kids went AF ROTC and got a pilot slot. One went NROTC and got a pilot slot. Big bro noted once in the squadron there was no difference between ring knockers and ROTC. In the Army I have a similar experience.

If your kids are quality they will get the pilot slots no matter the program.

Note: As an ROTC guy I have much better college stories than my USAFA big bro.
Absolutely correct---Once in the flight room- it doesn't matter where you went to get there, it matters that everyone helps everyone get those wings at the end!
 
All anecdotal, but several ways to look at it. Both paths have success, but there is a higher probability of getting a slot through USAFA.

USAFA receives a higher percentage of slots vs. students in the sample size.
At USAFA, in the recent past, a student who is PQ and does not opt to take a pilot slot has to explain why to the Commandant.
At USAFA, historically, there have been more pilot slots than PQ eligible graduating seniors.

Interesting bedtime reads - unsure how "current" this info is in this 2000 study:
"the minimum qualifying AFOQT scores for pilot selection vary by commissioning source. The strictest standards are for OTS pilot applicants without a private pilot’s license (PPL). The weakest standards are for AFA pilot applicants. The AFA sets no minimum qualifying AFOQT score, instead using it as a "tie breaker" when evaluating pilot applicants"

Unsure of source document or date of publication:
http://www3.citadel.edu/pao/e_let/03july/pilots.html
"Nationwide, only 57 percent of the Air Force ROTC students who seek slots for pilot training are accepted"

As you have seen through the years, the number of slots will range and are impacted by the economy and airline hiring. There is currently a pipeline backlog for UPT caused by COVID restrictions. This leads to a potential near term impact of fewer overall slots available.
 
Hey everyone! I am a USAFA '95 grad and parent of a Jr. who is interested in USAFA as well as ROTC. As a grad I understand a good bit about USAFA, but know very little (almost nothing) about ROTC. One question (among many) is how pilot opportunities differ among these two choices. (slot #'s, competitiveness, preparedness, process, etc.). Would welcome any input! TYIA!
I believe there are more pilot slots for USAFA cadets. I think I read that they had more slots then cadets wanting them a few years or go. I may be wrong.
My son applied to USCGA and wad decline last decision, so accepted his University offer. Orientation day, his first stop was AFROTC table to sign up.....offered a Commanders TYPE 1 sophomore year....offered a pilot slot...etc....
His last year (he had to go 5 due to ROTC)-- I asked him if he was glad USCGA declined him. He said-- YES!!! He got to experience college life with a taste of military. He marched in the marching band (Go DAWGS)--- was an honor guard, and had a small job. He had to experience balancing his life with the college atmosphere. Showing up to PT twice per week at 6 AM being a college student, is not easy in itself :) I will say, he had to be very structured and disciplined on his very own. He commissioned and graduated with a BS in Mechanical Engineering in May 2021.
Also, USAFA cadets report to their pilot training base quickly after graduation. Not sure if they go on casual duty or go into the next UPT class.
My son did not have to report to his base until March 2022. He got a engineering job for 8 months and also got his private pilots lic. during this time.
As his class went to flight training- he was on casual duty at his base because of his PPL. Another great thing--he learned the base, the surroundings, volunteered recording communications in the tower (which he said was fantastic learning).

Today he just completed his Cross Country and is getting ready for Formation Flying training. (c/o 23-07)
 
I believe there are more pilot slots for USAFA cadets. I think I read that they had more slots then cadets wanting them a few years or go. I may be wrong.
That's current as of this year! Quite a few put pilot as their least preferred option, some even as a joke, not thinking it would happen. Big Blue said they needed bodies in the BUFFs, and it was set, they would be going to pilot training.
 
That's current as of this year! Quite a few put pilot as their least preferred option, some even as a joke, not thinking it would happen. Big Blue said they needed bodies in the BUFFs, and it was set, they would be going to pilot training.
Oh My!!!!
 
I believe there are more pilot slots for USAFA cadets. I think I read that they had more slots then cadets wanting them a few years or go. I may be wrong.
I believe it is higher percentage and not more slots. They have about 1000 seniors vs our 2000 seniors. I think it’s pretty much a 50/50 split for slots. We just have more people that want to be pilots, so lower percentage. I think are seeing about 33% selection rate with percentages rising of people who want a pilot slot.
 
I believe there are more pilot slots for USAFA cadets. I think I read that they had more slots then cadets wanting them a few years or go. I may be wrong.
My son applied to USCGA and wad decline last decision, so accepted his University offer. Orientation day, his first stop was AFROTC table to sign up.....offered a Commanders TYPE 1 sophomore year....offered a pilot slot...etc....
His last year (he had to go 5 due to ROTC)-- I asked him if he was glad USCGA declined him. He said-- YES!!! He got to experience college life with a taste of military. He marched in the marching band (Go DAWGS)--- was an honor guard, and had a small job. He had to experience balancing his life with the college atmosphere. Showing up to PT twice per week at 6 AM being a college student, is not easy in itself :) I will say, he had to be very structured and disciplined on his very own. He commissioned and graduated with a BS in Mechanical Engineering in May 2021.
Also, USAFA cadets report to their pilot training base quickly after graduation. Not sure if they go on casual duty or go into the next UPT class.
My son did not have to report to his base until March 2022. He got a engineering job for 8 months and also got his private pilots lic. during this time.
As his class went to flight training- he was on casual duty at his base because of his PPL. Another great thing--he learned the base, the surroundings, volunteered recording communications in the tower (which he said was fantastic learning).

Today he just completed his Cross Country and is getting ready for Formation Flying training. (c/o 23-07)
Congratulations to your son,That's Awesome! My DS is starting his 1st year of AFROTC at BU, he got the HSSP Type-1, so elated, the AF offered him a 5th year so he can complete his Masters in ME/Aero before he commissions, he definitely signed that deal, he also wants to be a pilot.
 
General comments if your child is interested in a pilot slot

Overall, if able to attend and thrive at the USAFA and you desire to do so, I think it's a more secure path toward becoming a USAF pilot if that is your goal. AFROTC cuts a percentage of participants - each have to be invited to complete their latter years of training. Some reportedly were MIT near perfect GPA with no write-ups. For what that's worth.
1. Confirm what value/ impact having a technical major vs non-technical major has in the choosing of who gets a pilot slot in the USAF, regardless of scholarship. How does that rank? In the Navy, that tier of major matters in service and scholarship selections (though to what extent is a colonel's secret recipe). Does it matter for the AF with service selection? Certainly does for scholarships.
2. Confirm with the school if room/ board/ tuition/ fees will be covered with merit/ aid packages. Probably worth applying to the scholarships and then declining them later if it works out you don't need it/ wouldn't pocket money if you had both (in Navy, my DS actually gets paid to go to college between NROTC and other scholarships - he gets a check every semester that more than covers his apartment/ food. It's not a bad position to be in. Certainly better than paying 16k a year for 4 years for room and board, which was an option if he had gone to other schools.
3. (Broken record from other posts) I recommend getting a Class 1 flight physical by a physician who does these for the military, early if you want to fly to understand if there are any conditions that would preclude your child from flying for the military or airlines.
4. If your son does go the AFROTC route, AFROTC now do offer upperclassman I think 4,000.00 now for private flight instruction. Take advantage of it and you could use that for continued flight or for hours towards that rating boost. My son is a flight instructor and several of his students are AFROTC, getting their hours toward this goal.
5. Why not pursue other branches too if the goal is to serve and fly - Army, Navy. Every year top ranked/ seemingly perfect on stats alone candidates are here shaking their heads that they did not get a scholarship or SA appt - it happens, may wish to cover your bases.

Good luck and thank you for your service.
 
Congratulations to your son,That's Awesome! My DS is starting his 1st year of AFROTC at BU, he got the HSSP Type-1, so elated, the AF offered him a 5th year so he can complete his Masters in ME/Aero before he commissions, he definitely signed that deal, he also wants to be a pilot.
Boston U or Baylor?
 
I'm a father of three AFROTC kids who passed on the academies but as I understand pilot slots, there is more opportunity by attending USAFA. Others here can discuss that in more detail.
As for other areas, your son should tour the Academy and colleges. ROTC will offer a more normal college life (e.g., going out for pizza at Midnight, more time out of uniform, have a job on campus, full summers off - though ROTC offers great summer programs such as Project Go, etc.). It also offers the student a chance to socialize and hang out with a diverse group of students including those who aren't ROTC. My kids all had/have ROTC friends and non-ROTC friends. Having said that, we see more and more normalcy in cadet life with our sponsored cadet and our friends' sponsored cadets. Once they have access to a ride, they are away almost every weekend (skiing, hanging out at sponsor's homes, renting Airbnbs for parties) - our cadet eats out more often than our kids do at a regular college. :)
There are also some life skills learned via ROTC - our kids worked, created a budget, paid rent and utilities, searched for off campus housing, had to buy groceries and cook, etc.
Both routes are good for the right personality. My oldest thought he wanted USAFA but after going on a college tour for Spring Break. My youngest probably would have chosen USNA but he wasn't notified until he'd committed to a university and cadre and gotten excited about it. Taking your son to visit schools is a great tool, and a really fun way to hang out with your son for a week.
Good luck!
Given that you are both a cadet sponsor and father of 3 AFROTC - This is super helpful. Thank you! I remember my days of going on every weekend ski trip available and sleeping in late at my sponsors house. I have been curious how the times may have changed (after all, it was pre cell phone).
 
I believe there are more pilot slots for USAFA cadets. I think I read that they had more slots then cadets wanting them a few years or go. I may be wrong.
My son applied to USCGA and wad decline last decision, so accepted his University offer. Orientation day, his first stop was AFROTC table to sign up.....offered a Commanders TYPE 1 sophomore year....offered a pilot slot...etc....
His last year (he had to go 5 due to ROTC)-- I asked him if he was glad USCGA declined him. He said-- YES!!! He got to experience college life with a taste of military. He marched in the marching band (Go DAWGS)--- was an honor guard, and had a small job. He had to experience balancing his life with the college atmosphere. Showing up to PT twice per week at 6 AM being a college student, is not easy in itself :) I will say, he had to be very structured and disciplined on his very own. He commissioned and graduated with a BS in Mechanical Engineering in May 2021.
Also, USAFA cadets report to their pilot training base quickly after graduation. Not sure if they go on casual duty or go into the next UPT class.
My son did not have to report to his base until March 2022. He got a engineering job for 8 months and also got his private pilots lic. during this time.
As his class went to flight training- he was on casual duty at his base because of his PPL. Another great thing--he learned the base, the surroundings, volunteered recording communications in the tower (which he said was fantastic learning).

Today he just completed his Cross Country and is getting ready for Formation Flying training. (c/o 23-07)
Dawgs? = UGA?
 
Congratulations to your son,That's Awesome! My DS is starting his 1st year of AFROTC at BU, he got the HSSP Type-1, so elated, the AF offered him a 5th year so he can complete his Masters in ME/Aero before he commissions, he definitely signed that deal, he also wants to be a pilot.
That is FANTASTIC! Congratulations to him! ROTC and labs pushed my son into 5 years. Last year was gravy though.
 
I'm a father of three AFROTC kids who passed on the academies but as I understand pilot slots, there is more opportunity by attending USAFA. Others here can discuss that in more detail.
As for other areas, your son should tour the Academy and colleges. ROTC will offer a more normal college life (e.g., going out for pizza at Midnight, more time out of uniform, have a job on campus, full summers off - though ROTC offers great summer programs such as Project Go, etc.). It also offers the student a chance to socialize and hang out with a diverse group of students including those who aren't ROTC. My kids all had/have ROTC friends and non-ROTC friends. Having said that, we see more and more normalcy in cadet life with our sponsored cadet and our friends' sponsored cadets. Once they have access to a ride, they are away almost every weekend (skiing, hanging out at sponsor's homes, renting Airbnbs for parties) - our cadet eats out more often than our kids do at a regular college. :)
There are also some life skills learned via ROTC - our kids worked, created a budget, paid rent and utilities, searched for off campus housing, had to buy groceries and cook, etc.
Both routes are good for the right personality. My oldest thought he wanted USAFA but after going on a college tour for Spring Break. My youngest probably would have chosen USNA but he wasn't notified until he'd committed to a university and cadre and gotten excited about it. Taking your son to visit schools is a great tool, and a really fun way to hang out with your son for a week.
Good luck!
Had to take a quick moment to say this is a really nice post. Really well said.
 
Back
Top