What is the best course of action?

ProudPappa

New Member
Joined
May 2, 2024
Messages
1
My son was is an NROTC recipient. He has been cleared for NSI this summer. Two weeks ago he suffered a dislocated shoulder in a rugby match. After follow-up with the ortho and an MRI, he has an anterior torn labrum. He's scheduled for surgery this coming Monday. That gives him exactly 10-weeks post-op recovery, with physical therapy beginning 3-weeks post-op. We've reviewed the NSI curriculum and requirements. Without knowing how he'll recover or what his physical strength will be in 10 weeks, he'd be able to pass 60% of the requirements. Can we seek a medical waiver for this and he'd be able to maintain his scholarship and complete the other more physical requirements when he's healthier and stronger? His surgeon recommends a he not push his recovery, especially to the NSI level. Your guidance is appreciated!
 
Can't offer perspective on the NROTC approach, but can share our experience with labrum surgery. DS suffered a severe tear playing hockey. Had surgery done by one of the best sports-medicine practitioners around. Recovery was long, with much physical therapy. He wasn't cleared to play contact sports for seven months. Even then, he was a bit nervous stepping on the ice or even just twisting or stretching in a potentially harmful way.

Pushups and pull-ups are obviously a bit different. But definitely manage expectations and beware pushing too hard and too fast. Shoulders are critical in just about every physical activity, and a setback can be worse than initially missing out on some stuff. Best wishes to him.
 
Paging @GWU PNS (emeritus) , one of recently retired NROTC experts, for additional insight.

Has your son called the unit to discuss his changed medical situation? This is the perfect time to become accustomed to working with his future chain of command to resolve issues and determine next steps. He can organize his questions and go right to a primary source.

DoDMERB should also be notified, as they are the information clearinghouse for medical qualifications for the SA and ROTC programs.

These things happen. There is undoubtedly a process.
 
My son was is an NROTC recipient. He has been cleared for NSI this summer. Two weeks ago he suffered a dislocated shoulder in a rugby match. After follow-up with the ortho and an MRI, he has an anterior torn labrum. He's scheduled for surgery this coming Monday. That gives him exactly 10-weeks post-op recovery, with physical therapy beginning 3-weeks post-op. We've reviewed the NSI curriculum and requirements. Without knowing how he'll recover or what his physical strength will be in 10 weeks, he'd be able to pass 60% of the requirements. Can we seek a medical waiver for this and he'd be able to maintain his scholarship and complete the other more physical requirements when he's healthier and stronger? His surgeon recommends a he not push his recovery, especially to the NSI level. Your guidance is appreciated!
If you experience a change in your medical status (such as a new illness, injury, medication, or surgery), between the time of your DoDMERB physical examination and the time of reporting to your ROTC unit, you must alert DoDMERB of this change at 1-800-841-2706 or via email at usaf.usafa.dodmerb.mbx.helpdesk@mail.mil. Alt contact from DODMETS, if you have any questions, please feel free to call CIV Team at (215) 587-9600 or email CIV Team Staff at info@civteam.com

Please contact them directly to confirm your options. If you're seeking an spit-in-the-wind, unofficial opinion/ somewhat educated guess then read on.
Your DS must pass DODMERB physicals/ meet standards to participate in ROTC and activate the scholarship. He does not meet those standards at present. Until he does, he will not activate/ receive the scholarship, and he will not participate in NSI. At NSI, when injuries occur, most of them are sent home that day - maybe a couple stay if they were overheated/ cleared at the hospital, but something like a labrum tear - no, not watching from the sidelines. He's not ready.

Once you report your new surgery, I believe there will be a waiver review/ re-evalation of your status, and that your status will change from approved to DQ'd and perhaps a waiver will be requested. I believe you will not be approved to participate until your recovery is complete and validated. DODMERB is like a big cruise ship - typically doesn't turn swiftly- You should speak to DODMERB/ DODMETS experts directly and confirm your options. Some surgeries have a window of time that has to pass until you can qualify again.

In terms of reporting to NSI, honestly - play the long game here - don't push against medical advice. Best guess - your DS is simply not going to be healed and will not be attending NSI this summer. You should work with your surgeon and team to confirm IF they will be ready for rigorous activity in the Fall, or whether you might need to wait until the Spring to participate actively.

I'm the parent of a DD athlete who underwent Labrum surgery recently. Agree with post above - full recovery has several months. It's not a miniscus surgery that you're good as new a few weeks after an arthroscope procedure. It's a long haul. It would be foolish to push your recovery to try to be active in 10 weeks.

To my knowledge you'll get a waiver if you meet standards and can participate fully. I don't think they'll give you a pass to only participate in some areas. I don't think they'll activate the scholarship until this is resolved. I'm not even sure whether he'll need to reapply after a specific window of time or not - but again, I implore you to talk with DODMETS (and your unit) directly as I'm just a Dad trying to help, not an expert.

Good luck to you and your son. For other readers - this is a great post to read about risks of sports vs bubble wrapping thyself.
 
Great stuff already. My add, is to not beat yourself up about this. As long as he played with eyes wide open, accepting the risk, it’s what it is. Perhaps it will put a delay somewhere, perhaps not. Idk. But don’t spend time second guessing, or having regrets. Time to pivot and adjust.

Good luck to him. And to you!
 
Since the thrust of your question is NSI focused, the correct answer is straightforward......contact the CMGO immediately by email and send them the basic details that there was a shoulder injury requiring surgery. They will likely advise NOT attending NSI since there is some risk to them if they tell you it is ok for him to attend.

Next, inform DoDMERB. And this is where the unit can help.....in particular the correct upload of surgery details, recovery/rehab, and long term prognosis.

Lastly, and I do not know the answer but want you to not be shocked.......there is a chance that the scholarship cannot be activated without completing NSI. I do not know this.....you just need to think through the options.

Not sure if I helped that much.
 
Back
Top