Character Review Committee

USNA2025Prospect said:
Now do I have a chance based off the offense in question? I won't say much about the details but I can say that I was only suspended from school; I would be ten times more worried had we been talking about a criminal charge.
Click to expand...

Nobody can tell you the outcome. Even if you disclosed all details, each case is evaluated on its own and all you could get is individual opinions.
I have never sat on a Character Review Board, but suspect there are many factors involved - including the nature of the offense, the punishment, likelihood of reoccurrence (did you learn your lesson ?) , accepting responsibility, etc.

None of us are perfect; many of us are products of the mistakes we have made along the way. It's what we learn from the mistakes that is important.
 
Look at it as an opportunity, at least you have a chance to explain yourself. If you weren't interesting to Admissions they would probably not bother. Think of all the applicants who get rejected with strong files and no history of bonehead moves that don't get another chance to show who they really are.
 
USNA2025Prospect said:
That's exactly why I'm scared. This is just additional baggage.
Click to expand...
The SA has noted your baggage, but they are also looking at everything else you are. They will not be surprised by anything. Take some comfort in that.

Every choice we make in life has its initial consequences, and there are often secondary and tertiary consequences that impact us later in unexpected ways.

This is either going to be a body blow which will actually teach you a life lesson about choices and inner fortitude, and coming back with resiliency and determination to forge a new path (because not getting into USNA is truly not the end of the world) - or - it will be a blessed relief to know you made it out of this self-dug hole, are once again back on track, and you have learned a life lesson about choices, judgment, and striving to keep your moral compass properly aligned.
 
USNA2025Prospect said:
That's exactly why I'm scared. This is just additional baggage.
Click to expand...
I’m just a mom so my opinion means nothing in terms of SA appointment. However, please keep your head up. We all have baggage, some heavier than others. Using your metaphor, this is your opportunity to take that suitcase from where it’s been sitting, unpack it, and get it put away where you don’t have to trip over it or even look at it anymore. As others have said, take heart that they want to take a closer look at you despite a past mistake of some sort. Stay positive and think of this in a hopeful light.
 
Have you already had your BGO interview? Seasoned BGO’s will have better insight into this, but if so, I wouldn’t expect a call as a BGO. This is USNA’s admissions process. They are wanting additional info beyond your application and interview.

Unless you lied to your BGO, imo, I dont think you need to call them at this point. Let the process work itself out. It’s between you and the character review board at USNA.

All you can do at this point is trust the process. Let it work Itself out. It’s an important skill to be able to relax and not obsess over things. Whatever is going to happen, will happen. It’s out of your control.

BTW, I guarantee, the outcome will be better than it would have been had you lied initially. It’s important to be able to do the right thing. Even when it’s the hard thing. Kuddos to you for you honestly in the first place. I’m sure that is looked upon favorably by the committee.
 
Last edited:
I was under the impression that BGOs have access to candidates essays. So if OP has mentioned about the incident in essay, this would have been bought up during interview.
 
txfwindian said:
I was under the impression that BGOs have access to candidates essays
Click to expand...
No.
We have far less information on Candidates than you may think.

justdoit19 said:
Have you already had your BGO interview? Seasoned BGO’s will have better insight into this, but if so, I wouldn’t expect a call as a BGO. This is USNA’s admissions process. They are wanting additional info beyond your application and interview.
Click to expand...
Yes,

There is no duty to disclose or discuss with your BGO. If it make you feel better to get his/her insight, by all means make the call. However, it is unlikely the BGO has any more insight into the Character Review Board than anyone here, and unless you he/she knows you well, I wouldn't expect them to get involved as an advocate for a Candidate.
 
this was covered a few years back in onsite BGO training. they detailed the process and who it involved. BGOs do in fact get involved sometimes but not always. depends on what it is that they are looking into

if they need any info from your BGO, they will make that request, you have no obligation to inform anyone.
 
justdoit19 said:
Have you already had your BGO interview? Seasoned BGO’s will have better insight into this, but if so, I wouldn’t expect a call as a BGO. This is USNA’s admissions process. They are wanting additional info beyond your application and interview.

Unless you lied to your BGO, imo, I dont think you need to call them at this point. Let the process work itself out. It’s between you and the character review board at USNA.

All you can do at this point is trust the process. Let it work Itself out. It’s an important skill to be able to relax and not obsess over things. Whatever is going to happen, will happen. It’s out of your control.

BTW, I guarantee, the outcome will be better than it would have been had you lied initially. It’s important to be able to do the right thing. Even when it’s the hard thing. Kuddos to you for you honestly in the first place. I’m sure that is looked upon favorably by the committee.
Click to expand...

He never asked anything about a disciplinary record.
 
justdoit19 said:
Sometimes I think candidates and parents, new to USNA, think they have to be perfectly perfect, exceptionally exceptional, best of the best to receive an appointment. Not true!! They are looking for candidates that can become future Naval or Marine Officers. Leaders. Imo, people who have struggled, failed, learns and grown have an edge. It’s even a focus of the essay. USNA knows kids mess up. They don’t expect perfect little angels.
Click to expand...

Agreed, for all SAs. I will admit I was shocked to hear that my son's CVW host was arrested at the very end of his senior year of HS, yet still had his slot at I-Day mere weeks later. I was like, how can that happen? I had never heard of USNA's CRC until now, so I guess this guy was a real stud in all other aspects! So you can even get in with an arrest, which was certainly news to me.

USNA2025Prospect said:
I just didn't want my BGO to get any surprise about that and hear from them first.
Click to expand...

That is the right attitude. You are on the right path my friend. All great advice above and I hope it goes well for you!
 
parentalunit2 said:
I will admit I was shocked to hear that my son's CVW host was arrested at the very end of his senior year of HS, yet still had his slot at I-Day mere weeks later. I was like, how can that happen? I had never heard of USNA's CRC until now, so I guess this guy was a real stud in all other aspects! So you can even get in with an arrest, which was certainly news to me.
Click to expand...
Being arrested does not equate to being found guilty. And being found guilty is different depending on whether it was a misdemeanor or a felony. I don’t know the circumstances of this case, obviously, but I highly doubt being a “real stud in all other aspects” would compensate for being found guilty for anything but the most minor misdemeanor.
 
Hey there,

I see there is already a lot of really great information posted by other very knowledgeable people on this thread. I just want to add that I'm currently in the class of 23' and I had to go through the Character Review Committee when I applied because I was suspended in high school. I got in trouble with stuff regarding having e-cigarette stuff on me in school. The process was not that bad they will send you a list of like 10-15 questions for you to answer about what happened. My biggest recommendation is to answer everything as upfront as possible and explain how you have learned and grew from the experience. Do not withhold anything and be as honest as possible. What did you do as a result? How did you work to remediate yourself? That's really what they're looking for and do not be discouraged that you have to do this. They easily could've just rejected you outright. I don't know your background but I wasn't a super star athlete (didn't have a 4.0, did not get LOA) so there is hope for you! Feel free to PM me to talk more about this!
 
SAProspect said:
Hi all,

I was just contacted by admissions regarding a Character Review Committee and that my record was referred to this Character Review Committee? I really want to ask how this would work and how much of a shot do I got after this and how badly this would mess me up?

Thanks a lot
Click to expand...
Did you ever end up getting into the service academy you were interested in? I also just received a character review comittee notice, and since this thread was around three years ago, I was curious what came of your case.
 
JayCavet said:
Did you ever end up getting into the service academy you were interested in? I also just received a character review comittee notice, and since this thread was around three years ago, I was curious what came of your case.
Click to expand...
Thr OP is probably long gone.

Each case is looked at according to policy, precedent. needs of the Navy and specific case details. You may or may not be asked for additional info. They make a decision, and Admissions lets the candidate know. If it is unfavorable, then I believe the application process ends. Or it could be favorable, and the candidate’s application is still viable. There is no way to know except wait it out and continue to tend your alternate plans.

One way to look at this is whatever your case involved (not asking), you are getting an early and useful life lesson in learning choices not only have immediate consequences, but often secondary and tertiary consequences. Going forward, your ability to include risk analysis in your decision-making will be more informed.
 
JayCavet said:
Did you ever end up getting into the service academy you were interested in? I also just received a character review comittee notice, and since this thread was around three years ago, I was curious what came of your case.
Click to expand...
A buddy of mine had a character review committee and he got in. They just want you to explain something in your application, just be honest and do the right thing.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top