My $1.09 worth (which in AZ will get you an XL Polar Pop at Circle K)...
There's no advantage, in my professional (ALO and high school teacher) opinion to early high school graduation. What's the positive benefit/gain? You might meet all your district/state graduation requirements but do you "fill all the squares," that the colleges/universities that you are interested in, require? If you do, then press on however, if you don't, perhaps a little more thought?
Let's look at what USAFA says on their own webpage in the section: "Academic Requirements."
"
To be academically competitive for an appointment to the Academy, we recommend completion of the following high school courses:
- Four years of English (with a college preparatory class in writing)
- Four years of math
Strong background in geometry, algebra, trigonometry, and pre-calculus
- Four years of science
Lab-based and should include biology, chemistry, and physics
- Three years of social studies (to include a course in U.S. history)
- Two years of a modern foreign language
- One year of computer study"
Now...the first thing to take note of consists of two words: "We Recommend..." We recommend does NOT mean "
we require." So that means that you're not required to meet these guidelines, however, these are the recommendations based upon the past "pass/fail" efforts of new cadets. Those that didn't have this strong background, struggled and many did not succeed. FYI, I'm one of them: I got as far as trigonometry in math...got to USAFA and ran into a buzz-saw called "Math 131: Integral and Differential Calculus." LONG story short: at the end of the year, I finished with an "F" in the class and met an academic board for "consideration for dismissal due to academic failure." I don't advise that to anyone.
The second question is really related to the overall question: what is the benefit of early graduation? Again
using my experiences only, "early graduates" in high school have typically been students that: "wanted to take a gap year and either travel or work" or "were VERY academically superior" and were bored in HS AP/Honors classes and had early admission to college. I flew with a guy in the AF like that: he graduated high school at 16, finished his bachelors' degree at 19 (and AFROTC) but had to wait until he was 21 for his AF job. Now, I understand, they can commission younger but...I digress...so during his wait he completed a master's degree in his field. FYI, he's now a Ph.D. professor at one of the Senior Leadership Schools (National Defense University, War College, etc.).
Okay, if you've read this far...I think you have to really ask: is early graduation to my benefit? That's really the question, IMHO. If you have a goal, a target in sight, and early graduation helps ensure success, then it probably is to your advantage. If, however, you don't and are just interested in early graduation, maybe take a look at taking some "dual credit" classes or even taking a split-schedule of high school classes and classes at a local community college. This could help "prove" to any SA that you're college material (here are my grades in college English and Math, taken while I was also attending high school; hence, I can multitask).
Again, this is just my opinion. However if I were your ALO, these are the things I'd be asking you.
Steve
USAFA ALO
USAFA '83