Hi!
I can completely understand how you feel and the desire you have to redo this and to win. I was in your shoes...okay, in 1978. I still remember the disappointment, anger, and then this burning resolve to say "oh yeah, well...I'll show you!" And I did.
How? You need to focus your attack. Okay...so...this time it didn't work. Don't know yourself out trying to figure out "that one thing..." as it'll drive you crazy and you'll probably be wrong. Instead, focus upon the goal: obtain an appointment. Okay, how do you do that? You convince USAFA/RRS (that the admissions directorate) that YOU are the one they missed, that they WANT you, they NEED you. How do you do that?
First...go to school. Mirror your schedule to that of a doolie. Go on the academy website, do a little digging, and you will find the curriculum guide. Mirror your year in school to that of the first-year cadet. Take the hard classes. And excel in those classes. The BIG question the academy application is trying to answer is: will this candidate physically and academically SURVIVE doolie year and the ensuing three years after that? They don't know...so they use the CFA, your GPA, SAT/ACT scores, letters, DODMERB, and then they GUESS. Well, okay, Dr. Phil would disagree with that; he'd say "I have a fabulous success model and if the candidate fits, then they'll most likely do fine."So your job is to prove him wrong, in your case.
Slam the freshman courses! Crush the CFA, you completely control that. Consider retaking the ACT; perhaps take the SAT as well. STUDY FOR THEM!!
No guarantees...but if you approach the selection board with a "typical first-year cadet" academic load, a GPA in the 3.XX+ range, great fitness scores, etc...etc...well, you've taken the guesswork out of it, haven't you?
That'd be what I'd do.
Oh, FYI, I had a candidate this year that did precisely that. He received his appointment about a week ago.
Steve
USAFA ALO
USAFA '83