recruited athlete ???

Auggie

Member
Joined
Mar 21, 2021
Messages
39
I am hoping to receive some clarification on recruited athletes. My DD filled out the "recruit me" form on the webpage and then went to Bears Day. While we were there, she was able to meet the coach. After meeting the coach in the morning, she was invited to go and watch a practice that afternoon. The coach talked to her for a bit during the practice and asked her some questions and showed her around. The coach told her to come to a meet the next day and to stay in touch with him to update him on her how her seasons go ( high school and private club teams). So, they emailed back and forth on occasion over the next year. She attended AIM and he came a talked with her a there. After AIM, he emailed her and said if she could have her application ready by October 1st to let him know, which she did. He stated that he would be on look out for it so he could add an "athletic potential report" to her file that would be supportive and give a push towards an appointment on her behalf.
I am not clear if this is what "recruiting" looks like if you are not given a LOA or if this just means that if she would be able to join the team if she receives an appointment.
If anyone is able to clarify for me, I would appreciate it. Thanks!
 
Joined
Jul 17, 2020
Messages
232
This is not specific to the USCGA

Yes this is what recruiting looks like for many who apply to a SA. The coach may put a check mark in your application. Even though the coach may have never seen your S or D play. Kind of a walk on potential. And that can make the difference when your S or D is being compared to a few dozen with similar test and gpa scores, who do not have that check mark in their application.

Then there are the players the coaches have scouted and have come after and called and just like any other major college program would recruit for sports. It’s a full court press no different than a big 10 school might do.

The first is helpful and can separate your application from others.

The second one is way beyond helpful. At worse it should be a ticket to prep school


I have no idea how the USCGA or MMA would look at this compared to D1 programs like Army AF Navy where my experience has been.
 

Korab

Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2017
Messages
846
I am hoping to receive some clarification on recruited athletes. My DD filled out the "recruit me" form on the webpage and then went to Bears Day. While we were there, she was able to meet the coach. After meeting the coach in the morning, she was invited to go and watch a practice that afternoon. The coach talked to her for a bit during the practice and asked her some questions and showed her around. The coach told her to come to a meet the next day and to stay in touch with him to update him on her how her seasons go ( high school and private club teams). So, they emailed back and forth on occasion over the next year. She attended AIM and he came a talked with her a there. After AIM, he emailed her and said if she could have her application ready by October 1st to let him know, which she did. He stated that he would be on look out for it so he could add an "athletic potential report" to her file that would be supportive and give a push towards an appointment on her behalf.
I am not clear if this is what "recruiting" looks like if you are not given a LOA or if this just means that if she would be able to join the team if she receives an appointment.
If anyone is able to clarify for me, I would appreciate it. Thanks!

This is not specific to the USCGA

Yes this is what recruiting looks like for many who apply to a SA. The coach may put a check mark in your application. Even though the coach may have never seen your S or D play. Kind of a walk on potential. And that can make the difference when your S or D is being compared to a few dozen with similar test and gpa scores, who do not have that check mark in their application.

Then there are the players the coaches have scouted and have come after and called and just like any other major college program would recruit for sports. It’s a full court press no different than a big 10 school might do.

The first is helpful and can separate your application from others.

The second one is way beyond helpful. At worse it should be a ticket to prep school


I have no idea how the USCGA or MMA would look at this compared to D1 programs like Army AF Navy where my experience has been.
As @Small Team Bacsi says, this is an example of soft recruiting. The more traditional type is where the coach asks for a commitment from the player, and fully supports their application through the admission process. USCGA recruits just like the big 3. The coach can support the application or not, and if they support it, they let admissions know whether the individual is a program altering player, a difference maker, or someone who will be just a team member. Obviously, the coaches evaluation on program impact dictates how much of a boost their application receives. At USCGA, the coaches have a limit on how many applications they can support, so some kids may not get support but are welcome on the team if they get in. Generally, if you have to question whether you are recruited or not, you aren’t. Coaches make the kids who are being recruited well aware of that fact.
 

Auggie

Member
Joined
Mar 21, 2021
Messages
39
As @Small Team Bacsi says, this is an example of soft recruiting. The more traditional type is where the coach asks for a commitment from the player, and fully supports their application through the admission process. USCGA recruits just like the big 3. The coach can support the application or not, and if they support it, they let admissions know whether the individual is a program altering player, a difference maker, or someone who will be just a team member. Obviously, the coaches evaluation on program impact dictates how much of a boost their application receives. At USCGA, the coaches have a limit on how many applications they can support, so some kids may not get support but are welcome on the team if they get in. Generally, if you have to question whether you are recruited or not, you aren’t. Coaches make the kids who are being recruited well aware of that fact.
Thanks! The coach did tell her he is supporting her application through turning in a supportive / positive athletic potential report to give her application a push to receive an appointment. So we had assumed that meant that she is being recruited, especially based on other communication they have had over the last year. However, I started really questioning that when I read about recruited athletes receiving LOA. I appreciate your response.
 

Auggie

Member
Joined
Mar 21, 2021
Messages
39
This is not specific to the USCGA

Yes this is what recruiting looks like for many who apply to a SA. The coach may put a check mark in your application. Even though the coach may have never seen your S or D play. Kind of a walk on potential. And that can make the difference when your S or D is being compared to a few dozen with similar test and gpa scores, who do not have that check mark in their application.

Then there are the players the coaches have scouted and have come after and called and just like any other major college program would recruit for sports. It’s a full court press no different than a big 10 school might do.

The first is helpful and can separate your application from others.

The second one is way beyond helpful. At worse it should be a ticket to prep school


I have no idea how the USCGA or MMA would look at this compared to D1 programs like Army AF Navy where my experience has been.
Thanks for your reply! Anything to give a boost to the application is a good thing!
 

USMA97

Member
Joined
Nov 21, 2021
Messages
10
Also, I believe there was/is a spot on the application to indicate if you are a recruited athlete. The coach will definitely let you know if to mark that on the application.

The athlete should be able to ask the coach as well where he or she ranks on the coach's recruitment list. I would assume there are discussions outside of normal academy stuff the player and coach are discussing around vision regarding how the player fits in.
 

Sealion II

Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2021
Messages
17
Our recent experience may be helpful to some. My DD was recruited in September of this year to USNA. For the previous 12 months, she sent game film to her preferred list of schools. As a HS Sophomore and rising Junior, coaches are prevented from contact until 9/1 of Junior year. (My understanding is SA can begin contact two months earlier on 7/1. ) Her club coach received outreach from a number of schools.

Navy coach asked her club coach DD's level of interest in USNA. It was one of her top choices. DD received texts from USNA and 9 other schools on 9/1. Most of them were literally at 12:01 AM. She spoke to Navy coach who invited her to come for a school visit. She loved it.

A week of so later she attended a recruit camp at USNA. The following Monday, Coach called her to offer her a spot on the team. DD slept on it, then called coach to verbally commit to play at USNA. She, of course, still has to complete application, get nominated, and secure an appointment.
 

USMA97

Member
Joined
Nov 21, 2021
Messages
10
Our recent experience may be helpful to some. My DD was recruited in September of this year to USNA. For the previous 12 months, she sent game film to her preferred list of schools. As a HS Sophomore and rising Junior, coaches are prevented from contact until 9/1 of Junior year. (My understanding is SA can begin contact two months earlier on 7/1. ) Her club coach received outreach from a number of schools.

Navy coach asked her club coach DD's level of interest in USNA. It was one of her top choices. DD received texts from USNA and 9 other schools on 9/1. Most of them were literally at 12:01 AM. She spoke to Navy coach who invited her to come for a school visit. She loved it.

A week of so later she attended a recruit camp at USNA. The following Monday, Coach called her to offer her a spot on the team. DD slept on it, then called coach to verbally commit to play at USNA. She, of course, still has to complete application, get nominated, and secure an appointment.
The SAs are all very different from traditional college athletic recruiting. Since essentially everyone is on scholarship there is no LOI, no participation in national signing day, etc.

As original poster mentioned you can verbally commit but it doesn't really mean anything since the the coach can't offer you anything. And coast guard being D3 can't even pay for a recruiting trip whereas the D1 schools can.

The coaches can tell you they are interested, would love to have you play at the academy and they will endorse your application but unlike most other schools this still isn't a guarantee to get in.
 

Korab

Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2017
Messages
846
The SAs are all very different from traditional college athletic recruiting. Since essentially everyone is on scholarship there is no LOI, no participation in national signing day, etc.

As original poster mentioned you can verbally commit but it doesn't really mean anything since the the coach can't offer you anything. And coast guard being D3 can't even pay for a recruiting trip whereas the D1 schools can.

The coaches can tell you they are interested, would love to have you play at the academy and they will endorse your application but unlike most other schools this still isn't a guarantee to get in.
Service academy recruiting really isn’t that different than regular colleges, and is very similar to the Ivies. Service academy kids still participate in national signing days, buts it’s ceremonial, just like any Division 3 recruit Both the kids and schools want this to happen. It’s good press for the academies’ sports programs.

Verbal commitments don’t mean anything at any school. They are always subject to the kid getting accepted. That bar is just a lot lower at many schools. But if a coach at any school, academy or not, asks for and accepts a commitment, but doesn’t think he can get you in, he will lose credibility really quick- and then good luck recruiting players.

Division 2 and 3 can pay for travel for recruiting visits just like D1.

Recruits at CGA are told it isn’t a guarantee, but coaches have a lot of pull for the kids they really want. They do an academic review of the grades and SAT scores, and they know who they can get in.
 

Pmaclax

Member
Joined
Nov 16, 2021
Messages
34
Our recent experience may be helpful to some. My DD was recruited in September of this year to USNA. For the previous 12 months, she sent game film to her preferred list of schools. As a HS Sophomore and rising Junior, coaches are prevented from contact until 9/1 of Junior year. (My understanding is SA can begin contact two months earlier on 7/1. ) Her club coach received outreach from a number of schools.

Navy coach asked her club coach DD's level of interest in USNA. It was one of her top choices. DD received texts from USNA and 9 other schools on 9/1. Most of them were literally at 12:01 AM. She spoke to Navy coach who invited her to come for a school visit. She loved it.

A week of so later she attended a recruit camp at USNA. The following Monday, Coach called her to offer her a spot on the team. DD slept on it, then called coach to verbally commit to play at USNA. She, of course, still has to complete application, get nominated, and secure an appointment.
USNA can offer a spot during junior year. USCGA cannot. There is a huge line of demarcation between D1 SAs and D3 SAs.
 

Korab

Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2017
Messages
846
USNA can offer a spot during junior year. USCGA cannot. There is a huge line of demarcation between D1 SAs and D3 SAs.
USCGA can, and does recruit on the same timeline as the big three. In fact, they can offer earlier, as the NCAA July 1 (for academies) before junior year restriction on recruiting doesn’t apply to D3. If the D3 school expresses interest, and it’s reciprocal, the dance can start well before senior year. Whether offered in senior year or junior year, whether by USNA or USCGA, the kid still has to get in, but the offers can be made whenever the coach sees fit.
 
Last edited:

Pmaclax

Member
Joined
Nov 16, 2021
Messages
34
USCGA can, and does recruit on the same timeline as the big three. In fact, they can offer earlier, as the NCAA July 1 (for academies) before junior year restriction on recruiting doesn’t apply to D3. If the D3 school expresses interest, and it’s reciprocal, the dance can start well before senior year. Whether offered in senior year or junior year, whether by USNA or USCGA, the kid still has to get in, but the offers can be made whenever the coach sees fit.
When you say offer are you saying athletes get LOA from CGA in junior year or sooner?
 

Capt MJ

Formerly Known As Attila The Hunnette
10-Year Member
Joined
Sep 27, 2008
Messages
12,952
When you say offer are you saying athletes get LOA from CGA in junior year or sooner?
The varsity athletics “offers” are not LOAs from Admissions.

All candidates have to go through the complete application process on the timeline for their class, and be deemed fully qualified. Coaches can start “the dance” earlier than the timeline, and offer assurances of a spot on the team. Those candidates can accept that athletic offer and “commit,” but they still have to meet all Admissions criteria AND be selected by Admissions for an offer of appointment. Just separate the two in your mind. The long pole in this tent is the candidate must be fully qualified with an offer of appointment from Admissions, with possibly an interim conditional offer of appointment pending DoDMERB qualification, regardless of any parallel “offers” from coaches. Coaches have a voice with Admissions to advocate for a recruit.
 

Korab

Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2017
Messages
846
When you say offer are you saying athletes get LOA from CGA in junior year or sooner?
Not an LOA, I’m saying a verbal offer. Are you saying USNA gives out LOA’s to athletes in junior year? I’ve never heard that, and I know USAFA doesn’t. They do give out LOA’s to athletes very early in the application cycle, though.
 
Joined
Jul 17, 2020
Messages
232
Any SA coach that was making verbal offers to recruits , and those offers being accepted, then could not see those kids being admitted to their SA should be fired.

because a SA coach who did that more than once, excepting physical exams etc, would be a coach that could no longer recruit the blue chippers. They would be seen as dishonest and not to be trusted.

once the coach makes an offer and that offer is accepted , that is announced to the sports world by the SA , that commitment is published in sports magazines, and recruiting from other schools comes to a halt.

If the coach makes an actually offer , As opposed to saying they will help push the application with a check mark ,

and that check mark might give you a better edge at being admitted, then they know they can get you in , at least as far as grades and sat s ——at least with prep school as a back up.

And if they are wrong about that then this is a coaching staff not to be trusted.
 
Last edited:
Top