My DD recently improved both her SAT scores to 1290 (ENG 650 & MATH 640) from 1190 (ENG 650 & MATH 54P). Her ACT went up to 31 (READ 35, ENG 32, MATH 27, SCIE 28) From 28 (READ 30, ENG 32, MATH 24, SCIE 28). She reached out to her RC, which had told her to take them again. Once she received her new scores she reached out to him and he asked for her log ins to both and to send pdf to someone specific at USMA. She then asked him her chances and this is what he sent her: " You have done an amazing job on improving your file. You have obviously put in hard work and are very determined. I hope that it works out to where you are able to earn an appointment this year since I think you will make a solid cadet and great officer for the Army. I will continue to vouch for you and hope it can help result in an offer. I don’t know at this time for sure but I think you have a 50/50 shot right now. Have a great day." My DD has never recieved a 3Q letter or been told anything about NWL. Can anyone weigh in on this? Who actually makes the decisions of an appointment and does the RC vouching help? If so, how much?