How did the one guy who didn’t get selected take it?
Better question how does a college student not pass the AFOQT
The cadet who didn't get selected was actually a 250 who was on the mediocre/average side. I'm not in that class so I haven't talked to him about it, but I've heard he's not trying for a 500 year.
Out of the other five or six cadets that didn't get nominated, we had two that couldn't pass the AFOQT and two that got medically DQ'd for one reason or another. As for the rest, I don't know what their story is, but they probably just didn't meet the minimum requirements. I know this because our Commander has adopted the philosophy that if you have a pulse and meet the minimums, he's going to nominate you.
Since I've been in ROTC, I've known five cadets that failed the AFOQT both tries, so it happens more than you would think. Typically they just get caught up on one section of it. Personally, I didn't find it too difficult. I studied for about an hour total and scored in the 60s and 70s on everything. I don't know whether it's the time pressure or just poor test taking skills, but it does happen.