Nomination/Athlete
First Congrats on Nomination. You say you are pretty sure you are academically qualified. If you got a decent SAT or ACT and good grades in high school you should be. You say you have been recruited by the football team. Did you make an official visit? If so did the coach say they wanted you.
If he said he wants you and you committ there, the Director of Intercolligate Athletics sends a letter to your Senators and Congressman telling them you are a recruited athlete. We were told that the Director would send a letter and this was confirmed by our congressman. As for athletes getting special treatment, I think if you meet all of West Points requirements, Test scores, GPA, Physicial fitiness test etc then you are Ok. Usually coaches know when they recruit an athlete that they are qualified. We submitted everything to the coach before we even committed. Hope this helps. Let me know.