I understand your point but I was responding to this postbut there are plenty of stories where people get denied and no waivers are given after mutliple medical reports are sent in refuting the original diagnosis. Either the people at DoDmerb dont care, dont know how to read a medical report or possibily did not receive the refuting medical reports in the (military) format that would be recognized as a clear indication that the original diagnosis was wrong.
I'm not here to defend DODMERB, but I would be careful about anecdotal reports. Medical records are confidential and complex. The fact someone tells you: "This is what happened" doesn't mean it happened exactly that way. There may be parts to the story that the person doesn't know or isn't telling you.
When my DD had problems with DoDmerb. We contacted DoDmerb directly. DoDmerb Director contacted us the next day. His statement to us was "We are not here to keep them out we are here to get them in". Submitted the required remedials and DQ was removed. Deal with them directly first and save the money. They were great. It cost a doctor bill but no where near the cost of a consultant. Did cost some postage though.
If the negative stories I hear are anecdotal, so are the postive stories. I am sure there are plenty of people who work it out themselves. There are plenty of plenty who dont. That was my only point