A discussion about submariners šŸ¬ āš“ļø

Interrupting this thread of great stories asking for advice on how to get where you all are. DS is sitting on the waitlist of his top 2 plans Nuclear Engineering/submarines, USNA and U Mich( has the NROTC scholarship). He has a solid high school resume and is concerned he will not be able to top it with leadership and extracurricular roles at a plan C college while waiting to reapply next year. Currently in hand, needing a decision soon, 2 out of state universities, USAFA, USMA, potentially enlisting Navy. He has not visited any of his current options. He knows if he chooses the other academies, Subs will be off the table. If he chooses another college, he feels it will be difficult to top his high school application. Can you offer parental or professional advice as he sorts through options this week?
He should transfer his NROTC scholarship to a school that he has gotten into if he doesnā€™t think heā€™ll make it off either waitlist. He can also go to his in state school and then do OCS after he graduates from there (but I would really do NROTC over OCS just because he already has NROTC scholarship). There are multiple ways to become a submarine officer. I wish your DS the best of luck!
 
Interrupting this thread of great stories asking for advice on how to get where you all are. DS is sitting on the waitlist of his top 2 plans Nuclear Engineering/submarines, USNA and U Mich( has the NROTC scholarship). He has a solid high school resume and is concerned he will not be able to top it with leadership and extracurricular roles at a plan C college while waiting to reapply next year. Currently in hand, needing a decision soon, 2 out of state universities, USAFA, USMA, potentially enlisting Navy. He has not visited any of his current options. He knows if he chooses the other academies, Subs will be off the table. If he chooses another college, he feels it will be difficult to top his high school application. Can you offer parental or professional advice as he sorts through options this week?
Has he reached out to the unit at Michigan about his waitlist status? They may be able to provide some guidance. If he doesn't get off either waitlist (I really hope he does!) enrolling at the plan C college and doing well while reapplying seems like the best path if he is set on subs. Just based upon the forum posts from this cycle, many reapplicants were successful.
 
He should transfer his NROTC scholarship to a school that he has gotten into if he doesnā€™t think heā€™ll make it off either waitlist. He can also go to his in state school and then do OCS after he graduates from there (but I would really do NROTC over OCS just because he already has NROTC scholarship). There are multiple ways to become a submarine officer. I wish your DS the best
Thank you. He is checking into it, of course, unfortunately we think he may run into the problem others on the forum have had, the NROTC program at the school being capped and not being able to transfer a scholarship. We were really pulling for plan A or B and now it's crunch time. Good luck to you smokey%.
 
He could also try and become a college programmer if he cannot transfer the scholarship. I would expect he would earn a scholarship as a college programmer especially if he earned a 4 year one in HS.
 
Interrupting this thread of great stories asking for advice on how to get where you all are. DS is sitting on the waitlist of his top 2 plans Nuclear Engineering/submarines, USNA and U Mich( has the NROTC scholarship). He has a solid high school resume and is concerned he will not be able to top it with leadership and extracurricular roles at a plan C college while waiting to reapply next year. Currently in hand, needing a decision soon, 2 out of state universities, USAFA, USMA, potentially enlisting Navy. He has not visited any of his current options. He knows if he chooses the other academies, Subs will be off the table. If he chooses another college, he feels it will be difficult to top his high school application. Can you offer parental or professional advice as he sorts through options this week?
The part I will speak to, is that ā€œtopping his college resumeā€ may not look like what he thinks it does. He will be taking plebe like courses, and rocking them. Being a good NROTC student, stepping up where he can to lead. Being someone professors and company officers want to support and recommend. VS joining more clubs, doing more service hours, etc. IOW, having a successful NROTC/academic year will go far in reapplying.

Collegiate success looks different than HS success. Just by the nature of what it is. Plus he will have another nom source, if he does well freshman year.

Another add, is he may THINK he wants subs/nuke, but through a 4 yr journey, he may change his mind. Or, potentially not get selected for nuke. Being open to the journey, he may decide nuke isnā€™t his thing. Or? He may confirm that it is. Itā€™s common for a student to change their mind. Even multiple times.
 
Has he reached out to the unit at Michigan about his waitlist status? They may be able to provide some guidance. If he doesn't get off either waitlist (I really hope he does!) enrolling at the plan C college and doing well while reapplying seems like the best path if he is set on subs. Just based upon the forum posts from this cycle, many reapplicants were successful.
Thank you. He said he reached out to admissions right away notifying them of a scholarship, I believe it was after that that he was waitlisted. I've gotten the impression, hopefully incorrectly, that admissions isn't very supportive of having any ROTC programs on campus. Thank you for your feedback, it can't hurt to reach out again. I've heard nuke school is difficult to get into, if he couldn't even make the cut at the admissions level, I wonder if I should try to guide him into another service and career path. Personally, I can not imagine wanting to be on a sub. You all are something.
 
Thank you. He said he reached out to admissions right away notifying them of a scholarship, I believe it was after that that he was waitlisted. I've gotten the impression, hopefully incorrectly, that admissions isn't very supportive of having any ROTC programs on campus. Thank you for your feedback, it can't hurt to reach out again. I've heard nuke school is difficult to get into, if he couldn't even make the cut at the admissions level, I wonder if I should try to guide him into another service and career path. Personally, I can not imagine wanting to be on a sub. You all are something.
Curiosity: what is his exposure to subs? Where does his desire come from?
 
The part I will speak to, is that ā€œtopping his college resumeā€ may not look like what he thinks it does. He will be taking plebe like courses, and rocking them. Being a good NROTC student, stepping up where he can to lead. Being someone professors and company officers want to support and recommend. VS joining more clubs, doing more service hours, etc. IOW, having a successful NROTC/academic year will go far in reapplying.

Collegiate success looks different than HS success. Just by the nature of what it is. Plus he will have another nom source, if he does well freshman year.

Another add, is he may THINK he wants subs/nuke, but through a 4 yr journey, he may change his mind. Or, potentially not get selected for nuke. Being open to the journey, he may decide nuke isnā€™t his thing. Or? He may confirm that it is. Itā€™s common for a student to change their mind. Even multiple times.
I'm glade you chimed in, I always llvalue your advice. I agree with you on EVERYTHING in the last paragraph, that's where I find it hard to give advice. He has excellent opportunities available at the USAFA and USMA, but not subs. Choosing one of those, is closing the door on the thing he has worked so hard for.

On the first part, he has worked so hard already and somewhere fallen short. He had 3 noms and the door is closing by the academy. Do you know if admissions will let him know where he has fallen short?
 
Don't want to misrepresent, but my son did not select subs. I think this past year 3 of his classmates were selected (1 was drafted). Of those 3 only 1 was an engineering major. Justdoit19 is 100% correct that kids will change their minds, more than once, about where they want to end up. They'll learn a lot over their 4 years. My son was selected for the IW community, but would have loved SWO as well. His summer cruises taught him a lot.

Rather than reaching out to admissions have him get in touch with personnel at the Michigan unit about that waitlist status. Good luck to him!
Thank you. I will!
 
@TIME2GO my best advice (as the girlfriend watching the selection for nuke school process and prep for the interview many, many moons ago) is get good grades in math and physics classes, regardless of major. What he's accomplished prior to starting college won't matter too much except for good study habits and a propensity to be successful in those subjects. Hubs was a history major and was asked why should he be selected for a nuke program. He said something along the lines of 'I will still receive a bachelor's of science from the Naval Academy and have maintained As in all of my math and science classes.' That pretty much sealed the deal.
 
Curiosity: what is his exposure to subs? Where does his desire come from?
šŸ˜†, you've got me! I wouldn't be caught dead in one of those and don't love the idea of having a child on one. He is an intelligent kid with a desire to serve. He got As in both honors and AP Physics, U of MN AB Calc, AP BC calc and ran out of advanced courses at his high school. He's been interested in nuclear energy for a number of years but it wasn't until he researched college in 10th grade that he discovered the Naval Academy and decided that was where he was going.
 
I'm glade you chimed in, I always llvalue your advice. I agree with you on EVERYTHING in the last paragraph, that's where I find it hard to give advice. He has excellent opportunities available at the USAFA and USMA, but not subs. Choosing one of those, is closing the door on the thing he has worked so hard for.

On the first part, he has worked so hard already and somewhere fallen short. He had 3 noms and the door is closing by the academy. Do you know if admissions will let him know where he has fallen short?
My kiddo worked REALLY hard on aviation. The right clubs, mentors, academics, summer trainings, leadership billets, ECAS. I get it. Some of his drafted buddies had dreamed of aviation wind a young age. Come from military aviation families. Butā€¦ā€¦.guess what. Needs of the Navy superseded his 4 yrs of work.

Point is, the door may be closed FOR him, on his dream ā€˜that he has worked so hard forā€™. Maybe you could ask him what his choice would be if he didnā€™t get subs? Although, imo, that community seems to always need people and odds are, if he wants it and has the right qualifications, he would get it.

Personally, Iā€™m a ā€˜bird in the handā€™ kind of person. I would work the ā€˜sure thingā€™ angle. No matter where he chooses he. Has some time to figure out if itā€™s a good fit, or not (2yrs at a SA, 1 via ROTC). My guess is he would find a good fit anywhere. He doesnā€™t know all the opportunities available to him, anyplace.

As far as where he is lacking? No idea. He may not be lacking anywhere, but someone else edged him out. Itā€™s the nature of how the SA process works.
 
@TIME2GO my best advice (as the girlfriend watching the selection for nuke school process and prep for the interview many, many moons ago) is get good grades in math and physics classes, regardless of major. What he's accomplished prior to starting college won't matter too much except for good study habits and a propensity to be successful in those subjects. Hubs was a history major and was asked why should he be selected for a nuke program. He said something along the lines of 'I will still receive a bachelor's of science from the Naval Academy and have maintained As in all of my math and science classes.' That pretty much sealed the deal.
Being the wife of a submariner cannot be easy. I appreciate your insight and it is a breath of fresh air. As a parent it is a reminder and a pause. Everything he has achieved in HS won't matter moving forward anyway. The new goal prove that you can continue to excel under new challenges moving forward. Thank you.
 
If I understand correctly, his choices are USAFA, USMA and civilian college with NROTC scholarship. He needs to ask himself what matters most -- being a commissioned officer, a commissioned officer in the Navy, a commissioned officer in the Navy who drives subs. The common denominator among his current choices is commissioned officer.

He should ask himself where he'd be happier if he doesn't get his first choice. Unfortunately, things can happen, whether in or out of his control. He should also ask himself where he could see himself veering should he change his mind about subs. Cadets/mids change their MOS preferences as much as civilian students change their majors.

Finally, I don't understand what you mean about Plan B or C schools not being a good place to strengthen his case. The informed advice here on SAF is that reapplicants should take a plebe-like schedule (calculus, chemistry, English, all at minimum freshman levels) and excel. Also be an ROTC stud and make a leadership impact. None of that is unavailable at a school deemed lesser than Michigan. I don't believe USNA admissions considers perceived prestige when assessing reapplicants.

Bottom line: Figure out the primary goal. Then pursue the option that gets him there. And a bird in the hand... šŸ˜‰
 
I've heard nuke school is difficult to get into, if he couldn't even make the cut at the admissions level, I wonder if I should try to guide him into another service and career path. Personally, I can not imagine wanting to be on a sub. You all are something.
Navy Nuke power is difficult to get through but for an Engineering Major with decent college grades, especially Math/Eng grades, it is generally not too hard as in request it and you get it at Service Assignment or even before the actual Service Assignment since Nuke Power gets to "Advance Select" candidates ahead of the other warfare communities.
 
Interrupting this thread of great stories asking for advice on how to get where you all are. DS is sitting on the waitlist of his top 2 plans Nuclear Engineering/submarines, USNA and U Mich( has the NROTC scholarship). He has a solid high school resume and is concerned he will not be able to top it with leadership and extracurricular roles at a plan C college while waiting to reapply next year. Currently in hand, needing a decision soon, 2 out of state universities, USAFA, USMA, potentially enlisting Navy. He has not visited any of his current options. He knows if he chooses the other academies, Subs will be off the table. If he chooses another college, he feels it will be difficult to top his high school application. Can you offer parental or professional advice as he sorts through options this week?
Something to add to his research list, designed for people who know they want to be in the nuclear program, the NUPOC path:




There are NUPOCs at the top engineering schools in the country. Two samples among many:



And an unofficial blog:

As @MidCakePa noted above, identify the primary goal. There is more than one path to nuclear submarine service.
 
Last edited:
If you have any decent kind of grades in college (especially math and physics), you probably have an excellent chance of selecting subs. My DS went subs out of USNA with a history major and was allowed to early select (March of 2/C year). The most important factors (as a non-engineer major) were math and physics grades and ACT/SAT for math (which at first seems odd but probably is a good indicator of ability to quickly produce answers). At power school, it's all about the math (apparently not all that much is calc but some is) and ability to quickly memorize and retain for a couple of weeks. DS says that ability to memorize and parrot back is absolutely essential - with retention. NROTC and NUPOC/OCS students can do well at power school. Whether you're an engineer grad or a basket weaving grad seems to have little to do (except indirectly) with success at power school. Being unafraid to approach instructors in protype is a big factor for success there (i.e., social skills) - this is apparently an issue for a several in the nuke pipeline.
 
Being the wife of a submariner cannot be easy. I appreciate your insight and it is a breath of fresh air. As a parent it is a reminder and a pause. Everything he has achieved in HS won't matter moving forward anyway. The new goal prove that you can continue to excel under new challenges moving forward. Thank you.
My 18yo son wants to fly fighter jets so believe me when I say as a parent, I get it. For some perspective, my dad, brother and husband have a combined 57 years in the sub force. I grew up with all the stories, some scary, some not. But never was I so worried about hub's safety as when he was assigned to an aircraft carrier passing through some risky waters near enemy territory in a hot political climate. They are SO good at what they do, how they train, how meticulous they check and double check every step, that it all felt much safer to have him hidden below the surface. And I look at his classmates who became Marines, and all that their wives went through in the early 2000s. Man, that I don't think I could do. It's all where you become comfortable I guess. Also fun fact - if you're worried about radiation exposure, they wear a device on their belts that monitors exposure. A summers day at the beach yields quite a bit more than a long time on a submarine.
 
Being unafraid to approach instructors in protype is a big factor for success there (i.e., social skills) - this is apparently an issue for a several in the nuke pipeline.
FACTS! My husband went on to be a prototype instructor and this was definitely something he dealt with - sailors and officers!
 
If I understand correctly, his choices are USAFA, USMA and civilian college with NROTC scholarship. He needs to ask himself what matters most -- being a commissioned officer, a commissioned officer in the Navy, a commissioned officer in the Navy who drives subs. The common denominator among his current choices is commissioned officer.

He should ask himself where he'd be happier if he doesn't get his first choice. Unfortunately, things can happen, whether in or out of his control. He should also ask himself where he could see himself veering should he change his mind about subs. Cadets/mids change their MOS preferences as much as civilian students change their majors.

Finally, I don't understand what you mean about Plan B or C schools not being a good place to strengthen his case. The informed advice here on SAF is that reapplicants should take a plebe-like schedule (calculus, chemistry, English, all at minimum freshman levels) and excel. Also be an ROTC stud and make a leadership impact. None of that is unavailable at a school deemed lesser than Michigan. I don't believe USNA admissions considers perceived prestige when assessing reapplicants.

Bottom line: Figure out the primary goal. Then pursue the option that gets him there. And a bird in the hand... šŸ˜‰
Thank you. Yes, that will all be on the table for discussion this weekend. I'm not sure I probably conveyed myself with plan B/C. Mich has a strong math and science program that has been proven to send kids to Nuke School (or so I've been told).

Throughout high school, DS has excelled in at min Freshman level courses. AP English/language, UofM Literature, UofM Writing, AP History, AP Statistics, UofM Calc, AP BC Calc, AP Biology, Honors Physics, University Physics plus a handful of HS engineering courses.. ACT junior year 34. Math 35. He did not take it senior year. I have no doubt he has the ability to excel in college courses. It's finding leadership opportunities while in college he's worried about. It has been pointed out however that ROTC will provide opportunities for leadership.

I have seen forum users on their 3rd go at the Academy, so I know there is no guarantee. I don't want him to choose a school that he won't be happy with if round 2 passes him by.

I agree with the bird in the hand!

 
Back
Top